Gaming & Gambling

The \»new\» Online Gambling Advertising Self-Regulation Code

Carlos Lalanda ·

It has been widely announced that the new version of the so-called \»Code of Conduct on Commercial Communications for Gambling Activities\», prepared by and within Autocontrol (Association for the Self-Regulation of Commercial Communications), will “enter into force” on 15 January.… for the members that have adhered to it.

According to some, we are witnessing a “new” regulatory framework for gambling advertising in Spain. However, as we shall see below, the amendment of just a few very specific points of this “Code” is by no means a revolution in the legal regime applicable to this matter to date.

On the contrary, the real amendment of this regime is yet to come, and soon, once Spain’s exceptional political circumstances have been resolved, particularly following the publication of the programme of the coalition Government expected to seek the confidence of the Spanish Parliament in the coming days.

Specific content amended

 A specific analysis of these amendments to the aforementioned Code is already set out on the Loyra Abogados website, with a link to the consolidated text, briefly explaining what has been amended or added in 6 paragraphs of its previous version, with the following “new features” (in bold):

  1. Principle of truthfulness (Paragraph 4.3): Commercial communications and self-promotions must include all essential elements of the terms and conditions of bonuses or promotions.
  2. Responsible gambling principles. Paragraphs 6.13, 6.14, 6.15 and 6.16 are added, respectively providing that: the maximum amount of welcome bonuses used in commercial communications shall be two hundred euros; visual commercial communications and self-promotions shall include in advertisements the mandatory warning logos on responsible gambling and the prohibition on gambling by persons under 18 through a standardised warning; the commercial communications and self-promotions shall not feature active sportspeople engaging in gambling activities or recommending them. During live broadcasts by any means of sporting events, horse racing or any other events of a competitive nature, commercial communications publicising bonuses or promotions of any kind may not be made within the broadcast itself.
  3. Protection of minors. (Paragraphs 7.2 and 7.3). The prohibition on featuring minors in commercial communications or self-promotions is extended, so that communications which feature persons under 25 in leading roles shall not be permitted. Finally, in this area, commercial communications which directly or indirectly encourage minors to gamble are prohibited, through the inclusion, among others, of persons who are recognisable owing to their public prominence and appear in children’s programmes in the media or whose activity focuses on minors.

Despite this effort to introduce amendments, the regime governing gambling advertising in Spain remains mired in evident confusion, acknowledged by countless voices.

Particularly in relation to online gambling, these voices even come from beyond our borders and remind us that regulating and defining the limits of this aspect of online gambling is essential for its normal development.

By way of anecdote, a member of the public is seeking support through the well-known platform “change.org” to ask the Government, even if it remains eternally in a caretaker capacity, to approve, once and for all, the Decree which is to regulate this matter, the draft of which was drawn up several years ago, and to have it finally published.

Let us recall where we stand, and the consequences of every kind arising from this confused situation.

Online gambling advertising versus land-based gambling advertising

 Let us summarise the fundamental differences between the various sectors in terms of gambling advertising:

  1. From a substantive perspective, advertising (to the public) of land-based gambling has always been viewed as advertising of the premises where gambling takes place. For that reason, such advertising has always been confined to very specific, local media; since the legalisation of gambling in 1977, with greater or lesser restrictions. Online gambling advertising, by contrast, involves mass advertising of commercial “brands”, normally those of gambling operators at national level and of their products operated through websites; since this channel was legalised in 2012, without any restrictions beyond the general restrictions applicable to any other advertising message, provided that the operator holds a gambling licence.
  2. From the perspective of the importance of gambling advertising for the different channels through which it is offered, it has been said that land-based gambling advertising is useful and assists the operation of premises, whereas online gambling advertising is essential for the development of operators and products.
  3. From a formal perspective, competence to regulate land-based gambling advertising lies with the Autonomous Communities, whereas the State must regulate online gambling advertising. From this perspective, it may be said that the Autonomous Communities have regulated the advertising of gambling and gambling premises with varying degrees of precision, and in some cases even excessively restrictively, whereas the Central State has all but abandoned its regulatory powers over the advertising of online gambling at national level.
  4. Finally, there is the distinct perspective of advertising for SELAE and ONCE lotteries, which substantively and formally corresponds to the subject matter, needs and competences referred to above in relation to online gambling (although these are not actually online gambling). In this case, it is not premises that are advertised, but “products”, and advertising is essential to their operation, while competence to regulate it lies with the State. These two entities have never adhered to this Code and maintain their own policies of ethical self-regulation.

The non-existent State Regulation and the Online Gambling Advertising Self-Regulation Code.

The much-repeated and much-mentioned State Regulation on the Advertising of Gambling at National Level remains non-existent today. The only “advertising restriction” on games of chance at national level comes down to the technique of “self-restraint”, and this, in short, is what the so-called Code promoted by the association Autocontrol consists of, to which numerous gambling operators and advertising operators have adhered. Adopted in 2012, it was conceived as a kind of interim solution to the absence of regulation by the competent public authority.

Like other similar advertising codes to which adherence is voluntary, this is a technique alien to the Spanish legal system, originating in common law, which in practice serves to mediate between advertisers and the media in the “hostile territory” of the legal classification of any commercial communication.

The Gambling Law embraces this approach and refers to the approval of “Co-regulation Agreements” with other entities such as Autocontrol for the approval of these Codes (there could be others), to which the Law attributes a very particular effect:  there is a presumption that any advertising infringement is not attributable to anyone who has obtained the Association’s “copy advice”, which is the keystone of the system: the television and radio networks with the widest reach, which in turn have adhered to this Code, only agree to broadcast commercial communications if these have first passed through the filter of “copy advice ” (which thus appears as a kind of “private authorisation”)

No more, no less.

Although there are advocates of these Codes, and of the value of “ethical behaviour” by companies as a motivating factor in their advertising activities, this is by no means proven, and since the very earliest formulations of law, compliance with rules or commands has had much to do with the consequences arising from their breach. Human conduct in road traffic, accepting restrictions on movement, has a behavioural basis (avoiding constant collisions or accidents which may cause us material harm), but above all it is founded on the establishment of traffic rules laid down by the regulator and the corresponding infringement in the event of non-compliance, all published in the Official Gazette.

In the absence of a Regulation, proceedings for advertising infringements brought by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) are few or non-existent (they only arise where the advertiser lacks a licence), and if there were no self-regulation Code, exactly the same would happen. Indeed, “copy advice” could equally be obtained through adherence to the general Advertising Self-Regulation Codes, which ultimately refer in practice to general regulatory parameters such as audiovisual and content legislation, in addition to the general parameters focused on the advertising message. For example, the <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Advertising Code of Conduct of the same association Autocontrol. Nor would anything happen if SELAE or ONCE \»breached\» their own self-regulatory measures. And the various media outlets would not cease advertising the products of two of their best clients on that account.

Consequences of the Amendment to the Code

In this state of affairs, any Code that is approved, and any amendment made to the existing one, cannot make up for the absence of a regulation and can only be regarded as an innovation, of greater or lesser importance, in relation to the balance of coercive measures and counterweights described above.

The amendment now being adopted within Autocontrol, even though it carries the DGOJ’s “seal of approval”, demonstrates the failure of public enforcement in this area, which has always been subject to such public intervention (the Central State, competent to adopt an Advertising Regulation, has been unable to approve it in the 8 years since the Law required it to do so.).

On the other hand, it reveals itself as an attempt by those involved in online gambling advertising to alleviate the wave of criticism which, from all sectors of society, floods the newspapers and the media themselves every day.

The fact that the signatories to the Code impose a self-limitation of 200 euros on welcome bonuses, or require those adhering to it not to feature minors or public figures in leading roles in advertisements, is irrelevant insofar as they have long been able to do so on their own initiative. The measure concerning the information which should accompany the offer of welcome bonuses, one of the “flagship” measures, is simply impracticable: no human being is capable of reading, in a fraction of a second, the long list of elements that must be included in the message.

It is true that, through the operation of counterweights, failure to comply with these new “self-limitations” may in practice prevent the advertisement from being published. However, the consequences of non-compliance are not as serious as in other self-regulated sectors, such as sporting competitions: for example, a football club which fails to comply with the rules of the Competition Regulations, another example of self-regulation, may even be punished by relegation.

If we add to this the recent, equally ambiguous “interpretative statements by the DGOJ” concerning the limitation of sporting competitions involving minors on which betting is permitted, this time at the initiative of the regulator and with the same conciliatory aims, the outlook on this entire matter seems to us, once again, bleak.

Note:

More publications