Tax & Private Clients
Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Murcia (Administrative Chamber, Second Section) of 22 February 2018
·
The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Murcia (Administrative Chamber, Second Section) of 22 February 2018 annuls the tax penalty imposed in tax penalty proceedings arising from a personal income tax (IRPF) inspection report which determined that prizes from draws organised by O.I. D (Organización Impulsora de Discapacitados) are taxable as gambling winnings and do not benefit from the exemption which the Law grants to ONCE and SELAE lottery prizes (an exemption which applies until 2011, since from 2012 prizes are subject to tax above EUR 2,500).
As it is obvious that these winnings are taxed in the ordinary manner, and the exemption cannot be extended to these unauthorised draws, the taxpayer agreed to the amount of tax due in the initial inspection report. However, the taxpayer challenged the justification for the penalty for the infringement.
The Court considers that there is no culpability in this case, since the winner of the draw invoked the presumption of legality of these draws, as they coincided with ONCE draws, and because the Tax Agency had not included any reference to the inclusion of this prize in the successive IRPF “draft returns” requested by the taxpayer. The Chamber considers that the “popularity” of these draws in 2009, and the correspondence between their tickets and draws and those authorised for ONCE, are circumstances which preclude a reasoned finding of culpability.