Gaming & Gambling

New horizons for the application of Market Unity in the gambling sector

Carlos Lalanda ·

The work undertaken by the State–Asturias and State–Illes Balears Bilateral Cooperation Commissions, through Agreements recently published in the Official State Gazette (BOE), requires reference and analysis.

The first, dated 30 March 2015 (BOE of 15 April), examines and resolves disagreements concerning several articles of the Asturias Gambling Law (Law 6/2014); and the second, dated 2 June 2015 (BOE of 18 June), resolves others concerning Law 8/2014 on Gambling in Illes Balears.

It should be recalled that these Commissions are constitutional in nature (Article 33 of the Spanish Constitution (CE)), and operate as preliminary forums for mediation to reach agreement and resolve potential constitutional disputes over competence, seeking interpretations consistent with the Constitution in order to avoid bringing the dispute before the Constitutional Court.

Where a consensual solution cannot be reached, there is no alternative but to resolve the disagreement through constitutional proceedings, with the uncertainty that this entails.

In the cases examined, Gambling Laws were published in both Asturias and Illes Balears (in Illes Balears, the first in its history) shortly after Law 20/2013, of 9 December, on the Guarantee of Market Unity (hereinafter LGUM) had taken full effect, that is, after the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) should have adapted to its rules and principles.

This LGUM was intended to provide an impetus for change in response to the numerous restrictions prevailing in many business sectors throughout the national territory, in respect of which powers of intervention are vested in the Autonomous Communities (hereinafter CCAA). In the gambling sector, all the CCAA have incorporated this competence into their Statutes of Autonomy as an exclusive competence, with the blessing of the case law of the Constitutional Court (TC). In all of them, almost without exception, its implementation has resulted in a genuine territorial fragmentation of markets, as numerous administrative control barriers have been erected, imposing numerous obligations which multiply the requirements for access to the markets of each Autonomous Community, and which extend to all forms of operating gambling activities for the public, to the distribution of gaming machines and equipment, and even to the manufacture of gaming equipment.

An initial reading of the LGUM seemed to suggest some application of its principles and benefits to all kinds of businesses and some relief from the excessive requirements currently in force. In practice, however, the results of its application to the gambling sector appeared meagre, owing to the evident opposition of the CCAA to any removal of their controls, clinging to the interpretation hitherto expressed by the TC in favour of their competences. The LGUM's own internal contradictions and a certain final dilution of its provisions leave little scope for effective reliance on this Law, since not even the Directorate-General for Gambling of the Ministry of Finance (DGOJ) has managed to establish an effective mechanism for its application, despite the effort to formulate possible multilateral agreements in the Report on Regulatory Rationalisation and Market Unity of 9 December 2014 (which, in any event, someone within the Central Administration was obliged to produce, as the LGUM itself states).

Certain measures taken by the CCAA in fulfilment of the obligation to review their legal frameworks to adapt them to the LGUM have proved purely cosmetic or very limited in scope as regards the gambling sector. For example, the amendments undertaken in Andalucía and Castilla y León.

However, the threat of a possible dispute over competence before the Constitutional Court in respect of the new Laws of Asturias and Illes Balears has resulted in an initial “real” step forward in the application of this LGUM and, ultimately, in the removal of restrictions and obstacles. Thus, these Agreements concern entries in Gambling Registers, the approval of equipment, security deposits and professional documents.

The Agreement in Asturias

In the Asturias Agreement, the advances concern approvals, registers and professional cards. As regards the former, it is stipulated that implementing rules must ensure that approvals obtained in other territories are effective, through the introduction of effective validation procedures, or through the recognition of entries in registers of other CCAA. As regards professional cards, the Government of the Principality will promote the repeal of the provision. The Agreement is not much more explicit.

The Agreement in Illes Balears

In the Illes Balears Agreement, in addition to the provisions concerning prize draws, the subject of security deposits is notably mentioned, as it is agreed by both parties that the provision of security deposits “is confined to the conditions governing the pursuit of the activity, and only for certain activities that entail a direct risk to the health or safety of the recipient, or of a third party, or to the financial security of the recipient”.

Although this is a rather cryptic interpretation, it appears to point towards the abolition of security deposits required solely for entry in the registers (which is a requirement or condition of access, rather than of the pursuit of the activity); but also towards security deposits being required only to guarantee the payment of prizes to players (which was the rationale for security deposits when the first steps were being taken in the private management of gambling), and not to guarantee potential penalties, the payment of taxes, etc.

New horizons

It is interesting to note that these Agreements now provide a basis, at least in these matters and territories, for reliance on those interpretations, and even for potentially defending them before the Courts of Justice. But they may also be relied upon in other CCAA, now with greater justification and with interpretative precedents available.

However, given the reluctance of many of the CCAA to undertake a genuine, widespread removal of barriers, significant pockets of clear non-application of the LGUM remain (for example, mandatory domicile requirements, requirements for professional cards, etc.), which may undoubtedly also be challenged, although the road ahead appears, for now, to be long and tortuous.

The signing of a genuine multilateral Agreement or Convention is still awaited, for which the outline drawn up in 2014 by the DGOJ may serve as a basis.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Madrid, 19 June 2015

More publications