Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Second Section) of 15 November 2017

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Second Section) of 15 November 2017. resolves an almost Solomonic case concerning applications for authorisation for two adjoining gaming halls, or at least separated by a distance shorter than that permitted between premises of this kind under the Basque Country Regulations on Gaming Machines and Gaming Halls (250 metres radially, 400 metres linearly).

The two entities with mutually incompatible premises submitted the so-called “feasibility enquiry” on the same day, 15 February 2013, and both received a favourable response (that, as at that date, there were no premises at a distance shorter than that specified in the regulations). Thus, the first to submit an application for authorisation, following notification of the response to the enquiry, was the one ultimately granted authorisation, as it had priority in processing under the Common Procedure Law.

Despite the submissions of the entity whose application was refused, the request for an enquiry cannot be regarded as an “application for authorisation” (although this was subsequently argued), and once the first has been processed, the second can no longer be processed.

This judicial decision is probably the cause and reason why some subsequent Regulations on the Authorisation of Gaming Halls (e.g. the recent regulations in Andalusia) expressly provide that the issuing of a “favourable” report in these feasibility enquiries is regarded as an “application for authorisation”.

More publications