Gaming & Gambling
Murcia. Agreement of 19 September 2018 of the Governing Council (B.O.R.M. No. 218, of 20 September)
·
The Agreement of 19 September 2018 of the Governing Council (B.O.R.M. No. 218, of 20 September) provides that no authorisations shall be granted for the opening and operation of bingo halls, gaming halls and dedicated betting premises.
19 September 2018 will go down in the annals of the gambling sector in Murcia. As “19-S”, being the day on which the Governing Council adopted several measures of varying scope in this sector subject to administrative intervention, which should nevertheless be distinguished: an Agreement, a Decree, and the commencement of the procedure for another.
The Agreement contains the following operative provisions:
“First. – No authorisations shall be granted for the opening and operation of bingo halls, gaming halls and dedicated betting premises, nor shall prior viability consultation reports be issued, where the applications concerned are submitted from the date of this Agreement.
Second. – This Agreement shall take effect from the day of its publication in the Official Gazette of the Region of Murcia and shall remain effective until an express agreement to the contrary is adopted.
Content and limits of the Agreement
Agreements are an act of Government equivalent to an order or instruction that no new application proceedings be processed, covering the 3 classes of premises, although gaming halls account for the bulk of these. For various reasons which are set out and which boil down to our being in a phase of uncontrolled expansion. Not one more, for now.
But this Agreement is not a Regulation, and the Governing Council of the Region of Murcia cannot regulate or plan in secret and overnight the future and configuration of gaming halls or betting premises as authorised and extensively regulated activities under the provisions of the Law and the Regulations in force.
Government Agreements are one of the possible forms taken by the decisions of this administrative body and are different from administrative Regulations proper, and have a different legal effect.
The Agreement adopted certainly instructs officials to declare new applications inadmissible or even to refuse them, but not to suspend proceedings already commenced, which will continue in the ordinary course. This is appropriate and consistent with the legal certainty that characterises the Spanish administrative legal system. The long-standing general principle which remains unshaken is that proceedings must continue and be processed in accordance with “the Law in force at the time the proceedings are commenced”.
The reference to the “viability consultation” procedure may seem strange, since in these cases favourable reports confer on those making the consultation a right to the subsequent processing of the proceedings, and even a right to compensation arises if action is taken contrary to the report. Thus, within this exceptional situation, it seems logical that the prior viability consultation procedure should also be mentioned and declared inadmissible, just in case.
It is another matter that we are faced with a clear exception. And we wonder whether the Government can adopt such a measure contrary to the individual right of those subject to administrative authority to apply for authorisation when the Law and the Regulation allow them to do so. Without first having amended the Regulation. Some will take the view, and perhaps rightly so, that this improperly disapplies the Regulation and infringes one of the basic Principles of Administrative Law: the prohibition on derogating from Regulations in individual cases.
The Government of Murcia may issue whatever instructions it considers appropriate to its officials,,,,, but it cannot remove rights belonging to those subject to administrative authority (or their expectations, which is what properly exists before an application, according to case law). In short, this is an argument that will have to be advanced by those who intended on 19-S to apply for an authorisation, and the Secretary of the Governing Council reminds them that they have a period of 2 months in which to challenge the Agreement before the administrative courts. Although, for now, we have some precedents which cast more than a little doubt on its prospects of success; Agreements of this nature have already been adopted by the Government of Murcia, such as the Agreement of 19 January 2001 suspending the granting of operating permits for gaming machines, which lasted a long time. And no Court annulled that Agreement, if indeed it was ever challenged.
As expressly stated in its provisions, the Agreement entered into force on 20 September 2018