Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Section 9), of 2 March 2018

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Section 9), of 2 March 2018 upholds the decision of the Regional Economic-Administrative Tribunal (TEAR) of Madrid concerning Gambling Duty applicable to bingo, and in particular the time at which the taxable event occurs in these cases, which coincides with the economic moment at which the game takes place, and not with the “purchase of the cards” which bingo operators formalise at tax offices for subsequent use in games, when they “sell them to the participants”.

For practical reasons of administration, the duty is assessed and paid in advance at tax offices upon the “purchase” of these pre-numbered cards bearing serial numbers, which are subsequently used in games on later dates, depending on player demand.

The issue arose because the tax rate in the Community of Madrid was reduced from 22% in 2010 to 15% in 2011, with the amending provision entering into force on 1 January 2011. The cards “purchased” by the bingo operator in 2010 (paying an assessment at 22%) were then used in games held in 2011 (to which a rate of 15% applied); consequently, the difference between 22% and 15% was considered an undue payment, and a refund was requested. This request had already been upheld by the Economic-Administrative Tribunal, whose decision was challenged before the courts by the Treasury of the Autonomous Community.

This judgment sets out the consistent case law of other Courts of Justice to the same effect, accepting this interpretation both to uphold “upward” assessments (when rates increase) and downward assessments (when they decrease).

This judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid is reiterated by several others to the same effect.

More publications