Gaming & Gambling
Proposals on the LGUM in the Gambling Sector.
Carlos Lalanda ·
We are witnessing intense debate and growing interest in the possible application of the principles of the Law on Market Unity (LGUM) to the gambling sector, crystallised in recent sectoral meetings where there has been an opportunity to exchange ideas and perceptions.
This is a recurring issue owing to the diversity and fragmentation of Autonomous Community regulations in this sector, even though the LGUM does not mention the gambling sector even in passing.
The Constitutional Court (TC) judgments delivered over the summer on this Law have declared several of its articles and Provisions null and void, notably those relating to the so-called “single national licence”. Yet, like a boomerang, they have opened up possible avenues for its useful application in a sector subject to such extensive intervention across the various Autonomous Communities.
There appears to be some consensus in identifying several areas for analysis and work in relation to the following matters:
- Coordination or Simplification of access to the various Gambling Registers.
- In particular, the treatment of security deposits.
- Coordination or Simplification of type approvals for gaming machines, systems and equipment.
- Other common matters covered by the regulations of the various Autonomous Communities (CCAA).
This call for simplification has long come primarily from businesses, which are the ones affected by this multiple administrative intervention and repeatedly express it through their business associations, but receive different responses from the Public Administrations:
- The Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ). It appears to be leading an approach aimed at coordination and the removal of numerous burdens.
- The CCAA. Views are divided, although there are generally reservations.
The conclusion has been reached, and this was the prevailing view at the last Castilla y León Congress, attended by most of the regulators involved in this matter, that, on the basis of the LGUM, the Gambling Policy Council (CPJ) can serve as a forum for addressing these issues, as has already been attempted and included in its work agendas since 2014. Nevertheless, the effort must pursue two lines of objectives: as regards putting forward proposals, and adopting decisions that are effective:
- The matters to be addressed should be examined in greater depth within the so-called Working Groups, as has already been done in some cases. Both the DGOJ and those CCAA with greater proactivity or practical experience must identify the matters and propose “common standards”, e.g. for gaming machine requirements, arrangements for coordinating Registers, etc.
- The decisions adopted in that forum must formally serve to ensure effective and progressive application in the various territories. On this point, it is crucial to complete the adaptation of the Council's internal rules to Law 40/2015, which is underway to bring this Body into line with the regime governing Sectoral Cooperation Conferences.
Thus, the implementation framework would involve the following process:
- Proposal of common regulatory standards on specific matters. To be developed by the Council's Working Groups.
- Classification of the standard as suitable for an Agreement or a Recommendation.
- Approval by the CPJ of the Agreement or Recommendation in accordance with its new internal rules. These decisions would not apply in those CCAA whose representative members had voted against them, or would apply only in accordance with the separate opinion they had issued.
- Publication of the Agreement or Recommendation in the Official State Gazette (BOE).
For the above framework to be genuinely effective, it would be advisable to include, from now on, in the respective Gambling Laws of the CCAA, a clause (Additional Provision) in the following or similar terms:
“The common technical standards approved by the State's coordination and cooperation bodies in gambling matters shall have regulatory force where they are subscribed to by the Autonomous Community.”
With this legislative reinforcement, the decisions of the CPJ would achieve genuine practical application. The LGUM would have proved useful to this sector.
Madrid, 28 November 2017.
Carlos Lalanda