Gaming & Gambling
The war over \»scratchcards\» or instant lotteries: SELAE, ONCE, EAJA
Carlos Lalanda ·
Some call them “scratchcards”, others “tickets”, and more technically they are known as “instant lotteries” or “pre-drawn” lotteries.
What is it about these gambling products that makes them a constant source of controversy or fierce media criticism? A brief historical and legal review of this phenomenon in Spain may help us to understand it better.
The 1970s and 1980s, up to 1981 (from chaos to regulation)
At the end of the 1970s and the beginning of the 1980s, what were known in Spain as “tickets” flooded bars, with “operators” supplying bags of slips which were scratched in search of prizes that, if revealed, were paid out immediately on the same premises. The public was being offered a clearly illegal gambling product, without any authorisation and without paying the special taxes that other lawful forms of gambling were already beginning to bear. The mathematics of the prizes was generous to the “operator” of these bags and tickets, profits were maximised and shared with the bar owner; ultimately, it generated mountains of paper and was almost impossible for the police to control, as it was an “avalanche” phenomenon. The fortunes made by some operators through this practice are well known. As the operation of gaming machines became widespread, and subject to control by the authorities and Regulations, this activity declined.
The final blow was the Regulations on tickets approved by Royal Decree 1067/1981 which, while recognising the right of “private enterprise” to operate these lotteries, imposed other technical obligations concerning the characteristics and minimum guarantees of the “tickets”, including the requirement to collect these bags from the tax authorities …. and pay 20% of their total face value in advance……… a truly ruinous proposition. These Regulations on Tickets remain in force today, no one has formally repealed them and, furthermore, they apply on a supplementary basis in any Autonomous Community. They have become another of the zombie rules that swell our legal system, having long ceased to have any practical application.
The 1980s (Autonomous Community monopolies over “scratchcards”)
In the 1980s, the approval of successive Statutes of Autonomy and, pursuant to them, the first Autonomous Community Gambling Laws introduced the possibility of these tickets (which were already beginning to be called “pre-drawn lotteries”) being operated by the Autonomous Communities themselves, as a kind of public monopoly resource similar to that of ONLAE, but on a smaller scale: they could only lawfully be operated within the territory of the Autonomous Community. Along these lines, we find successive examples, beginning with the Basque Country (publication of Regulations in 1985, subsequent award of their operation under a concession to a private entity, and subsequent termination); Catalonia, where, as an additional product in the range of semi-active lotteries, further Regulations were approved at the time of the creation of EAJA (to which we shall return later); the Canary Islands, with the approval of Regulations and the award of a concession that was never implemented; and finally, the paradigmatic case of Galicia, which led to criminal consequences for some of its promoters.
All this is now “history”, except for the case of EAJA in Catalonia, whose “Loto Rapid” product is still being operated, even with “renewed vigour” online.
The 1990s and the third millennium. ONCE instant lotteries before the Constitutional Court
No significant developments emerged in the bleak landscape described above until the end of the 1990s. As this was a “lottery” product, it always seemed clear that it could fall within the scope of the State Monopoly through ONLAE, LAE, but it was never launched or seriously explored by the monopoly body. The introduction of new lottery products in addition to traditional passive lotteries (GORDO de Navidad, El Niño, weekly draws) had extended to “semi-active” lotteries (la Primitiva, Bonoloto, subsequently Euromillón, etc.), but without venturing into instant lotteries, which clearly broke with the principle that had guided the Monopoly from the outset: the marketing of products with draws taking place after the purchase of the bet, with less immediate access to prizes and “low addictive potential”.
However, there was no legal obstacle to including this product in the Lottery Concession granted to ONCE, if the State wished to do so.
Against this background, and following its inclusion in ONCE's Agreement with the Council of Ministers, an initial Royal Decree 844/1999 was approved, which was challenged before the Constitutional Court (TC) by several Autonomous Communities, alleging a hypothetical encroachment upon their powers, and that their territorial authority extended even to State-wide lotteries and draws, because they were sold in physical establishments located within a specific territory. It was necessary to wait until Constitutional Court Judgment 32/2012, which included the challenge to a subsequent Royal Decree, 1336/2005, for confirmation that there was no such impediment to their marketing. This was despite a very detailed dissenting opinion to the contrary.
In the meantime, ONCE had not developed the product, and a further reconfiguration of the Agreement with the Council of Ministers, and a new Royal Decree, very similar to the previous one, were required in order, this time in earnest, to roll out the aforementioned “lottery” product. Throughout Spanish territory, and with the aim of raising funds for the public purposes for which it was established.
Technical developments in scratchcards and the current state of the offering.
Technological advances have improved these products and their control, and consequently their commercial operation, throughout the world and also in Spain.
Scratchcards are now difficult to tamper with or counterfeit, and the security of the technical systems for their issue and distribution meets high security standards. The format of these lotteries has also moved to an Internet version, where platforms offer “virtual” tickets that are no longer physically “scratched”, but are “revealed” with a click.
Under the respective Regulations approved at State level and in Catalonia, there are currently two “operators” of these scratchcards, which even offer them in an online version: ONCE and EAJA. And now there is another which appears to be moving towards offering them: SELAE itself.
It is worth reviewing the legal framework governing each of them and their figures.
The legal framework governing ONCE is highly unusual, as I have commented many times, and has become even more so since Law 13/2011 on the Regulation of Gambling, because one of its Additional Provisions virtually “excludes” this organisation from its scope of application; furthermore, it provides that, because State-wide lotteries are classified as products subject to a marketing “reservation” (a reservation in favour of ONCE and SELAE), these products are exempt from the special taxation imposed on all others (25% of gambling revenue in some cases, and 15% or 22% of sales in others). This exemption does not apply to the special Levy on prizes exceeding 2,500 euros, which is in fact the actual and effective application of personal income tax (IRPF) to winners. Under the current business model, the gambling revenue received by ONCE (in 2016, an overall average of 49.9%, and 38.5% for instant lotteries, calculated on total stakes after deduction of prizes) must be used to cover management and general expenses; and, once these have been deducted, for social benefits, all these parameters being audited and monitored by the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs.
The framework governing EAJA is likewise unusual and unique in Spain, with the particular feature that the lottery product is not normally managed using its own resources, but is instead awarded to a private entity under a quasi-concession arrangement, which certainly conflicts with the principles governing EAJA: that it should manage lotteries “directly”. Unlike ONCE, and although EAJA is a body under the Regional Ministry of Finance, its figures are not publicly known, nor is the product's ultimate profitability.
In addition to the two operators mentioned, several Autonomous Communities could undertake their operation directly and on their own account or, in some cases, such as the Community of Madrid, through authorisations granted to private entities, although these possibilities are currently unviable in terms of the taxation to be borne (generally not exempt from a very high Gambling Levy), and undoubtedly the small size of the “market”, which could only be confined to a single Autonomous Community.
Hence the only “viable” prospect of this product being launched by new operators today lies with SELAE itself, which appears to have begun exploring this possibility. And hence it is its “natural competitors” (ONCE throughout the State, and EAJA only in Catalonia) that are called upon to voice the principal concerns regarding this initiative.
A degree of concern can also be observed among the other sectors in which games of chance are operated by private entities, since, ultimately, this is a product offering that has some impact on the market in which they operate.
The limits on the “scratchcards” and “online scratchcards” that SELAE intends to manage. The State Gambling Law.
It is worth recalling the legal classification and the “natural” and legal limits of this prospective new product line.
Following the now traditional and almost sole comprehensive study of the classification of the various types and subtypes of games of chance, Lafaille and Simonis[1] clearly include these scratchcards within Lotteries, but in the “pre-drawn” subtype. For its part, the Spanish Gambling Law regards as Lotteries both those in which the prize is determined by a draw on a specified date and those in which it is obtained “under a predetermined programme, in the case of instant or pre-drawn lotteries” (Article 3(b) of Law 13/2011).
Thus, as they are included within the Lotteries reserved to SELAE and ONCE, the framework within which these new gambling offerings must be introduced entails 3 unavoidable requirements and one caveat:
1 – That the “scratchcards” should be State-wide, there is nothing to prevent SELAE from developing them; on the contrary, they are “lotteries”. In my view, their legal framework requires the approval of new Regulations under Law 13/2011, because the current rules on passive or semi-active Lotteries have “regulatory status” only because they predate Law 13/2011 (Second and Third Transitional Provisions). The aforementioned Regulations of 1981 are manifestly insufficient. With regard to ONCE, it should be recalled that its Agreement with the Council of Ministers (of a mixed contractual-concessionary nature (or whatever it may be)) contains no qualification on this point concerning a possible offering by SELAE.
2. – That the marketing should be of “physical scratchcards” requires SELAE to use its “sales network”, also in accordance with the specific provisions of Law 13/2011 on this point (which is not straightforward to determine either, since this is a matter of debate and potential conflict).
3. – That the marketing of “online scratchcards” entails certain approval and technical control obligations (which may be laid down in the new Regulations referred to above, since the rules on “non-lottery” online gambling are insufficient in this respect). The “reservation” of lottery activity does not exempt SELAE and ONCE from the application of Title IV of the Law.
4. – However, and finally, it is not acceptable for “online scratchcards” to become actual gambling products similar to “online slot machines”, which is what we have been warning about in various analyses, specifically concerning certain “online scratchcards” offered by ONCE and EAJA. In that case, we are no longer talking about “lottery” products, but actual manifestations of “non-reserved” games of chance products requiring a “licence”, operating alongside and in competition with online slot machine gambling operators, both at State level and in Catalonia respectively.
The recent judgment of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia invalidating the operation of the so-called “binjocs” vindicates our position by accepting arguments of this kind: these are not genuine lottery products, which are what EAJA's statutory remit reserves to it in Catalonia or, at State level, to SELAE or ONCE. They therefore cannot be operated under that guise.
The aim here has been to outline briefly who the “contenders in this peculiar war” are, modestly to set out the weapons at their disposal, and to define the “battlefield”.
Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.
Loyra Abogados
www.loyra.com
Madrid, 2 February 2018.
[1] “El juego Diseccionado” published in Spanish by Fundación CODERE