Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid (Administrative Chamber, Section 10) of 24 April 2017

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid
(Administrative Chamber, Section Ten) of 24 April 2017 upholds the penalty imposed on Electraworks España PLC (Bwin), a fine of EUR 169,805 for a serious infringement of Law 13/2011 on gambling, for having allowed access to gambling activities on its website by persons who were prohibited from doing so because they were included in the Register of Prohibitions on Access to Gambling or were minors.

The judgment examines the mechanics of activating players' accounts and the manner in which the obligation to verify the information provided by the applicant in order to activate them and be able to gamble must be fulfilled, as elaborated in the various regulatory provisions governing the technical aspects of this obligation: both Articles 26 and 27 of Royal Decree 1613/2011 and the Resolution of the Directorate General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) of 12 July 2012. Accordingly, a technical difficulty in complying with the obligation cannot be invoked as a ground for extinguishing liability, nor, consequently, can a breach of the principle of culpability under administrative sanctions law be alleged.

As regards the remaining matters, mitigating circumstances cannot be applied on the basis that the appellant acted in the belief that it was acting lawfully as a consequence of the lack of clarity of the applicable rules; nor can the aggravating circumstances found to exist in the contested resolution be disregarded.

More publications