Gaming & Gambling
Online Gambling Advertising in the Early Hours: from 1 a.m. to 5 a.m.
Carlos Lalanda ·
It has recently been reported that the new Minister for Consumer Affairs has brought to a “multi-table” negotiation involving the gambling sector, over which he now exercises his governmental powers, an “opening proposal”: to reduce the times for advertising online games of chance to the night-time hours between 1 a.m. and 5 a.m.
With very little reflection, this measure is tantamount to eliminating advertising for activities of this kind, as some have already pointed out, and little further explanation is needed: at those early hours, most of the population is enjoying its well-earned rest, and audiovisual media will receive few or no advertising business proposals during hours when audiences are expected to be minimal. With all the consequences that this entails for media outlets and online gambling operators.
This proposal nevertheless fits with, and follows the same line as, campaigns on social media and initiatives in various forums promoting a total ban on gambling advertising, advocated by groups closely aligned with the new Minister.
Is the Minister therefore making a kind of “trap proposal” to disguise the true intention of banning gambling advertising or, as a modern-day colloquial speaker might put it, is he “having everyone on” by referring to such specific and inconvenient hours?
This theory must immediately be ruled out, since, surprising though it may seem, and as a recent statement from the Ministry itself reveals, it is simply a matter of “picking things up where they were left a couple of years ago”. The idea is far from new.
The Council of State Report of 2018
The mantra concerning the need to approve a Decree on Commercial Communications and Responsible Gambling is predictable and even inevitable, as we already know and have been pointing out for years, specifically since applications were invited for the first online gambling licences back in 2011 without this regulatory instrument having been approved, although it was necessary and indispensable to complete the system of intervention in these games designed in the Law itself.
And so, year after year, invitations to apply for new online licences were repeated (and there have now been three), without the Regulations seeing the light of day. Sometimes because it could not be done, but mostly because there was no desire to do so, this Decree was never approved. On the last occasion, its passage was halted, and this is what the Ministry's statement refers to, after the latest Draft was submitted to the Council of State for its mandatory Opinion ……. And this was issued and received at the end of 2018, already in “stoppage time”, with the new Government that had emerged from the motion of no confidence and with expectations of a short term in office.
Among the Opinion's various pronouncements, one accords with the purpose of this commentary: gambling advertising for fixed-odds betting and exchange betting should be confined to the time slot between 1 a.m. and 5 a.m. The reason: if the Audiovisual Law (Law 7/2010, of 31 March, distinct from and preceding the Gambling Law) permits gambling “programming” only from 1 a.m. to 5 a.m., this appears to be the logic inherent in its advertising, according to the Council, on grounds of protecting the rights of minors, which is also addressed in the Audiovisual Law, since this is the chapter of that Law under which the aforementioned restriction on programming falls.
In other words, the Ministry now justifies its proposal by reference to what the Council of State had already said, and presents it as a “starting point” in this round of talks. Better, certainly, than having chosen the other option: to conclude the conversation and put a “full stop” to it.
We are therefore interested in reviewing what that Opinion said and investigating the probable reasons why the Decree was ultimately not approved.
An “invisible” Opinion
It is curious to note that we find neither legal literature nor media commentary on the aforementioned Opinion, which did indeed exist, and that is why the Ministry now invokes it. Even its contents cannot readily be documented, as they have not been officially published and are almost “secret”. Yet a simple reading reveals that the reasons for its eclipse probably lay in the very “observations” made by the advisory body on the text submitted for its Opinion, two of them of an “essential” nature, although there are several others.
The successor to other royal councils of an advisory nature, the Council of State is now a constitutional body (Article 107), constituted as the Government's supreme advisory body, and currently retains, as acknowledged by the Organic Law governing it, a decisive formal role before the final approval of legislative or regulatory provisions.
Although its reports are not “binding” in the sense of being able to veto the Draft Regulations submitted for its Opinion, there is an initial obligation to await their issue before approving them, and, if they are not complied with, the case law establishes that the provision is null and void; furthermore, the manner of recording that the consultation has taken place and its outcome when approving any Regulations is both traditional and striking: under the aforementioned Organic Law, the act approving the regulatory provision by the Council of Ministers must include the expression “ in accordance with the Council of State” (if the Government has followed all the essential observations in the Opinion issued), or, conversely, “having heard the Council of State”, (which means that it in fact departs from the Opinion, that is, that its essential observations have not been heeded). The addressee of the published provision is thus informed and also receives a clear subliminal message concerning its validity; in the second case, it means that the provision is approved, but that the Council of State opposed it in its entirety or in some of its details, and, consequently, a potential challenge may have support. On many occasions, though not all, the Courts subsequently uphold the grounds of challenge, owing to the quality of the reasoning and arguments presumed of the Council; hence Drafts are normally amended in accordance with its Opinion.
An “insurmountable” Opinion
Read carefully, the observations are of such magnitude that they must have seemed insurmountable for the spirit and essence of the Decree intended for approval: either the Council of State was unaware of the real consequences of what it was saying, or it simply intended that the Decree should not be approved, which is what ultimately happened in practice.
We are therefore interested in disentangling and summarising the observations made by the Council. First, the “essential” ones:
- The observation concerning the times for online gambling advertising. On this point, it favours recommending, as more consistent with the law, that advertising be broadcast only between 1 a.m. and 5 a.m., but only for fixed-odds betting and exchange betting broadcast on television, considering these forms to be the most intensive owing to their immediacy and repetition, according to the analysis and background in the explanatory memorandum accompanying the drafting process, the structure of the Decree, and the reasons relating to the protection of minors referred to above. As regards other online games, and other media and time slots, it raises no objection in this section to the proposed text. If we consider that these forms of betting generate the greatest demand for advertising placements, at times other than those recommended, and their consequent reduction to zero, we can find an initial reason why the Decree was halted. Although we are not dealing here, and this must also be acknowledged, with “technical legal reasoning”, but rather with a value judgement.
- However, the second “essential observation” made was perhaps even more significant, since the Council warned that the proposed Second Additional Provision conferred on the DGOJ itself a power not recognised in the Gambling Law: that of“ issuing such provisions as may be necessary for the development and implementation of the provisions of this Royal Decree”, which it rejects because that Law did not grant the power to make regulations to just any ministerial body, but only to the National Gambling Commission, which never came into being, an independent administrative authority that disappeared from the Law in 2013 through the express repeal of the articles governing it. Had this observation been accepted, it would have amounted to a veritable “hara-kiri” for the DGOJ, or at least the amputation of one of the arms through which it acts, while simultaneously acknowledging the nullity of several of the resolutions that it has issued to date and continues to issue.
These are the two principal observations, but there are others, no longer classified as essential, which nevertheless give food for thought:
- The observation recommending a clearer reference to the applicability of the Decree to the persons and entities holding the reserved rights to operate lotteries, to whom the so-called principles of responsible gambling also apply.
- The observation concerning the distinction between the concepts of players' “self-exclusion” and “self-prohibition”, which appears at certain points in the Draft, an issue that may generate extensive debate, has so far lacked sufficient doctrinal development, and merits a much fuller commentary of its own.
- The observation concerning the promotional activities encountered in practice, which the Council mentions in general terms and appears to be familiar with. It is curious to note, and nobody had done so until now, that the Council of State points out that, if offering loans to players is expressly prohibited as contrary to the principle of responsible gambling, as framed in the Draft text, why does the prohibition not extend to “gifts” and “all kinds of offers”? (the words in quotation marks are a verbatim transcription; I believe it is referring to the practice of promotional bonuses… although it does not describe them.)
In short, all these are issues of considerable legal and practical significance which undoubtedly made it advisable to reconsider approval of the Decree at that time. The Government faced a choice upon receiving that Opinion. Either amend the Draft text in the terms indicated in its contents; or disregard it and approve it without amending the proposed text, with whatever short- and long-term consequences might ensue (that is, a challenge by certain groups)…; or simply leave it in a drawer.
That is where we stand today. The Minister has therefore merely “dusted off” the Draft in the same state in which it was left in 2018 (Opinion included). And returned to this “starting square”.
Furthermore, neither the passage of this Draft nor the Opinion on it reveals any other reason justifying action by the Central Government on other matters also attracting media interest. Neither intervention in land-based gambling, which has nothing to do with the former, nor regulation of its advertising, responsibility for which lies with the Autonomous Communities.
We shall be watching the next chapters of this peculiar tangle.
Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.
Madrid,10 February 2010