Gaming & Gambling

Judgments on Online Gambling Taxes: We Were Right

Carlos Lalanda ·

Two recent judgments of the National High Court of 20 April and 15 June 2015 prompt us to revisit a particular tax controversy arising from the first procedure for granting licences to operate online gambling in 2011. The question under debate was whether “.com gambling operators” had defrauded the Spanish Treasury by offering and entering into online gambling and betting transactions with Spanish users before the 2011 Gambling Law. This rhetorical debate reached its peak in mid-2012, when the competitive procedure was open, awaiting a decision, and a large proportion of the applicants were subsidiaries of “.com entities” which lacked a licence in Spain and sought to obtain one. Their parent companies were based in various EU locations with little or no direct taxation of games of chance or betting (chiefly Malta and Gibraltar, or even outside the EU), and some argued that they should pay no tax in Spain on their activities prior to the Law.

ONIF demanded payment of the taxes from the “.com” operators

 At that precise stage of the procedure, several applicant entities (or their parent companies) received requests from the National Fraud Investigation Office (ONIF), warning that, in previous tax years which were not time-barred (namely, 2008 to 2011), their extensive offering to Spanish players had been detected, without payment of the Gambling Tax applicable to these activities in Spanish territory. In other words, the normal course of events: the Office which investigates tax fraud was requesting information from potential tax evaders.

Some of them regarded this request as a form of unlawful coercion imposed as a precondition for the granting of the licences sought, and public statements were made to this effect.  This curious interpretation of the modern tax legal framework (namely, that the Treasury “unlawfully coerces” taxpayers when it demands payment of the taxes they evade) even prompted the Ministry of Finance itself to file a criminal complaint in connection with an article published at the time pursuing that line of defence.

The matter was clear from a tax perspective: the gambling tax (in its two forms, applicable to games of chance and to betting) applied to all activities of this nature conducted in Spain, whether “land-based” or “online”, lawful or unlawful. It was that simple, although it is true, as we have repeatedly pointed out, that the rules governing the so-called Gambling Tax are scattered and not very well organised. It is also true that Law 13/2011, on the regulation of gambling, included certain specific tax provisions for the forms of online gambling which were regulated and authorised from that point onwards.

Finally, and on this we all agreed, the amounts and rates of the Gambling Tax were, and remain, excessively high.

In such an absurd legal controversy, we heard some truly surprising arguments disputing its obvious applicability: for example, that the Gambling Taxes predated the Constitution, or that they had been approved under the Franco regime, and so forth.

The tax evaders paid and then challenged the payments.

 For one reason or another, those who received the requests agreed to pay “voluntarily” (or to file late returns without payment, as the case might be), and subsequently challenged them……. Until we come to the National High Court judgments, in 2015.

At the time of these events, certain media outlets estimated at 200 million euros the amounts “voluntarily” paid by these entities to regularise their position in respect of the Tax, although other data put estimates of the tax actually evaded at more than 1,000 million euros overall, according to calculations based on the actual volume of unlawful gambling between 2008 and 2011, and including all forms of tax evaded, not merely the Gambling Tax.

The judgments delivered by the Court “vindicate” those of us who argued, on technical grounds and in the context of that controversy, that fraud had occurred and that ONIF's action to secure the necessary regularisation was lawful and legitimate. Particularly when viewed from the perspective of businesses in this sector operating lawfully in Spain (whether Spanish or foreign operators), which were paying an annual average of 1,500 million euros into the public coffers in respect of the aforementioned Gambling Tax alone.

The judgments discussed affirm and reiterate the obvious: that liability to the Tax was proper, that the tax-evading entities sought to regularise their tax position for the years which were not time-barred (2008 to 2011), and, furthermore, that the surcharges and interest imposed by the Administration because the payments were late were also proper.

 Outstanding questions

To the foregoing must be added certain questions which remain unanswered 3 years later:

  1. Did the tax administration carry out any investigation into taxable events, or did it accept without question the returns submitted by the tax evaders? Let us recall that there was no “amnesty” prompting the late payments which would have prevented a subsequent assessment.
  2. did the tax evasion give rise to any form of competitive “advantage-disadvantage”  between gambling businesses, those that paid taxes and those that did not?

As these questions are not answered in the judgments discussed, we shall have to await further news to enlighten us.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Loyra Abogados

Madrid, 19 October 2015.

Article also published in the leading industry magazines: Sector del Juego,El Recreativo

More publications