Gaming & Gambling

This is no longer a \»competitive tender\»

Carlos Lalanda ·

 The launch of a third Call for General Online Gambling Licences recently promoted by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) requires us to reflect once again on the context in which the Gambling Law operates today.

Since its inception, many of the legislative milestones of Gambling Law 13/2011, of 27 May, have gradually fallen away or been replaced.

Its text has already been amended several times, through the complete repeal of some of its Titles or articles: all those governing that modern National Gambling Commission which never came into being, envisaged as a more or less independent body; repeal in favour of an internal body of the Ministry of Finance, the current Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling. There have also been some other amendments of lesser significance: concerning the advertising liability of advertising networks, or the earmarking of tax revenues from football pools.

However, the most significant distortions of the legislative edifice initially envisaged have come “from within”, through departures from several principles upon which the State's intervention was intended to be based, chiefly directed at online gambling, but also at lotteries in their “traditional physical” form. We identify the following areas in which the force of the law has been undermined:

  1. Dilution of certain provisions of the Law: From the outset, it became apparent that the numerous interests involved led to a considerable weakening of several of the milestones on which it was initially based. Some of these:
  • Under pressure from the Autonomous Communities (CCAA), the State's clear competence over gambling at national and supra-regional level was reduced to some extent, a situation which remains unresolved today: the authorisation of physical means “ancillary” to online gambling (that is, physical terminals for betting and other gambling in premises open to the public), which appears to fall to the CCAA;  or the express recognition of a singular form of “online gambling\»,  \»Autonomous Community online gambling”, which is difficult to accept conceptually; or the “sui generis allocation”  to  the CCAA of revenue from the Gambling Levy on online activities (the so-called “Gambling Tax”, which is the same traditional \»Levy\»). All of the foregoing, being contrived, is a source of problems and legal contortions. Unresolved.
  • Under pressure from the “.com operators” converted into “.es” operators, the very implementation of the Law and its transitional periods produced some truly surprising episodes. Data transfers, temporary gaps in the application of the law, privileges concerning activities that went unpunished, expedited tax regularisations for applicants, but also the urgent introduction of rules to accommodate situations tolerated in practice.
  1. Distortions in the application of the Law.

With the Law already fully implemented, and the entire body of implementing regulations in force, certain acts or omissions cause constant confusion (among insiders and outsiders alike) as to the usefulness and meaning of some of its rules. Examples in this category:

  • The need to regulate advertising and promotional activity for licensed gambling.  At this stage, no one understands why the third “regulatory leg” of the 3 envisaged in the Law is missing, namely the Regulation governing advertising activity for games of chance. We know that the draft has been prepared, is at an advanced stage, etc. But without this Regulation, advertising is “free” (subject to general restrictions like any other activity).
  • The blurring of the conceptual boundaries between the different categories of gambling. By way of example, authorisations to operate certain variants of Poker (with draws). The Law clearly states the distinction between games and draws. There is no known complaint or challenge, not even from the bodies holding the reserved rights to lotteries, on whose territory these draws (with poker) have positioned themselves.
  1. The “Competitive Tender” for the award of licences which is no longer such.  (Link to the website where it is announced)

Finally, the dismantling of the “competitive tender” mechanism for obtaining online gambling licences. During the passage of the Bill, a “competitive” procedure was initially devised for obtaining these Licences. That is, a numerus clausus of licences, to be obtained through selection by competitive tender. In the final wording of the Law, this was already watered down to a system of unlimited Licences and, consequently, a kind of “non-competitive competition”, two almost antithetical concepts.

In the implementing Regulation, Royal Decree 1614/2011, it remained more or less clear that, although applications were dealt with separately, they at least retained a common timetable, so that all were processed within the same time limits, and the decisions on all of them and their publication on the DGOJ website were simultaneous. Applicants submitted their applications within a given regulatory framework during the period specified in the Call.

With the launch of the Third Call now being announced, not even that remains, since within the period for submitting applications (one year from publication of the Call), each application will follow its own course and be processed independently. It is even possible that substantive rules may be issued in the meantime which make withdrawal possible owing to applicants' lack of interest; or new rules which make applying attractive to others.

We have thus moved from a system of “competition” among applicants to a system of an application “processing window”, which is essentially a mere restriction on the time limits for submitting independent and separate applications.

Faced with this reality, possibly contrary to the spirit of the Law, the solution proposed by some would appear easier, in order to avoid these conceptual pirouettes: to make a specific amendment to the Law, as has already been done on other occasions without any major upheaval, so that Licences may be applied for at any time.

Madrid, 23 October 2017.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

More publications