Gaming & Gambling
“Regulatory models” and gambling sectors. Encounters and disagreements in the Third Phase
Carlos Lalanda ·
Opinions are very frequently expressed on the merits or shortcomings of the “regulatory models” underpinning a particular business activity, which ultimately refers to all those rules that affect the activity one intends to carry on.
From a more rigorous perspective, a body of rules constitutes a “legal framework”, or “regulatory framework”, which may indeed constitute a “model” to be followed in other similar fields. Thus, depending on each person's opinion and perspective, regulatory frameworks will be exportable or importable according to one's standpoint ……..
Regulation and deregulation
In any business sphere, the ideal regulatory framework is, by definition, one of “freedom”, that is, one which imposes no restrictions or obligations beyond those required under general rules of business conduct, or under the various “branches of law” which affect it indirectly: Commercial Law, Employment Law, Tax Law, Consumer Law, etc., all in their “general” sense, and without any special provisions.
We already know that this is pure theory and that the ideal is almost never achieved…
This freedom of enterprise, recognised in our Constitution and in European Law, is sometimes subject to certain special provisions which restrict it, normally through the intervention of Special Administrative Law, or even Criminal Law. When this intervention occurs, we are dealing with a sector “subject to intervention” or “regulated”; indeed, certain specific sectors are classified as Regulated (with a capital letter) because they are expressly defined as such in legislation, which in colloquial terms could be translated as “excessively regulated or subject to intervention” for various reasons. Conversely, when the reverse process takes place, we speak of “deregulation”, because administrative or criminal-law interventions are lifted.
The Gambling Sector has always been, and remains, an “excessively regulated sector or one subject to intervention”, although it is not one of the traditional “Regulated” activities. By the State and by the Autonomous Communities. Through Special Administrative Law, through Special Tax Law. For countless and changing reasons which I shall not enumerate now.
Legal frameworks in Spain and their phases.
Gambling business activities in Spain have passed through several very clearly distinguishable legal frameworks in just a few years. Until 1977, the restriction was very clear: the operation of Lotteries and certain forms of mass betting was reserved to the State under a monopoly; all other activities were prohibited and even subject to criminal penalties. A simple regulatory framework, with internal State rules regulating the games themselves, and the Criminal Code governing the rest.
With the Constitution and the allocation to the Autonomous Communities of powers over land-based gambling, the various legal frameworks allowed private undertakings to operate, subject to extensive intervention and control under policing rules, accompanied by substantial special tax burdens.
With the passage of time and the sociological changes that occurred, the policing perspective diminished in importance, and the framework now focuses more on the protection of players and on “social peace” between undertakings, so that almost exclusive intervention by the Autonomous Communities within their territories becomes prominent, but under arrangements for “limiting supply” or so-called “economic planning”.
When, then, will there be “freedom of enterprise” in this gambling sector?
When will this “Third Phase” come?
Tax deregulation, “sectoral” deregulation of gambling?
It is said that we are no longer dealing with a legal framework “regulated through policing”, and that we are moving towards more advanced stages of deregulation, although the extent of this deregulation remains to be seen upon a brief examination of the forces at play.
From the perspective of Tax Law, it is clear that the signs point towards a certain degree of “deregulation”, which in this field amounts to a “reduction in the tax burden”. This is so because, once the traditional “disconnect” between administrative or parliamentary circles and gambling entrepreneurs has been overcome, the authorities responsible for governance and taxation are increasingly aware of the “normality” of this business activity, as well as of the real capacity to generate economic activity that comes from leaving the margins earned in the hands of entrepreneurs, rather than allocating most of them to special taxes. Thus, when attempts have been made to establish a gambling mega-complex in particular locations, a substantial reduction in this taxation has been made a condition, and, more importantly for our analysis, the administrations involved have acknowledged that limiting the tax burden was essential for this purpose. There are all the Eurovegas, Scala, Don Quijote, BCN World, Cordish Projects, etc.: All conceived and blessed with taxation of 10% or less on the business's gambling margin.
From the perspective of Special Administrative Law, the trumpets are also sounding for “deregulation”, beginning with the removal of bureaucratic obstacles and extending to the recognition of authorisations, registrations or security deposits from one Autonomous Community (CCAA) to another, on the basis of the Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity (LGUM).
However, at this point we must acknowledge the existence of distortions or discordant notes, owing to the presence of special provisions within the special regime. It is true that the initial overregulation came to treat not only the gambling sector as a matter subject to the Administrative Law of each of the Autonomous Communities (15 Communities plus Ceuta and Melilla, 17 self-contained regulatory regimes); each of them also distinguished and subjected to regulation each of the subsectors of the various forms of gambling, so that in all of them different forms of intervention have been established and delineated according to activity or game: undertakings and rules specialising in casinos, bingo, machines, betting, etc…….
Lastly, the State-level lottery and online gambling sectors appear to be watertight compartments, wholly distinct from the others. With no accessible channels of communication between themselves or with the others.
“Encounters in the Third Phase”
And now it transpires that the “deregulation” which appears to be the trend seeking to make headway is being held back by mistrust or fear between different “regulatory subsectors”, and, in a kind of world turned upside down, each subsector promotes the retention of “its regulation”, to the detriment of freedom of enterprise. The freedom of enterprise “of others”.
The “bingo” subsector says it is seeking a “new regulatory model”, but in the search for this new model at the recent meeting in Seville, only those advocating the retention of the regulatory compartmentalisation of the subsectors put themselves forward, without inviting those who have already moved beyond it towards another framework much more in keeping with reality, based on the regulation of “establishments” (a clear example of this: Castilla La Mancha).
The “casino” subsector argues in a recent statement that the recent regulation in Castilla La Mancha represents a break with the gambling policy developed over the last 35 years … and not before time, one might add!.
The “gaming machine hall” subsector, like the others, seeks everywhere some form of restriction or planning of these establishments, even in Castilla La Mancha, where the Autonomous Community has, in fact, recently introduced numerical limits in this subsector.
And so it goes on…….. including lottery reservations of various kinds.
All or almost all subsectors clamour for deregulation and freedom of enterprise, for innovation, but all or almost all could almost be said to be entrenched in their own sphere of activity.
The Autonomous Community and even State regulators look on in bewilderment at this dialogue of the deaf, because never before had such a degree of “deregulatory” understanding been reached among the authorities governing the gambling sector. Yet they maintain that they do not act for fear of the fray.
It is as though we were in a kind of “encounters in the Third regulatory Phase”, reminiscent of the cinema, between strangers from different worlds.
Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.
Madrid, 14 March 2017.