Gaming & Gambling

Online Gambling Contracts. DGOJ Guidance. Why and for What Purpose.

Carlos Lalanda ·

The Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) of the Ministry of Finance has submitted for public consultation the so-called \»Guidance on the drafting and content of the general terms of gambling contracts subject to a State licence\» . And a period has been allowed  for the receipt of contributions, which will end on 12 April 2019.

It is certainly difficult to know, particularly for anyone unfamiliar with the operation of gambling websites licensed by the DGOJ,  which legal regime applies to the so-called \»General Terms and Conditions\» governing the use of gambling websites, since they actually concern various contractual aspects which,  in turn, depend on different bodies of legislation. Online operators are indeed required to draw them up, but amid a sea of complexities which, in some cases, lead to unfair terms and give rise to increasing litigation.

Through this initiative, the DGOJ seeks to clarify certain concepts and ultimately provide some solutions in fulfilment of its role of protecting participants' interests, which is one of its principal functions under Law 13/2011 on the Regulation of Gambling (Art. 21.9).

What is being submitted for \»consultation\»?

The work undertaken by the DGOJ is concentrated in an eight-page summary document entitled Guidance on the drafting and content of the general terms of gambling contracts subject to a State licence , together with various aspects to be taken into account in their application\», accompanied by a useful and original tool, through which members of the public can record their agreement or disagreement with each paragraph ( by way of a \»vote\»), as well as individual comments on each paragraph. Any opinion expressed and submitted on the website will subsequently be published ( unless otherwise indicated), in an exercise in exemplary transparency.

It is also essential to analyse the accompanying \»Explanatory Memorandum\» to understand the legal basis and nature of this action, but also its limitations. For, as I shall summarise below, this is an initiative which merely seeks to encourage operators to incorporate voluntarily into their contractual documents the general principles it contains, in a context of minimal intervention in the relations between gambling operators and participants which has underpinned the Gambling Law and its implementing regulations from the outset.

Lastly, the DGOJ has decided to promote a \»seal\» to encourage good practices in participant care, which will be awarded on the basis of the criteria and requirements incorporated into the final wording of this Guidance, and which will be related to this guidance and other online gambling customer care measures, as explained in an accompanying <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Annex to the document.

Preliminary issue: the distinction between gambling contracts and the \»general terms and conditions\» published by operators.

The so-called \»general terms and conditions\» which appear on all online gambling operators' websites do not merely govern the relations arising from \»gambling contracts in the strict sense\» ( those entered into for each bet on roulette, bingo, virtual gaming machines, or sports betting, etc.) , but also include and seek to comply with all manner of administrative obligations  scattered throughout both the Gambling Law itself and its implementing Decrees, and sector-specific legislation  on Consumers and Users, such  as the Consolidated Text under Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, as well as the provisions of Law 7/1998 on General Contractual Terms, the Law on Information Society Services, and  the Organic Law on Data Protection (LOPD). Such is the profusion of different rules and obligations that it is hardly surprising that operators, from the outset, provided extremely lengthy documents drawn from previous experience of Anglo-Saxon law, under which many operators have their headquarters, retaining clauses which rather reflect formulations and requirements that do not always coincide with our own.

The \»gambling contract\» in the strict sense is regulated by our Civil Code. But this dates from 1889, and is ill-suited to the present-day manifestations of the types and categories of gambling and their various elements. However, the \»gambling contract\» regulated by Decree 1614/2011, implementing Law 13/2011, in Articles 31 et seq., encompasses  certain elements of the gambling contracts specifically regulated by the Civil Code, but also those of a \»gambling account contract\», which is different and not specifically regulated (as is also the case, for example, with any bank current account contract).

Thus, the \»General Terms and Conditions\» are in fact those of several different contracts which must, moreover, be adapted to and comply with various requirements imposed on consumer contracting generally, since these are relations between businesses and \»consumers or users\»; and are, moreover, offered over the Internet. The task of drawing up Instructions on these clauses (as much as that of actually drawing up these General Terms and Conditions) is Herculean, since a multidisciplinary perspective is needed to determine what they should contain,  and how best to express it. And this lies at the heart of the \»protective\» function assigned to the administrative body.

The voluntary nature of the Guidance adopted by the DGOJ

The Gambling Law and its implementing regulation opted for \»minimal intervention\» in the operator's contractual relations with participants in gambling, as in many other aspects of online gambling. There is only a brief reference to the need for participants expressly to accept the \»gambling contract\» and any amendments to it and to obtain a copy, followed by an outline of its content and conditions. However, its final content is left to the operators' discretion and determination, subject to certain obligations and rights for both parties described in Articles 33 and 34. The most important obligation in this respect is that laid down in the Specifications for the various licensing calls: the submission of the General Terms and Conditions to be displayed on the website.

However, acceptance of the Guidance submitted for consultation is not mandatory, and all the effort expended on the DGOJ's initiative ultimately rests on its opening statement:  these are \»guidelines\», references\» or \»recommendations\» concerning general principles  contained in the summary Document, for licensed operators to incorporate (if they wish) into their own terms published on their websites,  very much in line with what the Memorandum itself evokes: \»the sphere of soft law\» or \»European bussines soft law\» used by the European Commission, which to many, particularly the more traditional, sounds like \»fine words with little substance\». Nevertheless, this is the fashion, and it does no harm for someone  to undertake these analyses and facilitate a path which would otherwise be difficult or impossible to navigate.

It is true that Decree 1614/2011 itself  provides that the National Gambling Commission may venture into contractual wording and issue \»instructions\» in this regard, particularly in relation to contractual terms which may be considered unfair or detrimental to participants or harmful to the public interest (Art. 32.2). However, the \»Guidance\» submitted for public consultation does not address this specific issue, although, as the Memorandum itself acknowledges, numerous complaints in this regard have historically been received from users ( or not so many, depending on one's perspective).

The Ministry has not opted to approve \»Model gambling contracts\», as permitted by Art. 32.3 of Royal Decree 1614/2016. This is immaterial, however, since that provision does not refer to \»Mandatory models\» either, but to voluntary ones.

Content of the proposed Guidance

The intention, therefore, is that operators should ultimately consider the drafting of their terms with regard to various considerations and statements of general principles around which this Guidance is structured and on which the preparation of the General Terms and Conditions must be based:  the principles of legality, information, usefulness of information, and responsibility, and the principles of giving reasons and interpretation.

These principles are largely drawn from the extensive formulations and requirements contained in the Law on Consumers and Users, the Law on General Contractual Terms, the Law on Data Protection, and the Law on Information Society Services, which do indeed contain binding requirements that operators must take into account. And these are what actually define the limits of validity of the contracts of adhesion offered to participants in online gambling. A genuine compilation effort and a reminder that online gambling is not exempt from these cross-cutting matters and rules

However, in my view, and irrespective of the educational work which the initiative undoubtedly represents, a fuller implementation of the general mandate to protect participants would have required  the choice of far more precise and effective techniques to safeguard users' rights. For example, compulsory registration in the Register of General Contractual Terms (within the Register of Movable Property, administered by the Registrars), or the introduction of alternative dispute resolution procedures without the need to resort to the ordinary courts. But this would only be possible by amending the Gambling Law or its implementing Regulation.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Madrid, 20 March 2018

More publications