Gaming & Gambling
Commissions of LOTTERY POINTS OF SALE. A way to increase them: Sharing the VAT
Carlos Lalanda ·
Meetings between SELAE and the representatives of the Points of Sale repeatedly reveal frustration over a possible increase in the commissions which the latter receive on their sales, something they have persistently requested.
This request is difficult for the operator SELAE to accommodate and accept, since, whether one likes it or not, it has been a business entity since 2102, and any prospect of a response can only be justified by reference to some corresponding economic consideration. Any increase in these commissions would mean an automatic reduction in SELAE's business profits. As stated in the minutes of the most recent meeting between the representatives of both parties, this matter can only be discussed when “realistic and achievable” circumstances arise.
I propose to analyse one such possibility: sharing the VAT currently borne by SELAE on those very commissions of the Points of Sale.
VAT is not neutral for Lottery operators
Sales to the public of lotteries, betting and other games of chance are exempt from VAT in Spain, and the input VAT borne by operators on the goods and services they purchase and pay for cannot be deducted by them; it is not neutral. In SELAE's case, input VAT on invoices for commissions from the Points of Sale alone amounts to more than 100 million euros annually.[1]
However, what would happen if the Points of Sale were improperly charging VAT on their commission invoices to SELAE? In other words, if they were under no obligation to do so? Quite simply, SELAE would automatically obtain an additional profit of 21% of the total of those commissions, since it cannot currently deduct this VAT which it now bears: it is a genuine expense.
This additional profit could be allocated wholly or partly to the Points of Sale without adversely affecting its current operating account.
VAT on the commissions of the Points of Sale: a major uncertainty.
The mechanism used for settling and paying commissions to SELAE's Agents, both Dedicated and Mixed Points of Sale, is currently based on a “reverse” invoicing procedure. In practice, it is SELAE that “settles” the accounts, including a proposed invoice, but in fact it is the Managers of the Points of Sale who are obliged to issue the invoice and charge VAT, and SELAE that must bear it in the settlement. It is then the Managers who pay the VAT to the Treasury quarterly.
As a general rule, where the issuer of an invoice improperly applies VAT, it is the recipient who must challenge it on the grounds of disagreement, something difficult to put into practice when it is the recipient who prepares the settlement … and also includes a proposed invoice with VAT.
In SELAE's case, it seems absurd that the Managers issuing the invoices should have to “draw the attention” of those who must bear the cost of VAT and ask them…. has the settlement been correctly prepared? …or rather, has VAT been correctly applied to the commission invoice?
I shall now proceed to analyse the answer to this question.
The Points of Sale: genuine “agents” of SELAE.
How is the relationship between SELAE and the Points of Sale to be classified?
This is a crucial aspect of the problem, since everything else revolves around it.
Irrespective of the doctrinal constructions advocated on this matter by various authors, the legal contractual relationship between SELAE and the Points of Sale has changed substantially since 2012. Since then, apart from transitional exceptions still retained by some former Lottery Administrations, the relationship between the Operator and the sellers has changed in nature. The former “administrators of lottery and football pools sales” held an administrative concession and therefore there was no commercial contract. They have now become, of their own volition, “commercial managers of points of sale”(dedicated or mixed), who interact with SELAE under commercial law.
How should these commercial relationships be classified? Are they commission agents, agents or distributors? Bearing in mind the differences between these various categories, we are more inclined towards the “agency” framework, although for our purposes, as we shall see below, this makes no difference. The services that are “sold”, or rather “distributed” (lotteries or betting), are provided on behalf of SELAE, which alone is legally authorised to operate them; and this is done on a continuing, independent and exclusive basis, in return for remuneration (a percentage of sales and a percentage of prizes). These features are the basic characteristics set out in Law 2/1992 on agency contracts.
The remuneration received by the Points of Sale is referred to as commissions, relating to sales made on behalf of SELAE or prizes paid in its name. Both are contractually agreed. In other words, at least in the former case, a proportion of the revenue from sales to players. A share of the lottery ticket or one-tenth share of a ticket, or of the football pools entry.
To date, in the settlement proposed by SELAE, and in the invoice it prepares and includes, the agreed commission is increased by 21% VAT, although this is highly debatable, at least from the perspective of European VAT.
The position of CJEU case law and the European Commission
The fact is that the “European tax winds are blowing” towards treating transactions carried out by the sales Agents of operators of a gambling activity which is exempt from VAT at the final stage of supply to the user as transactions likewise exempt from VAT.
This is what is foreshadowed both by a judgment already delivered by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on 14 July 2011 (Henfling case) and by the Working Paper of 31 March 2015[2] prepared by the EU Directorate-General for Taxation and Customs Union (not yet elevated to Commission level).
According to those documents, this is so because agents are merely intermediaries, and intermediation in exempt services is likewise exempt from VAT, as expressly stated by the VAT Directive in the case of insurance (Article 135(1)(a)).
This assertion appears to conflict with the wording of our VAT rules, since, although they provide for the exemption of transactions relating to lotteries, betting and games organised by SELAE (Article 20.One.19 of the VAT Law (LIVA), first paragraph), the second paragraph then states that this exemption “ …does not extend to management services and other transactions of an ancillary or complementary nature which do not constitute the taxable event for gambling taxes…” , although cases in which bingo is managed through “service entities”, which “serve” the actual holders of the authorisation, who are the persons liable for the Levy, are excluded and remain exempt. It should also be recalled at this point that lotteries are not themselves subject to special gambling taxation in any of their forms (land-based or online), and that the reason why the second paragraph (restriction of the exemption) might apply to Managers of SELAE Lottery sales is therefore not readily apparent.
In short, it could quite reasonably be read as meaning that the Spanish Legislature's choice to exempt lottery sales from VAT also includes transactions involving their sale through intermediaries, as is the case with transactions carried out by the Agents or Managers of the Points of Sale.
Uncharted territory in Spanish case law.
The closest issues considered by our Courts concern the VAT treatment of relationships between companies operating type B gaming machines and the hospitality establishments or gaming halls in which they are operated, which is a clear example of an activity subject to the Gambling Levy. It has been held that VAT applies to them (except in certain jurisdictions, such as the Valencian Community, where judgments continue to regard them as associative legal relationships in which there is not, strictly speaking, a “supply of services” between two parties). Even from this perspective, a recent judgment of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia of 19 November 2015 reiterates the majority view that these transactions are subject to VAT, but because machine services in hospitality establishments are ancillary rather than principal. This fact contrasts with the case of Dedicated Points of Sale, which are precisely that: business operators engaged exclusively in selling the services of their principal, SELAE.
The request for a binding ruling from the DGT. The alternative of challenging the invoices of the Points of Sale.
In this context, and assuming that the VAT charged on invoices by the Agents–Points of Sale is improper, who may bring a claim?
There are two avenues, the first being a request for a Binding Ruling from the Directorate-General for Taxation (DGT) of the Ministry of Finance, which has already ruled in a doubtful case in favour of extending the tax exemption, in a clear case of gambling intermediation services not included in the Law, namely the management of “Simultaneous networked bingo” in Madrid (Ruling V0803-06 of 24 April 2006). In this case, any Point of Sale may request the Ruling.
However, a hypothetical rejection of the exemption in the response to the request for a Ruling cannot be challenged before a Court.
The alternative avenue, which may, if necessary, reach the highest judicial bodies, including European ones, involves challenging the invoices issued to SELAE by the Agents or Managers of Dedicated or Mixed Points of Sale, which include, perhaps improperly, VAT on the commission.
Who has standing to challenge these invoices? Their recipient: SELAE itself. It will therefore have to be asked to do so.
Madrid, 29 May 2017.
Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.
Loyra Abogados.
[1] According to SELAE's balance sheets, in 2013 these commissions amounted, including input VAT, to €600.65 million, from which it may be inferred that the input VAT on those transactions amounted to €126.13 million; and in 2014, total commissions amounted to €593.53 million, meaning that input VAT was €124.64 million.
[2]