Gaming & Gambling

Madrid, Mr Cordish and the Marx Brothers.

Carlos Lalanda ·

 One of the best descriptions of the process towards the establishment by Grupo Cordish of a complex with casinos (CID) in Torres de la Alameda, Madrid, called “Live! Resort Madrid”, was provided by Ignacio Ferrer (senior), in one of his latest reports from his vantage point in Valencia: “the Madrid farce”: a theatrical genre of frivolous and absurd comedy distinguished by a set with numerous doors through which the characters enter and leave without pausing for breath. And in that frenzy of entrances and exits, misunderstandings erupt, the grotesque reigns and the audience smiles or splits its sides laughing, depending on the author’s wit.

What follows is not a theatrical review of that process, but merely a commentary, with a legal foundation, on the latest moves by the Community of Madrid (CAM)  and Grupo Cordish following the refusal to process its CID application “in accordance with the Law…”.

Of course, in view of the administrative Resolutions and Press Releases included, concerning the surprising culmination of the process, we can only examine the legality of the proceedings from a “Marxist” perspective (that of the Marx Brothers).

  1. The Resolution refusing to initiate the CID process. (The first and the second, making two). Among many other arguments, the latest Resolution states that the creation of 17,000 permanent jobs is no great thing …… that the Project contributes little in terms of tourism or culture. That the Project does not encompass our most universal heritage, namely flamenco (literally). That an exception to the ordinary regime governing casinos cannot be made for such a meagre proposal (an “exception” that reduces to 10% the excessive levies imposed on casinos in Madrid and other gambling companies, which currently reach 40% or 50% of gross gambling revenue in some cases, ultimately maintaining the “medieval tithe” (my expression) equivalent to some 195 million euros annually). That the Community of Madrid had to guarantee customers’ access to the Complex, and that this entailed expenditure on public infrastructure which had not been fully quantified. In short, a disastrous proposal in the Community’s eyes; and the list goes on ….,… that the beach does not guarantee suitable bathing conditions without a treatment plant, that the animals moving around the area are affected, etc . In summary:
    1. With the first response, back in January, we were facing a problem of “almonds”, since Codish only guaranteed the “central almond” with €600 million in cash up front, it was said (“this Project is the little almond trick”, was the subliminal message).
    2. With this second response, Version 2 of the Project is regarded as little more than bread “crumbs” in  Madrid’s healthy and abundant economy.

In other words, plenty of gastronomy and few weighty legal arguments, since everything is referred back to the “public interest”, that is, I would add, to “indeterminate legal concepts” and to the “spirit of the rules”.

  1. By contrast, Grupo Cordish considers that its Project complies fully with the Law.

Who is right? As an illustration of the divergent positions: at the heavily attended meeting held between the parties on 19 July, according to Cordish “…nobody told them there was any problem….”; according to the CAM, in its Resolution, precisely the opposite (as many as 8 adverse technical Reports). According to both, an office full of people: Deputy Regional Ministers, Secretaries-General, numerous representatives of the Directorates-General,  company representatives……….. In other words, it suggests and brings to mind a universally familiar image:  “the Marx Brothers’ stateroom”. (A scene from “A Night at the Opera”). See accompanying Image.

So far I have said nothing about the Law and the process, as I ought to have done. Let us therefore turn to some genuine legal issues.

Groucho .

This whole affair, and Mr Cordish’s expectations, are based on a Madrid Law of 2012, on Measures (but colloquially known as the “Adelson Law” because Mr Adelson was its “alma mater”), which introduced an exceptional legal regime for Super Casino Complexes in Madrid. This Law (amending the Gambling Law, the Madrid Land Law, various Taxes and Charges,  etc,), was subsequently amended and relaxed by a later law, but in essence, and I agree with both parties, it formally remains in force; nobody has repealed it to date. Although I invite anyone who wishes to read its text, they will encounter something akin to Groucho Marx’s famous phrase: \»The party of the first part shall be known as the party of the first part\», etc. (Once again, a scene from “A Night at the Opera”). A veritable jumble. The Community of Madrid now says that it is in force, but that this is not such a case…… As we know, something like that fits another of Groucho’s famous sayings:  “These are my principles. If you don’t like them, I have others.” Another spokesperson for the Regional Ministry has said virtually this, almost literally, today.

Harpo. The silent brother.

The CAM’s Directorate-General for Gambling has maintained a perplexing position since the original Law of 2012 concerning this exceptional regime,  from the first announcements of Eurovegas, and never made any public statement on its innovations. Some justification was required for the introduction into Gambling Legislation of new provisions such as unrestricted access for minors (when accompanied), the freedom to lend to players, etc, freedoms unknown in the history of gambling Laws in Spain; and, of course, these excesses subsequently provided the impetus for Cordish, in return for so much freedom, to offer…. “the Ratoncito Pérez Museum”, and even a free beach in Madrid…. so that nobody would think that minors would be entering a casino complex to gamble, but rather for these other things…… That said, in a legal pirouette, an article was included under which an Annexe Gaming Room could not be authorised for CIDs.

Now, of all the various Bodies of the Community of Madrid submitting reports (as many as eight), the Directorate-General for Gambling is the only body that has said nothing against Mr Cordish (in other words, nothing at all, meaning that the Project complies with Madrid’s Gambling Law, and there is nothing more to discuss).

Gloria, the wealthy widow Gloria (a character in “Duck Soup”, whom some also regard as a “Marx sister”).

 Alternately insulted and praised by Groucho, the point was that Gloria was wealthy and influential; and she, despite these contradictions, placed her wealth and love at his disposal, and even helped make him President of the Republic of Freedonia.

When Mr Cordish’s representatives arrived in Madrid, it was all congratulations and flattery: joint photographs, talk of Mr Cordish and his Group being worth billions, of one of his sons joining Mr Trump’s Government, etc. In those amusing films, Groucho would flee when it came to getting married, and this character almost always ended up leaving, disillusioned and without a fiancé.

Chico. The brother who knows how to play the piano.

The Law of 2012 bears signatures and endorsements intended to secure Adelson’s success then, …….. but failure today: the signatures were those of Aguirre, Ignacio Gonzalez, and the “guarantors” were numerous . Any step towards implementing this Law must always be taken with the utmost caution; it could be given a double meaning, a hint of suspicion,………. To cap it all, someone then began linking Cordish’s land purchase options to a property consultancy said to keep bad company. In other words, here, in a dreamlike scene, appear “those who play the piano” (that was where I was heading, towards the police meaning of the term: fingerprinting. My apologies to younger readers; this time even Google’s algorithm has been unable to detect what I had in mind).

At this point in the legal examination we must pause and agree with Cordish’s representatives:  if Grupo Cordish is not allowed to carry out this Project, it is impossible for a Cid ever to be granted in Madrid; this is a Law that is a dead letter. Like El Cid Campeador in the final conquest of Valencia (who was “dead, but alive”); but the other way round (a living Law, but dead). In Groucho’s terms, but my own words: “someone forgot to repeal it when Adelson left”

Zeppo. The most serious.

To obtain the grant of a CID, the best course would be to acquire publicly owned land (this appears to be a subliminal message to which some, including the CAM, point). In other words, the same as was done when the Second Casino in Madrid, in Aranjuez, was authorised: to obtain authorisation, it was necessary to purchase a property owned by ARPEGIO (a CAM public company), rescued from a bad debt, at a fixed price of 5,000 million pesetas (not much; the same has now happened in Salou, but for 10 times as much). That was serious:  casino Planning in Madrid was approved, in order to authorise that casino, on a single day in July, without a public hearing procedure. The serious Gallardón now practises as a lawyer in Venezuela.

More wood!!!!.  This is war!!!!

The scene in “Go West”, in which Groucho calls for all the furniture in the railway carriage, and even the carriages themselves, to be burnt in the locomotive’s furnace in order to pursue the fleeing outlaws, is a classic. In Madrid, both sides are invoking a battle in the Courts to defend their differing positions:   “ the war  has only just begun …” (as one party has said in a media outlet). “we shall defend ourselves in the Courts” (says the other).

So we shall see whether someone decides one day that the resolutions are “lawful”, “unlawful”, or, as someone else interjects to split hairs still further, perhaps even “outside the law”. (And that is not from Groucho, Harpo or Chico).

A curious point here. The Adelson Law does not even provide for compensation for application costs in the event of refusal. That was why Adelson, at the time, lodged through the Registry, to keep up appearances,…. a Project (more literary than technical) entitled “A Possible Dream…..”  And nothing more was ever heard of him in these parts.

So rather than following the twists and turns of this matter in the Courts, I suggest spending an afternoon after lunch with a Marx Brothers film.

And I must leave it there for today. So many references to Freedonia and Valencia remind me that it is important to address other matters urgently.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Madrid, 25 July 2017. Feast of St James the Apostle.

More publications