Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Castilla y León in Valladolid, (Administrative Chamber in Valladolid, Section 1), of 20 October 2016)
·
The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Castilla y León (Administrative Chamber in Valladolid, Section 1) of 20 October 2016 examines the challenge to Decree 28/2015, of 24 April, which amended various aspects of the Regulations on Amusement and Gaming Machines of Castilla y León. It first dismisses a plea of formal invalidity based on the allegedly insufficient or incorrect explanatory report accompanying that provision. It also dismisses the allegation of supposed arbitrariness, or lack of necessity, and the possible infringement of the Law on Market Unity (LGUM), since the technical regulation of server-based machines was specifically included in a Document prepared for the Gambling Policy Council on the Regulatory Rationalisation Programme issued pursuant to the LGUM. Furthermore, the judgment emphasises that, although the regulation of these machines is not mandatory, they are a reality that requires regulation, and it has been considered appropriate for the Administration to establish their technical requirements; moreover, they will cause no economic harm either to the Administration or to undertakings in the sector. There can be no question of a breach of the LGUM, since that legislation does not require uniformity of regulations and, furthermore, these are a category of type B gaming machines which will coexist with those known to date, each operator being free to choose one or the other. Finally, these types of machines may be regarded as falling within those envisaged as type “B” machines under the Gambling Law of Castilla y León, since their defining characteristics under Article 18 of the Law remain unchanged.