Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia. (Contentious-Administrative Chamber, Fifth Section), of 15 December 2017

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia. (Contentious-Administrative Chamber, Fifth Section), of 15 December 2017.declares Decree 97/2014, which regulates the EAJA’s so-called Binjocs Lottery, null and void. Thus, for the third time, the regulation of these \»Binjocs\» games, operated through a central server and terminals installed in gambling premises, which the Generalitat relaunched in 2014, is annulled; the rights to these games belong to the EAJA, the public body with monopoly powers to offer “lotteries”, although their management has been granted to a private entity.

The Court holds that it is contrary to law for the Autonomous Community’s administration, through its public undertaking, to extend the monopoly to these games, because, rather than lotteries, they are similar to the game of bingo (hence their name: “binjocs”) and, in fact, include and permit both symbols relating to that game and other, different symbols.

The tripartite Government of Catalonia first promoted this product in 2006, and the same Court which annuls this Decree annulled, three years later, the Decree regulating it, as it did not comply with several provisions of the legislation governing the subject matter. That judgment was upheld by the Supreme Court.

In 2010, the tripartite government approved another, almost identical Decree, but in 2012 the High Court of Justice of Catalonia again declared it null and void, on the grounds, among others, that insufficient reasons had been given for it. That annulment judgment was also upheld by the Supreme Court (TS).

Once again, the Generalitat, this time under CC, approved the 2014 Decree, and the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC) considers that the Generalitat’s extension of lottery gambling to the \»Binjocs\» variant is not duly justified, which alone would, according to the Chamber, lead to its being declared null and void.

Furthermore, the judgment adds that \»Binjocs\» is a game \»with its own distinctive characteristics\», whose \»basic logic\» resembles plena or bingo, and therefore cannot be regulated as a lottery variant, the management of which does indeed fall exclusively to the public administration.

For that reason, the Chamber considers it unjustified to restrict competition from private operators in the management of \»Binjocs\» and declares the Decree null and void.

In its judgment, the TSJC also recalls that, in other Autonomous Communities, such as Andalusia or Aragon, electronic games similar to bingo are regulated within the scope of the Gaming Machine Regulations, a privately managed activity which cannot be subject to a monopoly. In this regard, the Chamber refers to the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (TJUE), which establishes that activities consisting of offering users the opportunity to participate, in return for remuneration, in a game in which money may be won \»are regarded as the provision of services\» which makes it very difficult to establish a regime of intervention, let alone a monopoly over such activities. In this respect, according to the TJUE, legislation of a Member State which limits the possibility of offering lottery games or games of chance \»may constitute a restriction on freedom of establishment and the freedom to provide services\», unless there are grounds of public interest.

Although an appeal in cassation was lodged against this judgment, the Supreme Court has refused to admit it and the judgment has consequently become final.

More publications