Gaming & Gambling

SELAE LOTTERIES ONLINE. Commercial Court Judgment

Carlos Lalanda ·

A recent judgment of Madrid Commercial Court No. 6 of 8 April 2018 is circulating on social media, declaring that SELAE has been engaging in acts of unfair competition against its Full-Service Sales Network by itself marketing Lotería Nacional directly through its website www.loteriasyapuestas.es.

A conflict in modern times, as our parents and grandparents would say on contemplating this situation. The State being sued (and even having judgment entered against it) by its own Sales Network. The formerly all-powerful State Monopoly, which dates back more than 230 years, to the time of Carlos III. That is where we stand, and we have no option but to analyse it.

“NEITHER ONE EXTREME NOR THE OTHER”

To avoid any confusion, it should first be noted that the aforementioned judgment merely declares, at first instance and pending what the Provincial Court may subsequently say on appeal, that SELAE must cease marketing through that online channel a specific product, the so-called “blue ticket”, (a visual representation of the traditional ticket, with shades of this colour, traditionally marketed and “sold” on paper; without affecting the other products marketed through that website: the euromillones lottery, bonoloto, football pools. Etc.

The judgment dismisses a second claim, which directly sought to bring an end to the marketing of those products through the “Complementary” Sales Network, also known as the network of “Mixed Sales Outlet Managers”, who also market these “blue tickets” in their establishments and through their own printers or terminals, as do those belonging to the Main Network or “Full-Service Management” Outlets, one of whose Associations brought the claim. As regards the dismissal of this second claim, there are already some precedents taking the same approach, the Judgment of Madrid Commercial Court No. 12 of 2 November 2017 , on the grounds that “blue tickets” are not traditional tickets, which are indeed distributed exclusively by the Full-Service Outlets.

Both the claim upheld and the claim dismissed now proceed to the second instance, without the claimant association having so far announced “provisional enforcement”, nor has SELAE commented on the matter, and for the time being the product continues to be marketed.

It also remains to be determined whether such a ruling would give rise to any form of compensation in favour of the entities potentially harmed, a possibility that would be extremely complex to quantify and resolve. We must still wait some time, since the first instance alone took 3 years to conclude.

THE CONFLICT OVER THE SALE OF LOTTERY TICKETS (LOTERÍA NACIONAL) ONLINE

Several legal transformations and paradigm shifts converge at the origin of the conflict, some of which are identified in the judgment under discussion.

First, owing to the requirements of Community law, but also to the State's urgent financing needs in 2009, the State Monopoly underwent a transformation leading to the incorporation of a State-Owned Public Limited Company governed by private law, so that the former Concession-Based Sales Network also had to be urgently transformed in 2010 into a new Contractual Sales Network through the mass signing of “Sales Outlet Management” contracts. This is why, in addition to the striking novelty of disputes being settled before the ordinary courts, these relationships are subject to commercial law, including the Unfair Competition Law, which is the legislation the Judge has analysed in the proceedings under discussion.

Furthermore, while it is true that SELAE's standard contracts for the Full-Service Network include, as an essential element, the exclusive right of this Network, and not the other, to sell traditional tickets, in fact these traditional physical paper tickets, which also constituted a form of bearer instrument, are actually nothing more than evidence of the betting contract between the player and the operator SELAE; and the operator (like any business), may develop its product to maximise its business, and introduce, as it has done, new sales techniques: the “blue ticket” is simply an “embellished” receipt for the bet (as the judgment under discussion acknowledges), which became available for marketing from 2015 through both the Full-Service and the Complementary Sales Networks. The traditional physical ticket continues to account for the bulk of sales, the “flagship” of the product brand, but is increasingly losing ground to the others.

The final factor of change, almost unnoticed by everyone, including the Commercial Court, which does not deal with these matters, is the precarious administrative regulation of lottery gambling at present, which is “petrified”. Its framework clearly falls within the scope of Law 13/2011 of 27 May, since under and by virtue of that Law these games are reserved to SELAE and ONCE, with the almost philosophical peculiarity that the framework governing ONCE lotteries is excluded from almost all of the Law (Second Additional Provision,) whereas SELAE lotteries are “included” (First Additional Provision), with numerous special features. Under this framework, there are no grounds, for the time being, for overlooking the fact that lotteries require their own specific implementing regulations, just as other games have implementing regulations, through Decrees or Ministerial Orders.

As long as the situation and the statutory mandate remain unchanged, the regulations applicable to lottery gambling (in addition to a few very specific provisions of Royal Decree 1614/2011) are contained in the old Decrees and even LAE's internal organisational Resolutions predating the Gambling Law (Second Transitional Provision.), so that, until new regulations are issued, the regulation of lottery games and the framework governing their marketing, directly or through third parties, remain “frozen” as at 2011.

The Monopoly's website, established by the former LAE even before the enactment of Law 13/2011 on gambling and not challenged in relation to the marketing of the other products, did not market this new “blue ticket” until 2015. This “innovation” is not supported by any gambling regulations. The sale of number-draw lottery tickets and football pools was already regulated by the LAE Resolution of 23 August 2005 (Official State Gazette (BOE) of 27 August), and a subsequent resolution on football pools of 18 June 2008, but these did not refer to Lotería Nacional.

And this is where the standard contract signed by the Sales Network outlet holders comes into play. Through what is “agreed” in the contract, which must be interpreted, applied and even brought into line with, among other legislation, the Unfair Competition Law, the holders of Sales Outlets in this Full-Service Network are granted an exclusive right to sell Lotería Nacional Tickets.

There is no objection to this, but it would have been sufficient for the administrative regulator to have permitted this new “direct” online offering by way of regulation, with the logical and formal provisions required by administrative law. The conflict would then have moved to a different level, avoiding the inevitable contractual crisis. We would be analysing the possible compensation arising from the State's liability in damages, from the perspective of the obligation to bear (or not) the general burdens that the public interest may impose on private parties.

THE KEY LIES IN COMMISSIONS, AS ALWAYS

In SELAE's relations with its Sales Network, contentious issues often come down to the commissions paid as consideration for the service provided to the operator, and their calculation. In other words, clause 5.1.1 of the standard contract.

These have long been debated. In the case of the online “blue ticket”, SELAE unilaterally decided that, in view of the foreseeable “reduction” in sales it would cause the Full-Service Network (on the assumption that purchases made on that website cease to be made at Sales Outlets), this reduction should be offset through a system reallocating a 4% commission. This commission would be attributed to each Sales Outlet according to a box to be completed by the online purchaser, at their choice or, who knows…perhaps to the one nearest to the address indicated by the purchaser.

According to the judgment, this method of reallocating commission lacks transparency, since the purchaser need only “forget” to complete this box for the commission to be left “orphaned”; moreover, the user lacks real information, and the imposition of any allocation criterion is difficult to reconcile with the arrangement. In short, this distribution system is “unilateral” (a 4% rate agreed with no one), confusing (within an unclear website feature) and opaque (it is not known whether SELAE makes the allocation it claims to make, since no one can check SELAE's platform).

The judgment concludes that this constitutes an abusive contractual amendment within the terms of Article 16.2 of the Unfair Competition Law, and that this marketing must cease on that ground. The “strong” or “dominant” undertaking (SELAE) imposes on the “weak” or “dependent” undertaking (the holder of the Full-Service Sales Outlet) a new form of Lottery and sales channel, with remuneration intended to offset the acknowledged reduction in commission, but distorting or damaging the market position of the “weak” undertakings, which are those of its own Full-Service Network.

No figures are known for the total direct sales of this product through SELAE's website, nor for the overall amount that the Full-Service Network ceases to receive under this heading, still less can this be individualised, should compensation subsequently be sought for the losses arising from the breach of contract. To establish all these parameters, it will be necessary to wait until the judgment is, hypothetically, definitively upheld.

THE SALES NETWORK'S ONLINE OFFERING, INDIRECTLY RECOGNISED THROUGH THIS JUDGMENT

It is also striking that the judgment recognises, indirectly but clearly, the contractual right of any Sales Network outlet holder to expand the offering through their own website. This is precisely one of the decisive counterbalances on which the judgment bases its argument concerning the imbalance caused by SELAE's direct sales through its website.

This statement is important and noteworthy, since whether or not Sales Outlet Managers may market products through their own websites is also constantly debated, in view of the limited range of arrangements provided for in clause 4.1.3 of the “standard contract” (common to Full-Service and Mixed Outlets). It should not be forgotten that this “inadequate clause” was amended by the Resolution of SELAE's Board of Directors of 14 June 2012, giving rise to a much broader case-by-case interpretation, which therefore now forms part of that contract.

THE ULTIMATE SOLUTION ONCE AGAIN LIES IN COMMISSIONS

Whatever the final outcome of the proceedings, for or against SELAE (and we have already reached 3 years for the first instance), the definitive solution to the problem requires SELAE and the other parties involved to resolve, by action or acquiescence, the longstanding and persistent demand for the “updating” or “restructuring” of the sales commissions laid down in that contract.

This is essentially a matter of commerce and expediency, and it is only appropriate here to recall the considerable assistance that would result from recognition of the exemption from VAT which the Network Managers currently charge SELAE on their invoices for the provision of services, already outlined <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">in previous articles.

Recognition of this exemption would enable SELAE to have an “additional pool” for distribution equivalent to 21% of total commissions (an annual pool of more than 100 million euros), which would be saved on invoices and could be “redistributed” by increasing the commission.

Of course, this depends on SELAE itself deciding to claim it before the tax authority that determines these matters, and on the Treasury itself (its very own shareholder) recognising it.

At this stage, more difficult and far-fetched things have been seen.

Madrid, 18 April 2019.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Loyra Abogados

More publications