Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid (Administrative Litigation Chamber, 10th Section), of 22 February 2018
·
The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid (Administrative Litigation Chamber, 10th Section), of 22 February 2018 upholds the fine of 150,000 euros imposed on the operator of the Bwin brand by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (D.G.O.J.) for a serious infringement of the Gambling Law, on this occasion for having accepted players’ bets on “in-play” events using funds derived from winnings obtained in other events of this type, which was classified under Article 40(a) as a breach of “the requirements and conditions laid down in the authorisation and, in particular, the duties of control to ensure the security of gambling.”
In particular, the Order governing this “in-play” fixed-odds sports betting, Order EHA/3018/2011, provides in Article 12 a detailed description of the sources of funds that the gambling operator must accept, and operators may only accept those funds that the participant held in the gambling account “at the time when the sporting event on which bets will be placed begins”. This means that if the gambling account holds, for example, 100 euros at the start of the event, this is the maximum stake that the operator could accept; and if it holds no funds, the participant cannot bet (this is what is stated, in a circumlocutory manner, in the second paragraph of this article). Funds won in that same in-play sporting event may also be used, but not those won in others. Nor may the participant place bets using new deposits, which is what occurred in the facts of the case file, over an unspecified period which the judgment does not detail.
The Court links this breach to a more general duty of online betting operators, namely compliance with the responsible gambling policies also included in the Gambling Law in relation to the protection of players and consumers, given effect through various preventive measures and other express rules such as limits on deposits and participation in gambling (in general, Article 8 of the Gambling Law). These are policies with which the operator undertakes to comply upon obtaining the licence.
On this point, as the judgment expressly states,
“The limitation on the amounts of money to be used in in-play fixed-odds sports betting falls within the regulation of responsible gambling, designed to protect the player. The characteristic of this type of betting is that bets are placed while the event on which the bet is based is taking place. It is evident that the course taken by the event will influence the likelihood of success of such a bet, which will directly affect the player’s state of mind, and the player may be inclined to increase the stake as the prospects of winning increase, even though they remain uncertain until the event ends. Precisely in order to prevent impulsive actions by players which undoubtedly undermine responsible gambling, the quantum of bets is limited and, for good reason, is fixed at the balance available to the player before the event in question begins. Bearing in mind that the Law on the Regulation of Gambling (LRJ) itself lists its objectives in Article 1, there is no difficulty in concluding that its purposes include both the prevention of addictive behaviour and the safeguarding of participants’ rights. Furthermore, Article 8 stipulates that responsible gambling policies entail approaching the conduct of gambling activities through a comprehensive corporate social responsibility policy that regards gambling as a complex phenomenon in which preventive, awareness-raising, intervention and control measures must be combined, together with measures to remedy the negative effects caused. Provision is even made for preventive measures against the possible effects of inappropriate gambling practices, and therefore, all the more reason exists for taking that purpose into account in intervention and control measures.
Accordingly, the foregoing demonstrates the importance of limiting the amounts to be staked in this type of betting, the purpose of which is to protect the player and even to prevent addictive behaviour. In any event, it constitutes one of the measures for the protection of participants provided for by the legislation in force, which are explicitly envisaged in obligation k) set out in the \»Terms and conditions of the general licence\». Its application also promotes responsible gambling behaviour and therefore, all the more reason exists for bringing it within the scope of that obligation k).”
Although this procedure for controlling the acceptance of bets is technically complex to implement, the Court considers that its absence constitutes an infringement, and that this is consistent with the principle of legality in the imposition of penalties. Finally, it finds no grounds for reducing the amount of the fine, nor for classifying the infringement as minor.