Gaming & Gambling

Tax on Online Gambling: the Miracle of the Loaves and Fishes

Carlos Lalanda ·

Recourse to a biblical parable is always a recurring approach when seeking to explain something which, although fundamentally very complex, can be simplified through highly graphic and descriptive symbols.

And as John and Mark tell us, at certain times Christ's followers were so numerous that the disciples were overwhelmed when they had to feed them at mass gatherings; on several occasions Christ performed the miracle and five loaves and five fishes were multiplied to the satisfaction of the faithful and the organisers of the event.

We shall endeavour to use this parable to illustrate, and describe as a miracle, what is intended with the revenue from the Tax on Online Gambling, in terms of its amounts and their distribution. And to avoid harbouring false hopes.

The Tax on Online Gambling:  how much is collected each year.

The fragmentation of information makes it very difficult to quantify the revenue from this Tax, which applies to online betting and gambling, and also to SELAE's betting.

A simple Excel spreadsheet would allow all the information needed in this case to be extracted. Approximately 160 entries (4 quarterly tax returns X some 40 active online companies) would give us exact and complete information on the amounts collected under this heading.

As the tax authorities never publish the overall figure, and publish the information in a highly segmented manner, we have to extrapolate the data provided by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) in its quarterly and annual Reports on amounts wagered and prizes awarded, since this enables us to deduce the taxable bases of the Tax. And if we assume that all companies, including SELAE, pay everything they are required to pay, we can reconcile the figures in a table.

Thus, in 2015, revenue under “ordinary” headings should have been approximately €80 million (of which €43 million under the Betting heading), and in 2016, €108 million (of which  €59 million under the Betting heading)

In addition, the Tax paid by SELAE, based on football pools and pari-mutuel horse-racing betting, amounted to €61.6 million in 2015, and this figure is always obtained through other sources of information, such as its Annual Accounts.  This phenomenon of taxing SELAE has had a distorting effect, since, although it is the same Tax, it has been considered “separately”, and, as we can see, it accounts for more than 40% of the total in 2015. The revenue under this heading for 2016 is not yet known, but we shall assume that it remains unchanged.

The total sum of both items, that is, the revenue accrued for the 2015 financial year, amounted to €141.6 million (80+61.6). And for 2016 it is expected to reach €170 million (108+61.6).

 Where each year's revenue goes.

 A particular feature arises here, since the ultimate destination of the above amounts has depended on numerous historical and “de facto” factors which constitute a genuine exception to the rule that a State Tax is collected by the State and contributes, without earmarking, to the State Budget. These distortions are more or less implicit in Law 13/2011 on Gambling.

  1. Revenue from Betting and Gambling “located” in any of the Spanish Autonomous Communities (CCAA) is collected by the State, but goes to the Resources and Budgets of the respective Autonomous Communities. This is what was “agreed” in extremis in the final stages of the Law's passage through Parliament. By elimination, revenue from foreigners remains with the State.

Technically, this mandate is incomplete, since its definitive application depends on the general formulae established for the Financing of the Autonomous Communities. A Solomonic criterion was provisionally adopted for its distribution:  that the Autonomous Communities receive a quarterly cheque proportional to the amount wagered in each Community by its residents who actually gamble. A definitive allocation in the Law on the Financing of the Autonomous Communities must be awaited; in the meantime, it remains provisional.

  1. Revenue from SELAE's Football Pools and Horse-racing Betting, as well as the tax amounts “related” to foreign players, goes to the General State Budget. However, we also find an “earmarked” application of revenue from SELAE's Betting (Third Additional Provision), with very specific distribution percentages; or from Betting in General (Sixth Additional Provision), to be developed by regulation, without specifying percentages or destinations, “pending” resolution.

Table of Online Gambling Tax Revenue/Distribution 2015

A simplified table graphically explains the movement of the funds generated by this Tax:

Revenue/Destinations

2015

Autonomous Communities Provincial Councils Liga Futbol Profesional RFEF State Totals
Revenue(Betting) (100% resid.)

€42m

0 0 0 0 €42m
Revenue(Other gambling) (100% resid.)

€37m

0 0 0 0 €37m
Revenue /Football pools and other SELAE 0 (49.95%)

€30.8m

(45.50%)

€28m

(4.55%) €2.8m 0 €61.6m
Revenue/foreign players 0 (100% foreign)

€1m

*estimated

€1m
Totals 79 30.8 28 2.8 1 141.6

The confusion surrounding the destinations and earmarking of the Tax

The foregoing being clear and concise, the difficulty lies in the possibility of modifying this distribution.

Although it is not the first to try, a political party (Ciudadanos) has proposed in the Spanish Parliament that part of the betting heading be allocated to various needs: grassroots sport, amateur and professional sporting structures, participation in international competitions, and combating conduct which undermines the integrity of sport, such as illegal betting, manipulation of sporting results and doping; and, in passing, also to the “horse-racing industry”. It also calls on the (National) Government to implement the Sixth Additional Provision of Law 13/2011, which states that the earmarking of a percentage of tax revenue from sports or horse-racing betting for a specific purpose will be regulated. According to the above table, a portion of the €42 million (2015).

We do not know for certain whether what it is ultimately proposing is a “new tax”, which is not for the Government to develop but for Parliament itself, or that the same Tax should be “distributed” differently in terms of its destination or earmarking, which, incidentally, would also be a matter for Parliament.

The difficulty of a new distribution

As we have seen, the amounts must necessarily match: the amounts distributed are necessarily equal to those collected. The miracle of the loaves and fishes cannot be applied here.

Thus, the motion consists of saying that the Government should do what it is required to do, but why has it not done so? How easy or difficult is it for the Government? Let us analyse this point by point:

Point 1.    Under our General Budgetary system, and subject to exceptions, taxes are not collected on the basis of specific purposes or earmarking (Art. 27.3 of the General Budgetary Law (LGP)). This principle can be explained in greater detail, but it forms part of a state of affairs: a single treasury, governability, avoidance of chaos, etc.

Point 2.   The distribution of revenue from football pools forms part of a more or less historical legacy. Modifying it amounts to a kind of “casus belli”. This distribution dates from the time of ONLAE or even earlier, its current structure dates from Decree 419/1991, and it is recognised down to hundredths in the Gambling Law of 2011. Historically, this was not the “earmarking of a Tax”, but rather a direct subsidy from the State Budget, which, on the one hand, received monopoly revenue from Lotteries and Football Pools (into the General Budget), and distributed it as expenditure or subsidies.

Point 3.  The exact “return” of current Football Pools revenue is set out in the Law (Third Additional Provision), but because of a circumstance coinciding in time: the transformation of LAE into SELAE, in the same year, 2012, in which the Tax began to apply; consequently, it was no longer possible to maintain a “direct subsidy” from a Public Limited Company to the Provincial Councils (which, curiously, the same party, Ciudadanos, has made it a flagship policy to abolish), or to the Liga de Futbol Profesional, or to the RFEF. All these cost centres could (and should, at least in the first case) be subsidised through the State Budget or, where appropriate, the Budgets of the Autonomous Communities.

Point 4. The “other return” which remains to be implemented (that of the Sixth Additional Provision) does not concern a percentage calculated on the amount wagered (as Ciudadanos' proposal appears to suggest), but rather on the Tax revenue itself, in its betting variant (that is, neither “Other gambling” nor Competitions would be included here). And, moreover, an unspecified percentage. But what percentage? Would this amount then be deducted from the amount allocated to the Autonomous Communities?

The chimera of a new distribution

Several attempts have been made to implement this Sixth Additional Provision. Without success. Above all, by the horse-racing sector, whose claims have supposedly been “forgotten” from the outset. Let us note here that revenue from the Tax on Horse-racing Betting amounts to little more than €1 million per year.

These attempts have always encountered the same obstacles. The first lies in the Additional Provision itself, which delegates to a Regulation what, once again, only a Law can do (see the LGP and the principle that earmarking is “reserved to statute”). However, there are other, more obvious obstacles, such as the interests of those “affected by reallocation”, that is, all the Autonomous Communities, but also, in the event of a “general readjustment”, all the Provincial Councils, the Liga de Futbol Profesional and the RFEF. All or some of them would receive less.

Would it not be more logical and appropriate to meet all the needs described through ordinary public Budgets; that is, for the honourable Members themselves to decide and approve how Taxes are to be distributed, rather than requiring the Government to do so? Of course, it would then be the Members of Parliament themselves who would have to contend with all the Autonomous Communities, with the Professional Football Clubs, with the RFEF……. No small matter.

In the absence of a miracle such as that of the loaves and fishes, we can only hope for other chimeras applicable to the case: the transmutation of the philosopher's stone into gold. Or squaring the circle.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

Loyra Abogados

17 March 2017

More publications