Gaming & Gambling

The Lessons of Mr. Green. (2014 Measures on Online Gambling in the United Kingdom) Part One

Carlos Lalanda ·

We take the opportunity afforded by the recent judgment of The High Court of Justice, Administrative Court, delivered on 10 October concerning the challenge to one of the amendments approved in May 2014 to British gambling legislation, namely the Gambling Act 2005, to highlight certain points of interest.

In particular, this amendment introduces the requirement to obtain a UK licence to operate online gambling where the player is located in British territory, thereby adopting the “point of consumption” or destination-of-service criterion.

This amendment and the resulting obligation prove extremely burdensome for those entities which had moved their operational headquarters to Malta or Gibraltar with the legitimate commercial aim of avoiding the special tax on gambling in the United Kingdom (which stands at 15% of the win), and which opposed it using every legal means at their disposal. They must now transfer their operations to their subsidiaries licensed by the UK Gambling Commission, or obtain a new licence in some cases.

The analysis may be undertaken from an educational perspective and by comparison with Spanish law on the subject, since, ultimately, the issues arising under English online gambling legislation are in many respects common to Spanish legislation, and even from the perspective of the operators, which in many cases are the same and operate through a subsidiary based in Gibraltar or Malta.

First, the effort, depth and speed with which the English Court determines the challenge to a statutory provision, the “Gambling Licensing and Advertisement Act 2014”, passed on 14 May 2014 and initially scheduled to enter into force on 1 October 2014, are significant and certainly commendable.A far cry from our slow Courts and their often “baroque” judgments.

It is noteworthy that the challenge is permitted and has been brought by a Gibraltar entity (Gibraltar Betting and Association Limited), representing the collective interests of international operators licensed or about to be licensed in Gibraltar, which, under the UK law cited and recognised in the judgment, is granted standing to challenge directly the substance of an Act of Parliament. The Government of Gibraltar and the Gibraltar Gambling Commissioner have also been parties to the proceedings (in support of the challenge), as have the UK Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport and the British Gambling Commission (in opposition). Under our law, challenges to Acts of Parliament are available only to Parliamentary Political Groups, the Ombudsman and the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities.

Of even greater interest is the fact that the British Court proceeds to adjudicate on a matter involving not only UK law as such (which is not even examined), but also the interpretation of the EU legal order, in particular that relating to the freedom to provide services, Article 56 TFEU. A matter on which a Spanish Court very rarely proceeds to adjudicate, although, like their British counterparts, they are all “Community judges”.

The approach of Judge Green (formally “Mr. Justice” Green) appears decidedly flexible as regards procedure (with the parties’ consent, he has allowed the entry into force of the Act to be delayed until 1 November 2014), yet forceful in his rulings, which are almost exhaustive to the point of exhaustion in a 96-page judgment (in small type and single-spaced), systematically resolving every procedural and substantive issue one by one, after describing as “Herculean” the efforts of the parties, and undoubtedly of the Court, to deliver an appropriate judicial decision in time, to the extent of offering the parties, at the hearing held on 23 and 24 September (with the Act scheduled to enter into force only a few days later), a kind of “pre-judgment” to provide the parties with greater certainty or, alternatively, a one-month suspension of its entry into force, which all ultimately accepted. It would be unthinkable for the Spanish Constitutional Court, the only court empowered to suspend the entry into force of a statutory provision, to do so in the course of a public hearing of the parties, for which no provision is even made in constitutional challenge proceedings.

On the substance, the Court’s decision is clear and concise: the claim brought cannot succeed, as no contravention of either EU law or, correspondingly, domestic (UK) law has been established. Mr. Green states that the British Act passed in May is neither disproportionate, discriminatory nor irrational, and that the new regime for operating online gambling, centred on the “point of final consumption”, serves legitimate objectives and does not create incentives to divert gambling to the illegal market, as the parties bringing the challenge had suggested. He also rejects the alternative proposal put forward by the claimant at the preliminary stages for a form of mutual recognition regime for licences issued in other territories (“passporting proposal”).

Mr. Justice Green’s arguments are virtually irrefutable, to the extent that the prestigious English gambling law firm Harris & Hagan, in its immediate commentary, described it as an unanswerable judgment (“A clear cut case”, freely translated as “as clear as day”), while also observing that an appeal against it was highly unlikely, as has subsequently proved to be the case.

A comprehensive, in-depth, swift and decisive response concerning an Act of Parliament, of the kind we would dearly like to obtain before the Spanish courts in similar matters. Thank you for that, Mr. Green.

Online operators have responded swiftly, and there are already reports that, as at 1 November, most have adapted or have applied for and obtained their new licence.

In subsequent instalments, if Azarplus allows us, we shall examine in greater depth the substance of the issue addressed, the importance and implications of adopting a harmonised licensing system centred on the “point of consumption” in online gambling, and the advisability of certain reforms to Spanish law in this regard.

Madrid, 1 November 2014

Carlos Lalanda.

Carlos.lalanda@loyra.com

Article published in azarplus.com

More publications