Gaming & Gambling

“ONLINE SCRATCHCARDS”. A problem out of focus

Carlos Lalanda ·

The expression “online scratchcards” is circulating in newspapers and publications to describe the traditional “tickets” for pre-drawn lotteries, which are also beginning to be operated online, for now on the ONCE websites (www.juegosonce.es), and on those of EAJA (www.lotocat.es) as regards Catalonia.

But what is the true nature of these offerings? Are they really tickets that are “scratched”? Are they lotteries?

It is important to arrive at a clear answer, since the applicable legal regime will differ depending on whether they are one thing or another, and their legality could even be called into question. Both ONCE and EAJA in Catalonia rely, within their respective territorial spheres, on their power to operate Lotteries under a concession (ONCE), or directly (EAJA), including pre-drawn or “instant” lotteries. Indeed, SELAE has announced the possible marketing of this class of products.

In this article I shall examine the difficulties in legally justifying this new “online” gambling offering, and its possible physical manifestations, which some have taken to renaming “video lottery machines”.

It is necessary to review the limits of the offerings of ONCE and EAJA under their respective legal titles to operate Lotteries.

The ONCE concession regime, a legal muddle

Before examining the problems arising from instant Lotteries and their limits, the most controversial issue, and the most difficult to explain, is the justification for ONCE’s concession regime itself, which is truly exceptional.

At a lecture I attended, a legal expert on ONCE’s gambling regime expressed himself in the following surprising terms when defining it: “The regime governing ONCE’s games is what it is, and no Court has dared to question its validity”.

On the one hand, ONCE has been classified in case law as a Public-Law Corporation, with all the particular features that this status entails: it does not form part of the State, and has separate legal personality, but is subject to State supervision. On the other hand, until the Law on the Regulation of Gambling of 2011, the operation of Lotteries in Spain fell within the sphere of State Monopolies. Any Agreement or Concession with ONCE simply fell within the rules of Administrative Law governing administrative concessions for the management of the Monopoly.

However, it is necessary to distinguish two phases, before and after the aforementioned Law.

Phase 1. Before the Gambling Law, ONCE’s post-constitutional legal regime is based on Additional Provision 20 of Law 46/1985: this is a “referral” provision without substantive content, because the substantive limit will lie in whatever is Agreed with the Council of Ministers. And while the initial Agreements concerned the so-called “coupon for the blind”, the concession was subsequently extended to other games described in later Agreements, which have always been confined to “lotteries”, and within these to certain very specific types. As there was no legal definition of “lotteries”, it was necessary to rely on the ordinary meaning of the concept, and its distinction from other closely related concepts within games of chance. This is how the Agreements were extended to “Instant Lotteries” (commonly “scratchcards”), and to “active” Lotteries (Lotto-type games, such as Eurojackpot, etc.) or semi-active lotteries (sales at petrol stations, for example).

The validity of the concession granted by the Council of Ministers to ONCE was justified by reasoning along these lines: since all classes of Lotteries have historically fallen within the scope of the State monopoly, any of their forms may be “conceded” to anyone, whether a public or private organiser. In this case, given ONCE’s public nature, this was a concessionary act of self-organisation taking the form of an “Agreement”. As in the case of the various Public Authorities which Agree upon or draw up cooperation or assistance Agreements, or Management Entrustment Agreements.

Phase 2. Since the Gambling Law. However, when the Gambling Law was passed in 2011, this regime proceeded from a different proposition. Lotteries are defined in Article 3(b) and their management is no longer entrusted to a State “Monopoly”, at least not an explicit one, insofar as SELAE has been constituted as a public limited company governed by Private Law. Lotteries are now subject to a “reservation”, in the sense that they may be operated only by those entities designated by Law 13/2011, which include ONCE. Curiously, when the Law seeks to delimit the position of ONCE’s Lotteries, it decides to exclude them from its application in every respect (Additional Provision 5), so that even the penalty regime (its own, not that of Law 13/2011) falls to the Supervisory Council to develop. This is a genuine legal muddle, for although it is true that the manner in which this power is acquired is referred, once again, to Additional Provision 20 of Law 46/1985, it is difficult to understand how this “general grant of powers in blank” can subsist today, when that of 1985 was founded on a Fiscal Monopoly regime which no longer exists, and there is no other connection with Law 13/2011.

ONCE obtains the concession to operate “tickets” or scratchcards”, and subsequently we reach their online operation, the so-called “online scratchcards”.

The so-called \»Monopoly” is not a “scratchcard”.

Through perseverance and patience, ONCE earned the inclusion within its concession of new forms of lotteries, namely instant or pre-drawn lotteries, as a means of expanding the list contained in the Agreements with the Council of Ministers, which is where its commercial offering is essentially regulated. That offering originally concerned the “coupon”, which was and remains a true lottery of the so-called “passive” kind; that is, a draw of numbers included on a ticket. Subsequently, the concept of “active lotteries” was introduced and authorised, in which the numbers making up the ticket are chosen by the player, and a draw is also held at regular intervals (for example, “Eurojackpot”).

After several years of uncertainty and the referral of several questions of constitutionality by the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) against the initial inclusions in the Agreements, Instant Lotteries passed constitutional scrutiny in Constitutional Court (TC) judgments 32/2012 and 133/2012, which declare that the operation of these lotteries does not encroach upon the powers of the Autonomous Communities, since they are nationwide in scope.

The evolution of the content of the Council of Ministers’ Agreement, as successively amended, does not, however, stop at aspects of operating an instant lottery based on a physical paper or cardboard ticket which has evolved, according to its latest version. It has also been extended to its “online” form, in which the meaning of “scratching” becomes obsolete and it must be understood that, in this form, the concealed box on which the player acts is not “scratched”, but “revealed”. In some of the more simply operated “online scratchcards”, the object of the game is indeed to “reveal” or trigger a combination of numbers, but also of symbols or graphics, in order to obtain a prize if the combination is a winning one.

Prizes are normally predetermined or pre-drawn according to a matrix programmed by the system, which establishes the prize structure within a statistical series.

When viewing an ONCE (or EAJA) scratchcard Website, the player’s perception differs from that provided by a physical “scratchcard”. It could, for example, be the following:

“A game in which, in exchange for the price of a play, the user is granted a period of use with the aim of obtaining a combination of signs or graphic representations which, in accordance with the specific rules of the game, wins a particular prize.”

But beware ……is this the legal definition of “online scratchcard” tickets?

It is not: it is the regulatory definition of “online slot machines” approved in Order HAP/1370/2014 of the Ministry of Finance, which regulates these forms of gambling. These are certainly distinct from Lotteries (slot machines are classified under “Other games”, Article 3(f) of Law 13/2011), and require a General Licence of this class, in addition to the Specific Licence for “Slot machines”. Any current online scratchcard could be described in this way from a player’s perspective. Even the scratchcard called Monopoly, recently introduced and advertised, is governed by “virtual dice”, whose random value determines the movement of the playing piece around the board. The player does not purchase a ticket to participate in a draw, but rather “plays with dice”. There is a category regulated in another State Order, this time that concerning “Complementary Games”, which could also fit this latest ONCE game.

With these “online scratchcards”, we are therefore witnessing a veritable “pirouette” over the theoretical legal barrier that should separate the concepts of “lotteries” and “other games of chance” in the strict sense, whose legal considerations and regimes are radically different. For example, ONCE should obtain a Licence if it wishes to operate “Other games”, pay the Gambling Levy in respect of them, etc.

Let it be recorded here that this is not the only conceptual leap we have identified among those recently occurring in the various online gambling offerings, and whose compliance with the law is highly doubtful.

And there are already precedents involving similar cases. The US State of Minnesota included “scratchcards” in its online gambling offering, under its power to offer and sell lottery products, including via the Internet. The Governor had to suspend their operation following numerous protests alleging that the legal powers had been exceeded, since games of chance (“gambling”) remain prohibited in that State too, and their operation is even subject to criminal penalties.

EAJA and its “online scratchcards”

 EAJA was established as an Autonomous Body for the direct operation of games reserved to the Government of Catalonia, and the regulations subsequently refer to lotteries as the subject of its activity.

As in ONCE’s case, EAJA has also recently been authorised, through the Autonomous Community’s own regulatory measures, to operate all its “lotteries” online, including instant lotteries or “scratchcards”, although this time within the nebulous “Catalan online” sphere (this too, it must be said, is an antithetical term, a contradiction).

And the ways in which these scratchcards operate are equally doubtful in legal terms, since the player’s perception is exactly the same as that described above: rather than betting on a lottery, the player appears to be facing a slot machine, since each “draw” takes place instantaneously, the system chooses a symbol and the winning or losing combination is obtained instantaneously, in a matter of seconds.

 Online scratchcard terminals.

Lastly, the bells are being rung in celebration because the current state of technology allows these online scratchcards to be operated through physical terminals located in establishments of any kind. A “round trip”.

Where these “online scratchcard terminals” are operated by a holder of State gambling rights (SELAE, ONCE), there is the additional controversy as to whether these terminals should require authorisation from the Autonomous Communities. However, when this is the only issue under debate, the answer is circumscribed by judicial decisions which have so far held that, in matters of State-reserved gambling (that is, nationwide “lotteries”), the powers of the Autonomous Communities give way.

This is not the real problem posed by these online scratchcard terminals.

As we have seen, we face a different problem: whether we are dealing with the operation of true games of chance through terminals, a matter not included within the concessionary or direct powers of SELAE, ONCE or EAJA, which could do so only in respect of terminals for true lotteries.

Carlos Lalanda Fernandez

Madrid, 2 June 2017

Loyra Abogados ( www.loyra.com”)

More publications