Gaming & Gambling

Psychosis

Carlos Lalanda ·

One of the most seasoned experts on the gambling sector, Juan Ferrer, in his digital column last Friday, has put his finger on the sore spot, or better still, has found the right term to understand what, at this very moment, is happening around games of chance and betting in Spain: psychosis.

Some of us who have long worked professionally in the field of gambling, studying its regulation and rules, defending interests, or resolving related disputes, cannot understand this phenomenon, nor are we best placed to analyse it. We normally approach our arguments using a technique governed by logic. Law and legal rules are considered to derive from this philosophical knowledge of premises and logical consequences.

This has nothing to do with social psychology, which nevertheless tends to be one of the driving forces behind the formation of law. Although law is normally classified as a social science, there are others, such as sociology and psychology, which bear greater responsibility for analysing “social psychology”.

Social psychosis, by contrast, is not strictly a scientific category, but rather an inexact term, a way of expressing, by analogy, the behaviour of a society in terms or attributes corresponding to an individual mental illness characterised by delusions and hallucinations. It nevertheless serves as a teaching tool to explain social phenomena, such as what is happening in the gambling sector in Spain.

Writers such as Rubén Amón, in his article in El País of 5 January 2019: “Populism and social psychosis” have framed this issue very accurately, referring to forms of populism further to the right on the ideological spectrum and explaining them in terms of the irresponsible but conscious stimulation of social psychosis through the misrepresentation and distortion of certain real and sensitive problems. There is no proportion between the actual problem and the perception of the problem.

The social psychosis in the gambling sector to which I refer might rather be identified with forms of populism further to the left; but make no mistake, this is another of those phenomena in which the extremes “meet”. In Juego y Sociedad en España 2019 (UC3M, tenth annual survey in the Percepción de los Juegos de Azar en España series), a curious finding emerged: negative attitudes towards gambling came from respondents who considered themselves further to the left, but also from the more traditional respondents on the right.

Symptoms of Psychosis

We find evidence every day of the distortion of information that develops into “psychosis” about gambling, merely by opening the newspapers, watching special programmes on public and private television channels, or following parliamentary and assembly debates, as has been the case for some time now.

As with other social psychoses, fuelled by fears and insecurities associated with disasters or contagion (it is common to describe gambling addiction as an “epidemic” or even a “pandemic” in order to instil fear), there are real events which may be trivial or insignificant, but which are exaggerated or amplified by the power of social media and the dissemination of information today.

By way of example, it has even been published that there are 600,000 gambling addicts undergoing treatment in Spain . Nobody, not even the centres or associations specialising in assisting people addicted to gambling or betting, has undertaken to compile comprehensive data on this group, which deserves attention; from the little partial data available to us, they do not appear to exceed 10,000, as can be inferred (with methodological difficulty) from the Ministry of Health's data (Report on the National Plan against Drugs). Nor is there comprehensive knowledge of how many receive psychiatric treatment in hospitals, but they should not exceed 1,000 throughout Spain, according to certain partial reports. Nobody among those responsible for healthcare has undertaken this simple compilation.

As regards gambling or betting for money by minors, beyond the surveys (erratic and impossible to cross-check, often including concepts such as video games or other games not involving money), there are few proven instances of its existence. No more than a few dozen cases have been documented over several years (perhaps we could raise that to hundreds, who knows), some of them particularly striking, notably last year in the Lotería del Niño but here, too, there are no other aggregate data that have genuinely been analysed. Citizens aged 18 and over (and I have even seen “up to 25”) are regarded in many surveys as “adolescents”, and are lumped together with minors, which reveals a profound ignorance of the reality of the twenty-first century.

There is also daily exaggeration of the economic figures for this activity. Although more accurate data are available than for the foregoing matters, the known business figures are constantly confused and exaggerated in the media, in order to satisfy readers or viewers with regard to a preconceived argument; and figures relating to the contribution of capital or public wealth (tax revenue, employment) are always omitted. It has even been said that the gambling “business” or “profit” in Spain reached €40,000 million in 2018; whereas the reality is that private companies, on estimated and broadly approximate figures, obtained less than €3,000 million in gross earnings, after paying the special levies (I am not counting “public” lottery companies, because I do not believe that the columnists and those spreading these claims include them in the colloquial concept of “profit-making” enterprises). And with that €3,000 million, the private sector must remunerate the hospitality operators or landlords of premises where gambling facilities are installed (150,000 premises and business operators), reducing this amount by almost half; and with the remainder it must still pay employees and suppliers, make investments, etc., like any other private business operator. We have gone from 40,000 to less than 1,000, distributed, moreover, among thousands of companies organising gambling.

Compare the figures and you will see the difference.

Only yesterday, a highly respected representative of the Government of Catalonia expressed surprise at all this collective psychosis because, at least in that Autonomous Community, the entire supply of games of chance has been “frozen” for 15 or 20 years, with no additional gambling premises having been authorised since then, the few gambling addicts whose condition has clinical consequences are treated in Catalan hospitals, and policies to prevent this addiction have been in place for years. Everything can always be improved, of course, but the Mayor of Barcelona stated that she had taken measures to restrict the dangers of gambling by not authorising new betting shops which are neither provided for by law nor within her power to authorise.

The psychosis feeds on another real fact, this time a very powerful one from a psychological perspective: the excessive advertising of new online games of chance in audiovisual media, an excess about which warnings have been issued from all quarters for many years. And on which the new Government is, quite logically, going to take immediate measures. (An advertising excess which could also be alleged in respect of products that provide excessive sugar in food, medicines, etc.).

Precedents of social psychoses (which led to tragedies)

It is not that we are dealing with comparable cases, but it is worth recalling a couple of examples in which social psychosis radically transformed things, penetrating the system of coexistence and driving a transformation of the law which paved the way for catastrophe:

Example 1. The elimination of paganism by the new religious currents of the time (fourth century). In this case, the propagation of populist arguments originating from the Christian vanguard spread the \»demonisation “(the term dates from then) of the religious beliefs that had sustained Greek and Roman civilisations. This case has not been sufficiently analysed, because it led to the physical disappearance of the evidence, both personal and material: monuments, buildings and statues were reduced to dust, libraries and pagans to ashes on pyres and in public squares. It is now being studied much more thoroughly as one of the most unfortunate examples of populism that led to collective psychosis.: “ La Edad de la penumbra” Catherine Nixey..Taurus, cites as the trigger and decisive Rubicon the Edict of Milan (AD 313) of Emperor Constantine, who not only converted to Christianity but was also pushed into establishing in that enactment the “religious freedom” which surreptitiously condemned the defenders of the ancient beliefs.

Example 2. The rise of nationalisms in the nineteenth century and, above all, their exacerbation and culmination in German National Socialism, whose history, being more recent, is much better known and studied. The collective psychosis of the German people, fostered by propaganda, gave rise to one of humanity's worst disasters. As in other cases, there are always common breeding grounds which act as catalysts for populism, such as economic crises. The advent of Nazism had its precursors in the crisis caused by the “reparations” of the First World War, the hyperinflations of the 1920s and the stock market crisis of 1929. As is known, the Rubicon here was the enthronement of the dictator but, above all, with the democratic political parties degraded, the enactment of the Enabling Act of 24 March 1933 officially entitled the Law to Remedy the Distress of the People and the State, which de facto eliminated legislative power. Then came the material and human ashes.

It is not that things are the same now, because collective psychoses are complex manifestations, but this is reaching a high point as regards the gambling sector in Spain. Targeted protests, graffiti and anti-gambling demonstrations are the order of the day. From this point onwards, factors come into play on which only the most experienced social psychologists can offer advice.

Psychotherapy

The prevailing psychosis extends to the point that the coalition Government has been structured with a new Ministry, that of Consumer Affairs, which will largely be devoted to trying to resolve this issue by attempting to “regulate gambling”, although in reality the most significant part of land-based gambling is managed by the private sector, and responsibility for its regulatory oversight rests with all the Autonomous Communities (CCAA) under their Statutes of Autonomy, for more than 30 years now in some cases and 20 in most; and this activity has been developing normally and routinely within their respective regulatory frameworks.

Thus, it is not the Minister but the State that would have an arduous legislative task ahead of it in addressing the “social alarm” said to prevail: on the one hand, amending all the Statutes of Autonomy, taking over all powers in this area, which frankly seems difficult to me. And, more difficult still, it could also raise the age of majority, for example to 21 or above, so that the prohibition on gambling and entering into contracts would extend to our “adolescents”. Unthinkable.

It is to be hoped that this psychosis does not invade governmental decisions and that good sense prevails.

As has been said about addiction to games of chance and betting at a recent conference on the subject, and by analogy, a good starting point is to recognise that a psychosis about gambling prevails in Spain. For the time being, the Minister responsible, in his presentation of the Decree on Online Gambling Advertising, also on Friday and with demonstrators at the Ministry's door, acknowledged, and repeated, before his audience that “you cannot kill flies with cannon fire”, which I will take for now as a good beginning to collective psychotherapy. Moreover, he has appointed a legal philosopher as the Department's second-in-command and the person responsible for the matter, who will have much to say from now on.

For my part, I must leave you now, as I have just received a message on my wahtsapp from SELAE: this weekend there is a €51 million jackpot in the Euromillon; and another from the Catalan Grossa: 2 million more in the “pocket”. I am off to place a bet, lest someone else should win it.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Madrid, 20 February 2020.

More publications