Gaming & Gambling

Law Guaranteeing Market Unity. The Successes and Excesses of the Secretariat of the Market Unity Council

Carlos Lalanda ·

(LGUM: Law Guaranteeing Market Unity)

(SCUM: Secretariat of the Market Unity Council)

Following the enactment of Law 20/2013 Guaranteeing Market Unity at the end of that year, high hopes were placed in the application of this legislation to remove numerous obstacles in various business sectors, including gambling. This has always been a sector constrained by the public administration through its traditional policing powers, often in the context of excessive protection of abstract and ill-defined interests, whose ultimate rationale, the case law reminds us, is the protection of players. It is often said that this is a “highly regulated” sector, although in reality it is rather a sector “subject to extensive intervention”, which suggests different nuances. The distinction is fundamental for the purposes of this analysis, since the overused term “liberalisation” of services cannot have the same implications in sectors such as energy, transport and communications as in others, such as notarial services or gambling. This distinction in regulatory treatment is not one that I make; it is recognised by the Community Directive on the liberalisation of services known as the “Bolkenstein” Directive, which excludes the two sectors mentioned above and certain others from its scope, as confirmed in the Spanish transposing Laws of 2009. In defence of the LGUM, the National Markets and Competition Commission (CNMC) has an “armed wing”, in that it has the power to apply to the courts to seek the revocation of an administrative act or a General Provision, but it is the recently established Secretariat of the Market Unity Council (SCUM) that processes and issues reports on complaints from businesses which consider their activities to be restricted and seek the protection of the LGUM, with such efficiency and speed that its performance is positively astonishing, even during this interlude of “caretaker government. I shall briefly review the Reports issued by this Secretariat concerning the gambling sector, which may be regarded as genuine successes in some cases, but also as excessive in others.

THE GAMBLING SECTOR UNDER THE LGUM'S MAGNIFYING GLASS

Let us first recall the traditional excess of bureaucracy on the part of the public administration in the gambling sector, and the multiplication of territorial rules arising from the constitutional allocation of powers to the Autonomous Communities, which has resulted in a tangle of scattered provisions that sometimes multiply business obligations by 17, the number of Communities with their own separate bodies of administrative law governing gambling. Fertile ground for the application of the LGUM, whose principal objective is the “removal of obstacles and barriers” in business matters, seeking to achieve a general concept that might be understood as “Market Unity”. However, there are unquestionable limitations on the application of this LGUM, because the Constitution has designed a territorially based system for the distribution of powers in which, although the right to freedom of enterprise is clear and the free movement of persons or goods is guaranteed, an area of “exclusive powers” is reserved to the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) into which the State cannot intrude. Particularly illustrative is the image of a senior regional official attending meetings of the Gambling Policy Council brandishing a printed copy of Constitutional Court (TC) judgment 52/88, which recognises the validity of the system for the allocation of powers established in relation to gambling, a doctrine under which the CCAA may regulate virtually all activity in this field within their respective territories where their Statutes of Autonomy so provide, as is now the case in all of them. This premise leads to an obvious reality: very few restrictive rules on gambling can be affected through the application of the LGUM, because this would conflict with the exclusive powers referred to above. It is also true that, a priori, online gambling markets are not affected by the LGUM, since their regulation and supervision are entirely matters for the State.

SUCCESSES OF THE SCUM

Against this background, the SCUM's initial interventions addressed the problem of its application and delineated certain aspects of interest in its first Reports of 2-4-2014 and 21-5-2014. In the first, concerning type approvals, the findings of the Report relating to betting terminals proved somewhat ambiguous, because the matter addressed concerned gambling equipment not clearly specified in the regional regulations. In this initial approach, the conclusion was reached that the restriction imposed by the Valencian Community, through regulations, on the installation of a class of these terminals in certain establishments did not appear to comply with the principles of necessity and proportionality. It also began to distinguish clearly between rules governing intervention in the provision of the service to the user (restrictions on the “exercise” of an activity), which fell within the exclusive powers of the Autonomous Communities, and those constituting genuine barriers to entry into a regional market (restrictions on “access”). This distinction has been and will be fundamental, because it is essentially in the latter that the weight of the LGUM will be much more significant. The second Report mentioned analysed the requirement for prior administrative authorisation in relation to type A machines (without betting), which Catalonia and Galicia still subjected to authorisation at certain stages of their business activity. The outcome was clear and correct: such activities are not excluded from the Community Directives and, consequently, the LGUM applies with the greatest intensity, and within that framework it seems easy to deduce that there are no grounds for imposing a restriction such as administrative authorisation. Lastly, in relation to security deposits for entry in the Regional Gambling Registers, the Reports of 30-10-2015 (Illes Balears), 18-3-2016 (Cantabria) and 11-4-2016 (Galicia) state clearly that, even though this sector is excluded from the application of the Community Directives, the LGUM operates and fully affects even the sphere of regional powers where the restriction impinges upon the constitutional and Community principles guaranteeing freedom of enterprise and the provision of business services. In taking this momentous step, the Secretariat relies on the recent Agreements adopted by several Bilateral State–CCAA Commissions, in the face of the threat of bringing a formal constitutional dispute before the TC (which almost always entails the suspension of the effectiveness of the contested statutory provision). Thus, the Agreements of 23-2-2015. (Asturias), 2-5-2015 (Illes Baleares) and 15-5-2015 (Canary Islands) declared that various restrictions imposed in the respective recently enacted Regional Laws could constitute genuine barriers to business activity and that, on the basis of the LGUM, they should be interpreted differently. Through these Agreements, the first arrangements affected by the LGUM in the gambling sector are multiple entries in Regional Gambling Registers, the provision of multiple security deposits for the registration of businesses, the imposition of “professional cards”, and also, albeit cryptically for the time being, type approvals for gambling equipment.

EXCESSES

However, subsequent complaints to the SCUM have extended to other, hitherto unexplored areas and are therefore probably excessive. The first concerns the imposition of minimum distances between gambling establishments, which many Autonomous Communities require for the authorisation of bingo halls or gaming halls. The Report of 17-7-2015 analyses Decree 55/2015 of the Valencian Community, which increased these minimum distances between gaming halls from 400 metres to 800 metres, a measure which the SCUM and subsequently the CNMC considered contrary to the “principle of necessity” enshrined in the LGUM, as a restriction on freedom of establishment. In this case, the CNMC has initiated legal proceedings and the matter is at the appeal stage. The application of the LGUM in this case seems excessive to me, because this restriction falls within the context of planning the supply of establishments, as recognised by the various Regional Gambling Laws, and although it may be challenged or even declared void, this would certainly not be on the grounds that it falls within any of the situations covered by the LGUM, but for other reasons relating to the formalities and safeguards governing the formal preparation of these general provisions. Thus, several regional Decrees were declared void even before the LGUM existed. Even the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) advocates removing these restrictions on the basis of a direct interpretation of the principles of the Treaty, rather than through their inclusion within the scope of the Directives on Freedom to Provide Services, which specifically exclude activities relating to gambling. Another, more recent Report, of 21-1-2016, concerns the restriction imposed in Galicia on operating betting in hospitality premises, the authorisations for which must involve a gaming machine operator linked to those establishments. In this case, the restriction is clear, but I very much doubt that it can fall within the scope of application of the LGUM, since this restriction operates in the sphere of the “exercise” of the activity, at the stage of providing the service to users, and is therefore a matter for the discretion of the regional legislature, that is, within its exclusive powers; this does not rule out reaching the same conclusion in favour of a challenge as that invoked under the LGUM through other areas of law, such as Competition Law. But not through the application of the LGUM. Lastly, the Report of 19 April 2016 concerning Aragon and the possibility of installing online gambling terminals on the basis of the State Licences granted by the Directorate-General for Gambling of the Ministry of Finance and Public Administrations (MINHAP). This is a Report that clearly exceeds the remit of the SCUM and the LGUM, since, as follows from Law 13/2011 on Gambling, any land-based manifestation of online gambling is subject to the discretion of the regional authorities, which may opt for an absolute restriction or for liberalisation to a greater or lesser extent.

SHORT-TERM TRENDS IN ADDRESSING NON-COMPLIANCE WITH THE LGUM

The action of the SCUM and the CNMC promises to be very vigorous and effective in the forthcoming stages, in the face of widespread non-compliance with the LGUM, both through the failure to adapt regional rules and through the lack of sufficient initiative on the part of the State bodies responsible for driving these changes. But always within those aspects that may be regarded as limitations on requirements for access to the activity, not those which fall within each Autonomous Community's constitutional powers. It is true that some CCAA have protested against what they consider an encroachment on their powers and have even brought constitutional challenges against the LGUM. In such a context, they cannot be expected to be particularly inclined to comply exhaustively with its requirements. Nevertheless, the obligation of the CCAA to adapt their statutory and regulatory provisions persists, even though the period for doing so established by the LGUM itself, six months from its entry into force, has long since expired. Furthermore, the “Sectoral Conference” of the Minister and the Regional Ministers responsible for gambling has never formally met since then, and attempts have been made to assign its role and remit to the Gambling Policy Council established by Law 13/2011. However, this Council lacks the power to approve Agreements, which would be the appropriate instrument for a genuine adaptation of the legislation in this field. Nor have even the Rules of Procedure required by the Law been approved, so the technical efforts undertaken by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling, which acts as the Secretariat of this Council, have remained embryonic and without any real effect. As matters stand today, we face clear non-compliance with the LGUM, of varying degrees and with various examples, and an outstanding task. On the part of both the State and the CCAA.

Madrid. 28 April 2016.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

LOYRA ABOGADOS.

Article also published in CINCO DÍAS and AzarPlus.

More publications