Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Third Section), of 5 October 2010

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Third Section), of 5 October 2010
recognises the right to a refund of certain amounts of input VAT incurred by a gaming machine operator on invoices issued by the proprietors of the establishments where the machines are installed, and charged in connection with and in respect of the “services provided” by those business owners.

The courts differ in their interpretation of the legal relationship in these cases involving the operation of machines in hospitality establishments, as most accept an initial interpretation by the Tax Agency that these constitute supplies of services and are therefore subject to VAT, and, on the other hand, that the operator owning the machine cannot pass on that amount to end users, since operation of the machines for use by the public is exempt.

However, in the Valencian Community, the former Territorial Court, and now the High Court of Justice, have maintained a consistent line of authority that, at least where the parties expressly agree, as in the case under consideration, these are genuine “joint operation” agreements, and the relationship is therefore a partnership relationship, not subject to VAT. Consequently, the charging of tax on the invoice may be challenged, and a refund is ordered.

It has not been possible to reconcile these differing interpretations owing to the procedural restrictions on access to appeals in cassation, which until recently was highly restricted and available only in cases involving substantial amounts. The new rules governing appeals in cassation have enabled the appeal against this judgment brought by the State Counsel, acting in defence of the State Tax Administration Agency (AEAT), to be admitted, and the judgment is not final.

The High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community has delivered several judgments to the same effect as this one (ordering the refund of numerous items of input VAT), pending judgment in the respective appeal in cassation.

More publications