Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (Administrative Chamber, 5th Section, of 17 May 2018

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (Administrative Chamber, 5th Section, of 17 May 2018
partially upholds the challenge concerning two aspects of Decree 163/2015, which made specific amendments to the Regulations on Gaming Machines and Gaming Halls in Catalonia.

On the one hand, it dismisses the challenge brought against the renewed inclusion of a regime restricting authorisations for gaming halls in Catalonia on the basis of a minimum distance of 1,000 metres from another authorised gaming hall. Whereas on previous occasions the Court had annulled this restriction (on procedural grounds relating to the adoption of the Decree, or for lack of sufficient reasons), in this case it declares it valid on account of the extensive reasons stated in the provision itself. Furthermore, as regards the infringement of the freedom to conduct a business enshrined in Article 38 of the Spanish Constitution (CE), alleged by the claimant, the Court holds that “in a business sector such as gambling, administrative powers of intervention and control are amply justified by the interests underlying it”, relying on certain judicial precedents concerning restrictions on casino authorisations.

On the other hand, it declares Article 27.2 of the Regulations on Amusement and Gaming Machines, which is also amended by this Decree, null and void insofar as it again provides that the installation of type B gaming machines in hospitality establishments must be restricted to a single operating company in each bar, although the regulations permit two machines to be installed. The main reason for adopting this provision was to remove the reference to type “A” machines that could be installed on such premises, but the amendment to the text reiterates the “exclusivity” of type “B” operators that had already been declared null and void in judgments 831/2015 and 832/2015 concerning challenges to the previous text. The High Court of Justice recalls that this nullity was declared on the grounds set out in the Report of the Legal Advisory Commission of Catalonia, as the restriction had no statutory basis and could not be linked to the statutory principles governing the Catalan Government’s planning intervention in gambling.

The Court determines that, although appeals in cassation have been lodged against the aforementioned earlier judgments annulling the provisions, it must again annul those provisions which reiterate the same restriction, for consistency and coherence with its rulings.

However, while all the foregoing is true, it is also true that, subsequent to the earlier judgments, another provision, having the force of law, was adopted, incorporating this restriction into the text of the Gambling Law in Catalonia through Law 5/2017, of 28 March. This circumstance was probably not pleaded by the parties for reasons relating to procedural timing, and the Court did not take it into account, since otherwise it would have altered its decision, as the statutory basis whose absence had been criticised was now established.

More publications