Gaming & Gambling

Minimum distances in the Valencian Community

Carlos Lalanda ·

It must be said that the regulation of the minimum distances applicable to gambling establishments in the Valencian Community has reached intolerable extremes, and anyone following this issue should start complaining.

Whereas the recent Law 1/2020 on Gambling in this Autonomous Community already stipulated, after a lengthy saga, that new gaming halls, betting premises and bingo halls could not be authorised within 500 metres of other gambling premises, or within 850 metres of certain educational establishments, the latest Decree 97/2021, of 16 July (DOGV of 4 August), which implements specific aspects of that Law, devotes Section Three of Chapter I to this issue, setting out in minute detail how these distances must be measured.

One of the articles provided for this purpose concerns the “general conditions for measurement” (Article 10); another the “measurement procedure” (Article 11), the next the particular features of measurements (Article 12), and the last the “representation of the measurement” (Article 13). Quite a record for meticulousness.

All this is undoubtedly important and may have implications and even affect those who already have an establishment open; but it could have been resolved differently, or even dispensed with, in the interests of prioritising other problems prompting the Decree, including the grim consequences looming over the holders of authorisations for establishments authorised some time ago which, owing to the exorbitant and retroactive requirements of the Law itself, now risk being closed “for failing to comply with the distances”. The Decree addresses these other, more or less urgent, problems, to which I shall not refer now.[1]

The recurring issue of minimum distances

 The imposition of minimum distances between business establishments by the various Public Administrations has generated reams of commentary, even in times past. Back in my younger days, some Local Councils passed municipal by-laws prohibiting bars from opening in adjoining premises, or within a few metres of one another, on public thoroughfares; at that time, for obvious reasons, “freedom of enterprise” could not be invoked, nor could many other freedoms.

This issue has always had many facets and attracted interest for different reasons, usually related to competition between businesses, since, when these distances are imposed, it is generally to the detriment of some businesses (new entrants) and to the benefit of others (those already established); most of these restrictions are imposed within the framework of the intervention of Administrative Law in business activity, free competition law, etc.; or have even been incorporated into Planning Law. They have been applied, and disputes have arisen, in many business sectors (e.g. pharmacies); there has been debate over the legislative rank required to approve them, or the Administrations competent to impose them; and they have been examined, and upheld or annulled, by numerous Courts and decision-making or advisory bodies, by reference to the general rules and principles of the Spanish Constitution (CE) and, since accession to the EU, to Community principles concerning the “right of establishment” (of businesses). Recently, it has become common practice to invoke the Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity (LGUM) as a defensive bulwark against the “temptation” to impose, among other barriers working in the opposite direction, a minimum distance (from something) in order to set up a business.

The gambling establishments sector and minimum distances

 Almost all subsectors of gambling establishments have been subject to the constant dynamics of conflict between those wishing to impose some minimum distance and those who do not subscribe to the idea (in the abstract, or in specific cases when it is “their turn”).

Several Autonomous Communities' Gambling Laws incorporate provisions imposing these restrictions, either expressly and directly or by laying down the basis for imposing them, which has generated disputes and litigation of varying significance. Until recently, these minimum distances related to other premises engaged in the same type of business, but minimum distances from educational establishments have begun to be incorporated, with the purported justification of protecting citizens' (mental) health — which some would rather identify as a problem (also mental) afflicting those promoting them.

In the Valencian Community

 In the Valencian Community, the issue is already becoming somewhat suffocating, and has been in vogue for some years. First came the imposition of minimum distances of 800 metres between gambling establishments (Decree 55/2015), which the National High Court annulled in 2018, a decision upheld by the Supreme Court in 2019, and then an attempt to reimpose them by reference to shorter distances, with one Draft even proposing 700 instead of 800 (which is, of course, a difference of 100 metres from the other distance: “to comply with the judgment”, as its Preamble stated).

Finally, in Gambling Law 1/2020, the issue developed into the additional imposition of minimum distances from educational establishments, something that is also gaining ground in other Communities, although in the Valencian Community it takes on a certain dramatic character, with numerous actors (as a drama, tragedy or farce, depending on one's perspective).

During the passage of the Gambling Law, we were able to observe the race among the various groups supporting the regional coalition Government to propose the greatest (distance). The distance between business premises was set at 500 metres, while the distance relating to educational establishments was somewhat more difficult to reconcile. Following the parliamentary debates and amendments to the Law, and various articles in the media, reveals that some set it at 700 metres, others at 1,000. And, finally, the Law approved a distance of 850 metres, corresponding more or less to the arithmetic mean of all the proposals, weighted according to the influence of each within the Autonomous Government. A mathematical solution to a negotiation worthy of inclusion in textbooks.

Article 45 of the Law defined this latter minimum distance, specifying that it was to apply:

  • in relation to educational establishments accredited by the Regional Ministry responsible for Education to provide compulsory secondary education, upper secondary education, basic vocational training courses and professional arts education.
  • This distance restriction does not apply to gambling establishments located outside residential land (which are, of course, very much in the minority)

However, the main drama lies in the fact that, whereas until now these restrictions were approved “for the future”, the Valencian Law, which is indeed pioneering in this respect, provides that they will bear down on all establishments which fail to comply with the distances when their licence comes up for renewal, and which will consequently have to “disappear” or “move elsewhere” (Second Transitional Provision and Tenth Transitional Provision, paragraph 2, of the Law), as though this were as simple as moving a car from one parking space to another on a public road. Even if the educational establishment opened after the gaming hall. This is why the Decree now sets out in minute detail the rules on the manner and procedure for measuring these distances.

The specifications for measuring these distances are little short of exhaustive: they may relate to educational establishments that are open or closed, with or without authorisation, with applications pending, already built or still at the planning stage, existing or non-existent, establishments attached to the Regional Ministry of Education or otherwise, public or private, and even the details of the possible routes between them for taking the measurement; temporary, emergency or “contrived” routes are not valid, and measurements must always follow the “shortest” public thoroughfares. Measurement along “planned” routes or those “tolerated for pedestrian use” is not valid. If works are in progress when the measurement is taken or the route designated, these are to be deemed “non-existent”. I shall not elaborate further, because the articles are lengthy in their treatment of measurement techniques and reference points, axes, straight or perpendicular lines, etc.; routes plotted across hedges, fences or flowerbeds are not valid either. Just in case anyone should think of proposing something so imaginative in order cunningly to circumvent the restriction.

If any “objection” or “shortcoming” can be identified in this exceptionally detailed system, all that is missing is a requirement for the measuring instruments to be approved by the competent body; or even (why not?) an obligation on the Administration to verify “in situ”, using its powerful resources, the measurement submitted, rather than merely checking it on paper (this, at least, is what emerges from the suspicious reference to the “representation of the measurement” required by Article 13: this article appears to have been included so that no official need travel to the measurement site in the event of doubt).

A misplaced focus on the problem. The solution no one thought of.

Everything suggests that, with the Valencian Government putting so much detail under the microscope, the main problem, namely the retroactive application of the minimum distances in the Valencian Gambling Law referred to above, has been relegated to the background in the Decree.

Furthermore, when a dispute arose over the measurement of minimum distances, the Courts would ultimately find and impose a solution using the legislative or expert tools available to them, in greater or lesser detail, and could even turn a “blind eye” where there were reasonable doubts about the measurement, or where the deviation was insignificant. With the rules now detailed in the Official Gazette, whether or not the right to carry on a business activity can be exercised may depend on centimetres. Giving the measuring device a slight nudge, knocking down a wall, or moving a reference door may determine whether or not the right can be exercised.

In seeking to make measurement methods objective, the Consell has forgotten the quickest and most reliable solution, which is that provided by Google Maps in an application available to everyone. We do not know whether anyone proposed adding it to the draft legislation during the consultation procedures. It would have avoided doubts, lengthy expert reports and, moreover, the intervention of the Courts in the event of disputes (let us see who would go to California to contradict them!).

By way of corollary and summary, what is important and decisive is not so much the measurement of the distances, although that too may now be important, but the fact that they were included in the Law.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Madrid, 24 August 2021

www.loyra.com

[1] See a general commentary on this Decree on the Loyra Abogados website:

More publications