Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Section 2) of 29 January 2018
·
The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Section 2) of 29 January 2018 rules on the validity of the Planning Regulations applicable to Bilbao’s Old Town, among which the distance restrictions between premises of different kinds, such as hospitality premises (between 25 and 40 metres) and gaming halls (100 metres), were challenged.
As regards hospitality premises, it concludes that the planning restriction is justified on various grounds firmly based on prior studies and documentation. The key legislation applicable to distances between establishments is Directive 2006/123, and its subsequent transposition into Spanish law by Law 11/2009, and although it does not generally permit restrictions or limitations of this kind on the freedom to conduct a business, the grounds set out in Articles 40 and 56 of the aforementioned European legislation for an exception (protection of the environment and the urban and rural environment) are present; in this case, these are based on overriding reasons relating to the public interest and, at the same time, on the legitimate interests of local residents.
As regards gaming halls (and other establishments also subject to restrictions), this exception cannot be applied, given that the grounds for the restriction are purely economic. The Court therefore annuls the provision imposing it, noting, in the case of gaming halls, that the General Gambling Regulations themselves impose more restrictive distance requirements in this regard.