Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the National High Court (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Seventh Section), of 8 March 2017.

·


The Judgment of the National High Court
(Administrative Litigation Chamber, 7th Section) of 8 March 2017 upholds the €25,000,000 penalty imposed on Organización Impulsora de Discapacitados (O.I.D) by the Ministry of Economy and Public Administrations for a very serious infringement of the Gambling Law, for operating unlawful lotteries, as no authorisation had been obtained from either the State or the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) for the lottery products named “euroboleto” “euromillonario”, “busca OID” “Busca 25.000 €” and superbusca 10 millones €”, which are even marketed on the website www.oid.es. The Court recognises that this constitutes nationwide lottery activity, both in the forms in which prizes are awarded through a draw on a specified date and in those of an “instant” nature, as the prize is determined in a previously scheduled draw; and that the nationwide scope of the draws is evident, as is the fact that the activity is permanent rather than occasional. Furthermore, both the penalties imposed on this entity in various Autonomous Communities for unlawful gambling activity and the refusals to grant administrative authorisation have been repeated, all having been upheld by the various Courts of Justice.

According to the Court, the principle of freedom of establishment referred to in Article 49 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) cannot be invoked, since this requires that it be invoked by an entity authorised in one Member State to operate in another. Furthermore, the Gambling Law states in its Explanatory Memorandum and its First Additional Provision that the reservation of the operation of nationwide lotteries to SELAE and ONCE may be considered proportionate on grounds of consumer protection, in the sense of guaranteeing the payment of prizes and avoiding insolvency situations; likewise, that reservation respects the principle of non-discrimination, since it must be granted to a body linked to a public administration whose activity is subject to special supervision and control. Reference is also made to the regime applicable to ONCE as having been held constitutionally permissible in various judgments.

More publications