Gaming & Gambling
No, they do not represent us
Carlos Lalanda ·
This is one of the most widely circulated slogans of the 15-M movement, subsequently adopted most readily by certain political groups as a campaign rallying cry. “No! They do not represent us!”
And it may sum up the sentiment to be drawn from the parliamentary activities of the Joint Congress–Senate Committee for the Study of the Drug Problem, particularly as regards gambling addiction — pathological gambling — understood as a “drug without a substance”.
In particular, following an analysis of the wording, debate and votes on the Non-Legislative Proposals and Motion considered yesterday.
The PSOE Non-Legislative Proposal , on consumer protection, adopted unanimously, includes a battery of measures on the advertising and promotion of games of chance, and calls on the Government to implement Articles 7 and 8 of the national Gambling Law through regulations, concerning the advertising and promotion of online gambling, with numerous measures restricting advertising times, limiting the use of popular personalities, prohibiting online advertising on social networks aimed at minors, restricting gift bonuses, restricting the advertising of names through the sponsorship of sports teams, etc.
The Ciudadanos Non-Legislative Proposal, on preventing addiction to online gambling and betting, adopted on this occasion with 10 abstentions, also calls for legislative changes along similar lines, although in this case it insists on a total prohibition of bonuses and incentives as a means of promoting gambling and betting.
Lastly, the Podemos-En Común-En Marea Motion, which was rejected, sought to promote a general prohibition of commercial communications for sports betting and games of chance, through an amendment to the Audiovisual Communication Law.
Almost everything said concerns “online” gambling
If we delve a little deeper into the reasoning and the Parliamentary Proposals, their basis and grounds refer specifically to “online” gambling, although their cause then appears to be extended to all kinds of games of chance. The Ciudadanos Proposal refers only to this subsector, and the others also refer almost exclusively to it, since Articles 7 and 8 of the Gambling Law have only been applied to online gambling, and the Autonomous Communities do not adopt them as supplementary law; most of the measures would only affect the excessive advertising of these online products.
In recent years, we have not observed any complaints about the advertising or promotion of land-based gambling, which in most cases is strictly and excessively restricted; nor any greater hostility towards the advertising excesses of all kinds emanating from publicly managed games and draws run by SELAE or ONCE.
Had online gambling advertising not been extended to the point of exhaustion, this intensive parliamentary work would have been unnecessary, or at least different in its intensity and forcefulness.
Let us also recall that online gambling accounts for less than a third of gambling as a whole in terms of “stakes”, while it accounts for 5% in terms of “actual gambling”.
In short, the problem–solution dialectic is proposed only from the perspective of a minority segment of games of chance, namely the online gambling offering, which is indeed very likely to generate most of the problems now being studied by the Committee.
A chance coincidence of Proposals and Actions?
Coinciding with these Proposals is the general public consultation procedure opened this very month by the Secretariat of State for Finance for the processing of the Draft Royal Decree on Commercial Communications relating to games of chance (that is, on the Advertising and Promotion of online games of chance, and measures concerning Responsible Gambling, among other matters).
This procedure resumes the process of preparing the Royal Decree, the draft of which had already been drawn up, reports issued on it, and even submitted to the EU, before it was brought to a halt in 2015.
One might ask which came first …. the resumption of the processing of the Draft within the Ministry? Or the parliamentary initiative in the Cortes?
Although the pace may differ, the coincidence is plain, since the PSOE Proposal calls on the Government to process a Decree implementing Articles 7 and 8 of Law 13/2011, which concern the very same matters (a coincidence?) addressed by that Draft. The Ciudadanos Proposal does almost the same. Thus, from this perspective, the Proposals serve only to gather up and add one more drop to the sea of requests already on the table concerning the same subject: the need to develop these Regulations.
The need for these Regulations.
That these Regulations are necessary has already been said ad nauseam, and this has been the approach from every standpoint, for many years, with varying degrees of intensity and specificity. Only the occasional recalcitrant ultra-liberal has maintained that online gambling advertising should be virtually unrestricted, as it is now.
To a greater or lesser extent, everyone agreed on their necessity, both because the Law requires their publication (they are the only ones still missing of the 3 specified in Law 13/2011), and because of the obvious excesses of the media and online gambling advertisers, which have attracted criticism of every kind.
The sole reason why these Regulations have not already been approved and entered into force is precisely one of political representation: the processing of the Draft from 2015 onwards was shelved when elections were called that year.
In short, an absence of regulation owing to the “absence” of political representatives. All of them.
The “victims” of online gambling advertising
It now turns out that the victims of this “absence” of measures are principally young people and those with a gambling addiction. This is a manner of speaking, of course, but it is what emerges from the Proposals submitted and from the submissions and debates of all the political representatives. But let us not fall into “victimhood”, the general tenor of many current debates, and let us properly analyse the data, reports and studies that have neither been examined in depth nor verified.
According to the Podemos Motion, more than a million Spaniards have a gambling addiction, or thereabouts. Or, according to the PSOE Proposal, between 3.5% and 5% of adolescents (both adults and minors, it is understood) have a gambling addiction; the Ciudadanos Proposal is not far behind, accepting as valid a study that appears to conclude that 20% of those under 18 actively participate in online sports betting. Those of us accustomed to analysing these reports in detail can never rationally validate the figures and statistics provided “but, in short… how many victims are there?” or the scientific validity of these studies “what is being asked, and of whom?” Faced with such vagueness, the supposed “representativeness” of the sample or statistic quickly falls apart.
Viewed in this light, the true victim of these proposals is “truth” itself, distorted by clearly erroneous and exaggerated conclusions.
Parliamentary action in response to this problem.
The problem of gambling addiction in Spain is a mantra that cannot be ignored and must receive a full response, in its proper terms, including in Parliament.
But what might the response in this forum consist of? The principal response is that political representatives must undoubtedly allocate part of the public Budget to alleviating this problem, as they do to alleviate other problems.
For example, by allocating resources to social (and even healthcare) initiatives that can be funded from the enormous special contributions generated by these activities. Through the Gambling Tax, private gambling operators contributed €1,750 million in 2016 (of which some €100 million came from online gambling entities); or through remittances from SELAE (a further €1,700 million annually).
On the expenditure side, I have seen almost no budgetary allocation at national or Autonomous Community level intended to finance policies of this kind. It would seem that the only possible policy here is to prohibit or restrict (which costs the public purse nothing).
If the problem exists, as it certainly does, and is amplified by online gambling, the budgetary measures to alleviate it are in their hands. In this respect, political representatives do not represent those affected either, nor the voters who delegate the allocation of public expenditure to them.
The world turned upside down.
So, on the one hand, the Committee adopts the Proposals for the Regulations to be processed and to include measures, while, on the other, the Regulations are already being processed by the Ministry. Is everything resolved, then? Are the adopted Proposals already being acted upon?
It must first be said that a “Non-Legislative Proposal” (Congress) or a “Motion” (Senate) is not a Law, obvious though it may be to say so. And it should even be added that nothing happens if they are not complied with…. even if they are adopted unanimously by all the Political Groups, as in one of these cases (the PSOE Proposal).
So …. what purpose do they serve? …. Can they at least serve as “submissions” in the consultation procedure opened by the Ministry?… We even doubt that, given that some of the measures, even those accepted by the parliamentary Group of the governing party …. are not in the Draft: for example, restrictions on sports sponsorship or restrictions on bonuses (the PSOE Proposal); or, outright, the prohibition of bonuses (the Ciudadanos Proposal).
It is somewhat embarrassing to recall that Law 13/2011, regulating online gambling, originated in a measure processed and promoted by the PSOE Government, pursuant to a mandate from 2006 published with the force of Law in the Official State Gazette (BOE). And that its principal concomitant cause was the “legalisation” of the numerous advertising sponsorships of football clubs by illegal online gambling operators.
Also, that the First Call for Licence Applications, involving the processing of numerous regulations at supersonic speed, took place while overlooking and bypassing precisely the processing and approval of the Advertising Regulations, which were deferred “ad calendas graecas”.
And now the other Government is being required to undo what was done in the first instance, and to do what was not done in the second.
Moreover, some of the objectives underlying the measures proposed can only genuinely be achieved if the Gambling Law is amended. For example, by regulating the consequences of non-compliance with “advertising and promotional self-regulation”, the technique to which this entire matter of advertising has hitherto been delegated. But in this case, the appropriate course is not so much to “call on the Government” as to legislate … through a formal Legislative Proposal.
In short, in this respect too, political representatives are inconsistent in their dealings with those whom they claim to represent (young people, the unprotected, civil society, etc.).
Ultimately, we must look at what the Draft Decree provides for, and devote a few minutes to analysing it. And let everyone represent themselves.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández
Madrid, 13 December 2017