Gaming & Gambling

The “liquidity” of games of chance under scrutiny

Carlos Lalanda ·

The “liquidity” of games of chance under scrutiny.

After some time, we still have doubts surrounding “liquidity” in games of chance, its concept, its legal framework, regulatory developments, etc., which do not advance while technology progresses.

In previous analyses, I expressed my doubts about the terminology used, which is highly confusing and contradictory, and the existing alternatives of our own, rooted in our legal system.

“Liquidity”=”Common pool”

Rather than “liquidity” (an Anglicism poorly rendered into Spanish), the “common pool” in games of chance is the sum of the bets placed for a single game or draw. The term “common pool” is used in our legal texts to address certain problems arising in “common pool” games, lotteries, football pools, horse-race betting, and even bingo. It can also be used for other, more recently authorised games, such as poker or pool betting.

In general terms, the interest and importance of the “common pool” lie in the amount of the prizes, which are much larger the greater the “common pool”. Unlike games with fixed prizes, or prizes calculated on statistical probabilities, every gambling operator will dream of a large “common pool” of bettors and bets in a single game.

In Spain, one of the draws with the largest common pool of bets is the Christmas lottery draw, el Gordo, although it actually offers a prize that is not linked to the volume of bets placed. Pool betting on football or horse racing is another very popular example of this class of games with a large common pool. In bingo games, the greater the volume of cards sold for the same game, the greater the prize obtained. In poker games, the more players and bets there are, the greater the prize for the winner of the game.

The limits of the “common pool” in games of chance.

The legal problems arising in relation to the common pool of bets do not normally derive from the concept and understanding of the underlying gambling contracts, or from the conflicting interests of operators and players; rather, they derive from the limits of the pool in games, ultimately, how far it can extend, or whether it can be “expanded indefinitely”.

If a game is offered in a particular physical establishment, no such problem exists, since the limit will be determined by the public and the pool within the premises themselves; but this perspective becomes more complicated when the operator can offer the same game or draw in several different premises at the same time, or in several different political territories, or even worldwide. Telecommunications technology has revolutionised the foundations on which the “common pool” of games of chance rests; and we must examine the different levels at which the problem arises.

Taking the Spanish example, we can examine the different levels relating to common-pool games: “multi-premises” games still within a single Autonomous Community; games with a nationwide or supra-Autonomous Community pool, and games with an international pool.

Games with a multi-premises common pool (within the same Autonomous Community).

In this first category, the game or draw takes place through mechanisms situated in different establishments, connected to one another. This is the case with “simultaneous” bingo, or gaming machines interconnected within the territory of the same Autonomous Community, with a common prize.

Under the system for the allocation of powers to intervene in gambling matters, such intervention is vested in the Autonomous Community authorities, which will therefore control the game and regulate the authorisation of gambling conducted in several establishments at the same time.

The fact that the Autonomous Community authorities lack constitutional powers to regulate Telecommunications is no impediment, because the limit lies within the territory of the Autonomous Community.

The only legal problems arising at this level concern the “designation of the operator”, which tends to be the “common organiser” of the games. Although there are examples in which the holder of each establishment contributing to the common pool is considered the “operator”, it would seem more appropriate to regard the operator as the party that actually “has control over the common pool”.

Within this category, problems of restrictions on competition, the authorisation of Autonomous Community monopolies, etc., may also be observed. This category could also include “Autonomous Community online” games, namely those in which all players interconnected via the Internet, Interactive TV, etc., and all located within the same Autonomous Community, can participate in the same game from their personal devices. In this case, there is debate as to whether it is feasible to fragment the reality of the Internet, which is by nature borderless.

Games with a nationwide or supra-Autonomous Community common pool

This second category includes traditional State games and lotteries (now the lotteries of SELAE and ONCE), SELAE pool betting, and “nationwide online” gambling and betting; but it also includes so-called “supra-Autonomous Community” games, which may award accumulated prizes from machines in casinos situated in several Autonomous Communities, or, more recently, bingo games interconnected across several Autonomous Communities, such as electronic bingo.

In the case of lotteries and games authorised for SELAE, ONCE, and nationwide online licensees, there is no problem at all, since the “pool” by definition extends throughout the national territory.

However, when it comes to launching one of the “supra-Autonomous Community” games originating in an Autonomous Community authorisation, we face a genuine problem of a constitutional nature. All Autonomous Communities without exception have incorporated “exclusive competence” over games of chance into their Statutes of Autonomy, which, like other powers, is territorial in nature, so that one Community cannot interfere with the competence of another.

This means that games authorised in one of them cannot be offered or conducted outside its territorial boundaries. Each Autonomous Community thus has, in practice, a limit on the “pool” wagered by players within its own territory.

However, as technology advances, and with it the possibility of increasing the size of gambling pools, it has become necessary to interpret the legal system to reach a solution capable of regulating their growth, but that solution is still far from clear.

Judgment 35/2012 addressed this problem, and the Constitutional Court (TC) decided to annul a statutory paragraph which declared State competence whenever a game extended beyond the territory of a single Autonomous Community. In other words, the typical case in which the “limit of the common pool” was intended to extend across several territories. However, as the Judgment is very confusing and State competence is also maintained where the nature of the offering is clearly nationwide, and in certain other very specific cases, ….doubts remain:

Is an Agreement between Autonomous Communities necessary to introduce games with a pool common to several of them?

What kind of Agreement? One of those regulated by the Law on Common Administrative Procedure (LPAC)? The one described in Article 145.2 of the Spanish Constitution (CE)?

Would it not be more appropriate to provide for centralised authorisation of these games?

These doubts should have been resolved by Law 13/2011 on the regulation of gambling, since, until then, Royal Decree-Law 16/1977, which regulated our games of chance, predated the CE. However, as this was not the case, the problem remains. Only a decisive initiative by the Central Administration, through the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ), on the basis of the recent Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity, could resolve this problem of games with “supra-Autonomous Community liquidity or common pools”.

Thus far, the problem has been provisionally addressed through cooperation “Protocols” signed by representatives of several Autonomous Communities, but without any relevant legal content. These are more akin to “non-aggression pacts”.

Games with an international common pool.

In this category, matters do not fall within the framework of domestic problems concerning the allocation of powers, but rather within that of relations between sovereign States.

As far back as the Catholic Monarchs, attempts were made to prevent Spaniards from entering the “common pool” of certain German lotteries, and until very recently (2011), participation by Spaniards in foreign lotteries was classified as a smuggling offence.

Even with entry into the EU, which entails a certain “surrender of sovereignty” in many economic respects, this matter of games of chance in Europe remains reserved to each Member State, which normally prevents its citizens from participating in games in other States; this is what happens with online gambling, hindering the existence of games with a “European international common pool”[1].

This is the purport of the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), which has held in many cases that there is no legislative harmonisation in this area, and that each State is free to do as it wishes, which normally means preventing (and penalising) its citizens as far as it can when they seek to bet on a foreign operator’s common-pool games.

As matters stand, it is not so simple in theory for a State to admit an “international common pool or liquidity”, as has recently been argued in relation to online games, which have technically made it possible to overcome traditional physical barriers, “customs”.

However, let us consider several cases in which an “international common pool or liquidity” is a reality in Spain, and the doubts raised by its existence:

Euromillones. In 2003, Ley and other national operators in Europe decided to hold a weekly lottery draw, integrating the different national pools into a single common pool. This was made possible following the signing of an Agreement by the managing entities of the various monopoly lottery undertakings in Spain, Great Britain, France, etc. This pact included its specific features, the draws being held in Paris, or a clause under which all parties reciprocally undertook not to accept bets from anyone who was not one of their nationals.

ONCE’s Eurojackpot. A draw of the same type as the one mentioned above, although its participants are not exclusively European. The draw is held in Helsinki. Unlike the previous one, the “Constituent Pact” was entered into by different entities with a legal personality distinct from that of “States”; and in Spain, ONCE was previously empowered by the Council of Ministers in the context of its particular “Concession Agreement”, which governs its general operation.

PMU horse-race betting (Parimutuel Urban, Fr.) offered in the Basque Country (and temporarily in Andalusia). This case is peculiar: the 2005 Horse-Race Betting Regulations allowed the common pool of bets in the Basque Country to be contributed to other operators outside that Autonomous Community. This was interpreted as valid in the case of the well-known French entity. The same occurred temporarily in Andalusia. However, in my view, since this is not generally permitted under the Spanish Gambling Law, it would not be permitted in this particular case either.

Online Gambling. Law 13/2011 on the regulation of gambling in Spain. For this class of games, the Spanish Gambling Law allows operators authorised in Spain to open accounts for foreign players, unlike other legislation, such as that of France. In this way, foreign and Spanish players share, for example, the same bingo game or poker game. This is different from the “common pools” of operators from different jurisdictions being combined in a single game or draw.

The legal problem of contributing common pools or holding games or draws with a common pool shared by Spanish and foreign operators requires one of the following solutions: either the law is amended (by amending Article 9.4 of Law 13/2011, which does not recognise operators authorised abroad), or an International Act or Agreement is signed between the States concerned (subject to the formalities of International Law)

Madrid, 16 June 2015.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández . carlos.lalanda@loyra.com


[1] There is even less room for doubt regarding the “non-European” common pool, since it would not even be possible to invoke any provision of the European Treaties, which many cite as a possible exception to the system.

More publications