Gaming & Gambling
The National High Court annuls the AEPD Guide on biometric data: implications for the land-based gambling sector
Patricia Lalanda, Cristina Romero, Fernando Martín ·
1. What the National High Court has ruled
The First Section of the Administrative Litigation Chamber of the National High Court, by Judgment No. 367/2026, of 30 June (Ordinary Proceedings 84/2024, reporting judge: Helmuth Moya Meyer), has allowed in full the challenge brought by the Asociación Española de Empresas de Seguridad (“AES”) and has annulled the Guide on the processing of biometric data for presence monitoring (hereinafter, “the Guide”), published by the Spanish Data Protection Agency (hereinafter, “AEPD”) on 23 November 2023. The Judgment is not final: an appeal in cassation may be brought before the Supreme Court.
This is the first time that a court has annulled an AEPD guide on the grounds that, under the guise of a guidance document, it imposed binding criteria on third parties, effectively constituting a disguised circular that should have been processed in accordance with the legally prescribed procedure. The Chamber recalls that what matters is not what the document is called, but what it actually does. If a guide merely organises the internal work of the Administration, there is no issue; but if it also imposes rules with which third parties are obliged to comply, then, whatever it is called, it is operating as a legal rule and must be processed with the formalities required for a legal rule, in this case, as a circular. Since that procedure was not followed (participation by the affected sectors, reports and an opinion from the Council of State), the Guide is unlawful.
In reaching this conclusion, the National High Court emphasises that the Guide itself announced that “the criteria will be determined” for biometric processing, expressed its conclusions “in categorical terms” and established a framework that “undoubtedly sought to influence” controllers’ decisions; and that the AEPD itself had been basing its decisions imposing penalties on references to those same interpretative criteria.
2. What the Judgment does not say (and why this should be emphasised)
The annulment in the Judgment concerns form, not substance. The National High Court does not say whether or not the AEPD’s view of biometrics is correct; it assesses only the instrument used to express that view. Everything else remains in place: biometric data remain a special category, and the requirement for statutory authorisation, minimisation, the Impact Assessment and the concerns regarding consent continue to apply. The General Data Protection Regulation (RGPD) and the Organic Law on Personal Data Protection and Guarantee of Digital Rights (LOPDGDD) are unaffected. What falls is the Guide as a document and, with it, its method of imposing a restrictive interpretation without following the procedure required by law.
3. Why this judgment is of particular interest to land-based gambling
This ruling extends far beyond the monitoring of employees’ working hours, which was the main scenario addressed by the Guide. Its practical impact has, if anything, been greater in the land-based gambling sector — casinos, bingo halls and gaming halls — where biometric systems are not used as an alternative to clocking in and out, but as an identification mechanism for access control: verifying that the person is not a minor, is not listed in the Registers of Persons Prohibited from Accessing Gambling and, increasingly, is not impersonating another person using artificial intelligence-based fraud technologies.
The practical consequence of the Guide in this area was by no means insignificant: numerous operators suspended or modified biometric access control projects solely because of the restrictive interpretation made public by the AEPD in November 2023, and several Autonomous Communities responded by amending their gambling laws to provide express statutory authorisation for the use of biometrics, declaring it to be of “substantial public interest” within the meaning of Article 9(2)(g) RGPD. In other words: the sector, and even the regional legislature itself, ended up responding to a document that, legally, should never have had that scope.
4. The origin of the problem: unfounded “mutatis mutandis” reasoning
It is worth pausing here, because this is the true root of the uncertainty, and the judgment indirectly confirms it. The Guide devoted its central analysis to the recording of working hours: in that context, it concluded that, given the statutory obligation to clock in and out and the imbalance of power between employer and employee, the employee’s consent could not lift the prohibition under Article 9(1) RGPD if an equally effective non-biometric alternative existed. Up to that point, the reasoning was confined to the employment relationship.
The leap — and the true origin of the uncertainty for the gambling sector — occurred when the Guide itself extended that same logic, mutatis mutandis, to access control for non-employment purposes; that is, to the relationship between a gambling establishment and a consumer/customer. In its conclusions, the AEPD simply transferred reasoning devised for the employer–employee imbalance to a context — a customer’s access to a casino, bingo hall or gaming hall — in which that structural imbalance simply does not exist. This is an extrapolation by analogy that lacks significant interpretative value in law: neither Article 9 RGPD nor Article 9 LOPDGDD provides for a general exclusion of consent for access control at gambling establishments, and the AEPD’s own enforcement practice (case PS/00413/2022, concerning biometric access to a gym) confirms that the problem was never the use of consent as a lawful basis, but rather when and how the data subject was informed.
That single paragraph — devised for a very specific scenario and subsequently extended, by analogy, to an entire sector — is precisely the type of content that a “guidance” document cannot purport to impose as generally applicable. And it is also, in essence, what the National High Court criticises in the Guide as a whole: establishing, under the guise of mere guidance, a categorical criterion intended to apply erga omnes without the necessary procedural underpinning. The land-based gambling sector treated that paragraph as though it were positive law, when it should never have had that status, something this firm pointed out to some of its clients when the Guide was approved.
5. Guides, FAQs and consultations: a necessary reminder of their status
The biometric Guide episode is not an isolated case, and this judgment provides an opportunity to issue an important reminder to the entire sector. Gambling is one of the most heavily regulated and penalised activities in our legal system, which — understandably — drives operators to seek the greatest possible legal certainty in interpretation wherever they can find it: guides, frequently asked questions, responses to consultations or instructions published by supervisory authorities. That search for certainty is legitimate, but it must not obscure the true legal nature of those documents.
The AEPD itself recalls this in its Instruction 1/2021, of 2 November, on its advisory function: the content, materials, FAQs, guides and other information documents published by the Agency constitute information and awareness-raising activities, are non-binding in nature, and do not replace the exercise of the investigative, corrective, authorisation or advisory powers provided for in Article 58 RGPD. Even the legal reports issued by the Agency itself are not binding on its inspectors. In practical terms: a guide, however authoritative its source, cannot alter the assessment of suitability, necessity and proportionality that the controller must carry out on a case-by-case basis; and a restrictive interpretation contained in a guide cannot, in itself, deprive a lawful basis recognised by the RGPD and the LOPDGDD of its substance.
This judgment therefore provides an additional — and now judicial — argument for operators in the sector not to regard a legal issue as definitively settled merely because a guide, FAQs or a response to a consultation says so, even if they originate from the supervisory authority. Legal certainty in the sector must rest on the law, the RGPD and case law, not on documents of a merely informative nature which, as this case demonstrates, may ultimately be annulled. And this can be extrapolated to the other supervisory authorities.
6. What we recommend to operators of casinos, bingo halls and gaming halls
– Maintain the analytical framework that we have already been recommending, irrespective of the fate of the Guide: a test of suitability, necessity and proportionality, documented in a prior Data Protection Impact Assessment (EIPD) specific to biometric access control.
– Remember that the lawful bases under Article 9(2) RGPD remain available: explicit consent — accompanied by a genuine alternative that is not equivalent in terms of security, such as the national identity card (DNI) or an access card — and, where applicable, authorisation by a provision having the force of law, already expressly included in several regional gambling laws (Comunitat Valenciana, La Rioja, Extremadura, among others).
– Review and, where appropriate, reactivate biometric identification projects that were suspended, abandoned or modified solely as a result of the restrictive interpretation in the now-annulled Guide.
– Apply minimum retention periods — ideally, immediate deletion following verification — and enhance the information provided to users on the specific processing of biometric data.
– Closely monitor the AEPD’s institutional response — a circular, a new guide or a regulatory vacuum — and any appeal in cassation, since both may alter the interpretative landscape once again.
We remain at your disposal to analyse the specific impact of this judgment on access control systems already implemented or planned at your establishments.
LOYRA ABOGADOS
Intellectual Property and New Technologies Department
Partner: Patricia Lalanda