Gaming & Gambling

Quo vadis, Gibraltar?

Carlos Lalanda ·

Gibraltar is a constant source of comment and analysis. There is much to discuss.

From complex reasoning from the perspective of international law to intermittent disputes over whether territorial waters have been encroached upon. Questions of sovereignty, history, smuggling or mere Andalusian humour frequently pepper newspapers and articles. Leaving aside quips about political or social circumstances, this time we cannot resist commenting on judicial news originating in the treatment of online gambling in Gibraltar, a thriving local industry.

I shall therefore comment on the recent Opinion of Advocate General Szpunar of the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) of 19-1-2016 in Case C-591/15, which concerns a reference for a preliminary ruling from the Administrative Court of England and Wales on a change to the taxation applicable to online gambling in the United Kingdom since 2014, which directly affects Gibraltar. And, in passing, the implications of “Brexit”, or the United Kingdom's withdrawal from the EU, for Gibraltar and its online gambling market in Spain.

Background to the case.

The matter under discussion before the CJEU concerns the taxation of participation in gambling by British people domiciled in the United Kingdom, which, until 2014, was not taxed in Great Britain where that participation took place through websites and the gambling operator was domiciled outside the island. This tax-exempt situation was attractive to companies domiciled in Gibraltar because they saved the United Kingdom's online gambling tax, which is 15% of the win. Moreover, their contribution to tax on profits was minimal, a characteristic feature of all business activities “carried out” in Gibraltar.

This exemption was not only attractive to these operators. For example, when an operator licensed in Spain obtained gambling revenue from residents of Great Britain (through a “.es” website), it was obliged to pay gambling tax in Spain (25% of the win). But not in the United Kingdom.

Now, if the player is domiciled in Great Britain, they are obliged to pay in both. Those operating through “.com” websites licensed in Gibraltar, and those operating through “.es” websites licensed in Spain. In other words, they seek to prevent this from happening and apply for a licence in Great Britain.

The obvious cause of this legislative amendment was the recent economic recession; to secure budgetary resources, Her Majesty's Government decided to put an end to this “dysfunction”, which, according to some estimates, meant forgoing some £300 million a year in revenue. At its proposal, Parliament approved two significant legislative changes in 2014: the first introduced an obligation for companies to obtain a licence in Great Britain if they wished to offer online gambling to residents of the island; the second,  in addition, amended the specific tax by shifting the connecting factor to the “place of consumption”.

As regards the first, we have already had occasion to comment at length on the amendment to the Gambling Act 2005 and the judicial rulings delivered by Mr Justice Green in 2014. (See articles on the Loyra Abogados website from 2014) .

As regards the tax amendment, it now comes before the CJEU in the case under discussion, raising the question of whether this tax  amendment affects the principle of freedom to provide services ……between the United Kingdom and Gibraltar …. as though they were separate legal entities within the EU.

From every perspective, it is striking to analyse the reasons why a matter such as this comes to be considered by the CJEU, the judicial body responsible for scrutinising Community law, and not for disputes between political entities within a Member State.

Who is bringing the challenge and what is sought in this case

As is apparent from the Opinion under analysis, the case has been referred by the Court of England and Wales for the CJEU to rule on whether “Gibraltar and the United Kingdom form part of a single Member State”, in connection with Article 56 of the EU Treaty, that is, the principle of freedom to provide services. It is true that the referring court, in its Decision of 14/7/2015  appears to have doubts on this point, since otherwise this matter could not have been raised before the European Court. However, no such doubts whatsoever existed even in the earlier decision of Mr Justice Green in the previous judgment of 2014, nor on the part of any of those appearing before the English court …… except the applicant Association … and the Government of Gibraltar as an interested party.

As regards Gibraltar's status, we all know that the United Kingdom's Act of Accession of 1973 has certain particular and special features, but everyone knows and is aware that Gibraltar is a “colony” of the United Kingdom (an almost unique historical remnant in the world), and that it forms part of the territory of the European Union only “because it is part of the United Kingdom”, since otherwise it would not enjoy the numerous prerogatives granted to Member States (or rather, “freedoms”) in relation to the free movement of persons or the provision of services. If it did not enjoy them, and the protection of the CJEU itself in several cases, Spain would probably have imposed entry and exit visas on persons at the border and refused “.es” gambling licences to gambling entities in Gibraltar. For tax purposes it is a genuine “tax haven”, and, at least in the case of corporation tax, this is legally permitted for the United Kingdom because the <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">General Court of the EU itself so ruled in its judgment of 18-12-2008. Above all because Gibraltar forms part of the United Kingdom for the purposes of the Treaty.

When the Court of England and Wales refers the question to the CJEU, it passes on a “hot potato” which only the courts of the United Kingdom have jurisdiction to resolve: how the United Kingdom imposes taxes on its own citizens. With due allowance for the differences, this is somewhat equivalent, in the Spanish legal system, to what happens with the financing of the Autonomous Communities, with their own or assigned taxes: it would be unthinkable for our own system, which is determined within the Spanish constitutional framework, to be debated before the CJEU. Utter nonsense.

All this is brought by the Gibraltar Betting and Gaming Association (GBGA), with the assent of the Government of Gibraltar as an interested party; and, to keep this matter alive, they proclaim far and wide that Gibraltar and the United Kingdom should be considered separate Members of the EU  and hope that the final judgment will so declare (see its latest press release). For his part, the Advocate General sets out and elaborates on the contrary position very clearly.

 A masterclass from the Advocate General on Gibraltar.

Faced with such a striking request, Advocate General Szpunar makes a titanic educational effort: to set out the reasons why this procedural “nonsense” must end with a self-evident conclusion which becomes the headline of the Court's Press Release: “The United Kingdom and Gibraltar are a single Member State for the purposes of freedom to provide services”. I would add …could anything else have been expected?.

The Advocate General tells us that we are dealing with a matter of domestic (British) law, simply because these questions concerning the taxing power of any Member State are matters of “national sovereignty”. This premise is sometimes forgotten because of its simplicity, and requires no explanation beyond its being the very essence of the European Treaty as we understand it today. The EU has not yet acquired “sovereignty” over this basic State power, which has its roots in history: States tax their citizens, and a tax on their citizens' participation in gambling is one further modern manifestation of this State power.

This tax, like many others, is at the disposal of State authorities without the EU having any say in the present context. The United Kingdom Government was free to exempt its citizens' gambling transactions from tax when the company was domiciled in Gibraltar or outside Great Britain, which was what happened before 2014; an exemption which also applied, for example, to gambling transactions by English citizens on websites holding Spanish licences, taxed by the Kingdom of Spain. This situation would now become a case of double taxation into which, according to the Advocate General, EU law does not enter because it is a matter of sovereignty. It must be resolved by the States in their Double Taxation Treaties.

From there, he enlightens us as to Gibraltar's position within the various scopes of application of EU law concerning fundamental freedoms. And the admittedly very complex reasons which align or distinguish Gibraltar's situation with that of other British Crown territories such as the Isle of Man, Jersey, etc . These are neither EU territory nor able to invoke the principle of freedom to provide services in their commercial relations.

The judicial decisions he cites lead to a very obvious conclusion: that Gibraltar is part of the EU only insofar as it is considered to be \»within the State of the United Kingdom”, which he describes to us with subtle irony from almost the very first paragraph:

“ 4. This case concerns relations between an island and a rock, but the reader will not have to undertake a long voyage to discover the outcome: …. Gibraltar and the United Kingdom must be considered a single entity.”

As to the remainder, and in case it is needed,  he also provides a very concise and clear analysis of the characteristics of the English tax model described in the case;  whether we are dealing with a direct or indirect tax; how the connecting factor for the tax liability is structured around the “point of consumption” (that is, the player's domicile), and even whether any excessive taxation which entails and results in the “restriction” of an activity, or in possible discrimination, can be examined in the light of Community law. Very useful reasoning of undoubted interest, whose application to the case is entirely ruled out, and which makes this Opinion a “piece of legal literature” of great value.

We shall see what the final judgment says on this matter, although we are inclined to think that it is unlikely to depart from this line……… if it is delivered at all, as we shall see below.

Brexit and Gibraltar: an earthquake on the Rock.

And all of the foregoing coincides, in terms of procedural timing, with Brexit, or the unilateral decision of the United Kingdom to leave the EU; a process for which we currently have two reference points: the popular referendum last June, and also the recent statement by the United Kingdom Government concerning the interpretation given to Brexit vis-à-vis the other Member States: the intention is that this departure from the EU should enable the United Kingdom to become a kind of “tax haven” in relation to its partners to date, and one of the first measures will be not to be bound by the Treaty, nor, of course, by CJEU decisions, from the very moment that withdrawal is formally requested, (in March, as is being said).

Put that way: what interest is there in this whole matter we are discussing?  Essentially none, since the subject being considered is no more than, as the Advocate General says, an internal matter for the United Kingdom. Or, as it may be perceived in another way, a kind of subterfuge by the Government of Gibraltar (under the umbrella of a private Association) to annoy Her Majesty's Government. If we now add to this the fact that CJEU judgments will not apply in the United Kingdom, we are faced with a genuine procedural absurdity, and also an unnecessary expenditure of material resources.

Finally, from the EU's perspective, maintaining a “tax haven within another” would make no sense whatsoever and would be a muddle.

All this suggests that Brexit, in general, is going to amount to a kind of earthquake for the Rock.

Gibraltar, Brexit, online gambling, Spain.

And, in connection with the procedural effect of Brexit mentioned above, a brief comment should be added on its effects in Gibraltar, specifically on the “Spanish market” of online gambling operators domiciled there, since, as we also know, some of the operators holding “.es” licences in Spain are domiciled in Gibraltar.

This domicile on the Rock does not mean that licensees cease to pay gambling tax in Spain at 25% of the win, and their “tax saving” is focused “only” on corporation tax. The current Spanish tax regime is more or less the same as that now applied in the United Kingdom in respect of citizens domiciled in Great Britain, apart from the applicable rate; with one further slight difference: the tax liability in Spain extends to “all” customers with an account on the website, (including Spaniards, for whom it is mandatory to play on a “.es” website). Brexit will not change the obligation to pay tax at 25% of the win from their operations in Spain.

However, the Spanish licence was granted precisely because the operator's “domicile” is in a territory within the European Union (unlike, for example, the Isle of Man, etc.). The Spanish licence will therefore be cancelled automatically when this requirement ceases to be met, that is, on the day that the United Kingdom's departure from the EU takes effect (which is expected  two years after the official request).

Of course, Spanish law also allows the domicile to be within the countries of the European Economic Area. Therefore, either the United Kingdom signs that Association Treaty (and we shall then see whether Gibraltar is included within its territorial scope of application, which Spain and other countries may oppose); or they will have to relocate their domicile in order to operate with Spanish citizens from a domicile other than Gibraltar, within the EU.

There is also the possibility, in the face of all this commotion, that Spanish law will be amended, of course.

Carlos Lalanda Fernandez

Madrid, 20 January 2017.

More publications