Firm News

Someone Has a Plan

Carlos Lalanda ·

It is striking, and it turns out, that the Ministry has an Action Plan on Addictions for 2018–2020, which includes “non-substance addictions” as an objective.  These non-substance addictions are of various kinds, and among them, they say, is betting with money. Thus far, in the realm of principles, precautions and public concern for health, this seems consistent with a modern conception of the State (or of political power in general), whether that conception is broader or narrower, more or less pronounced. Some will feel that the State intervenes more, and others less, depending on their political outlook.

But let us follow the thread, to see the purpose and context of the Plan.

How far the Plan extends

It also turns out that the inclusion of games of chance within “non-substance addictions” in the Plan is not based on statistics on people affected by and treated in hospitals for pathological gambling (statistics which do not exist), but on certain sociological surveys on games of chance in which respondents are asked about their behaviour and habits.

The conclusions of these surveys, from the most to the least alarmist, suggest that in Spain, in terms of volitional “control”, problem gambling is minimal among the population. Having been involved in monitoring some of them, it seems to me (as a matter of common knowledge) that this problem is of a similar or lesser order than other “non-substance addictions”, such as excessive shopping, using the internet to browse aimlessly, running marathons, walking the Camino de Santiago every summer, persistently channel-hopping on TV, or pirating Movistar to watch Liga matches, among many others. I have no data on these others.

It is a scientifically proven fact that all these activities and many more, previously described as “pastimes” rather than “addictions”, and even the consumption of certain physical substances considered “normal”, such as added sugars, generate chemicals in the body which, once they reach the brain, influence behaviour and control over one's actions.

A whole theory which is, more or less, the basis of present-day marketing of all kinds of goods and services.

This Plan, then, in its new chapter on non-substance addictions, is going to give specialists a great deal of work, as the field is almost impossible to encompass.

Youth, divine treasure

And here we find youth being introduced into the objective of the Plan. Because the State (the public authorities) must concern itself with young people. This is in the Constitution, and anyone would agree with it. Disagreements then depend on each person's priorities: should we devote more attention, or give priority, to the problems caused among young people by alcohol or tobacco, or to compulsive internet shopping? To treating those hooked on heroin, or to internet content for 2-year-old children? To their greater social, political, economic and cultural participation, to which Article 48 of the Spanish Constitution (CE) refers? ….What should we do about minors who gamble for money?

All these questions are beyond the grasp of the ordinary person until the specialists enlighten us, and, judging by the headlines of the Plan, the specialists have found a veritable “treasure” in this field. There are surveys in which adolescents are asked what they gamble on, and how much they gamble, and, finally, more or less “scientific” figures and conclusions are provided. The presentation of the Plan refers to a “Baseline” (page 8 of the Plan), according to which,

  • “21% of students aged between 14 and 18 use the internet compulsively (IN GENERAL)” 4.6% more than in 2014”.
  • furthermore, according to “the DGPND's (Government Delegation for the National Plan on Drugs) own data, in 2016, 6.4% of secondary school students gambled for money online and 13.6% placed bets in person (ESTUDES 2016 Survey)”.
  • Lastly, “that between 0.2% and 12.3% of male and female adolescents meet the criterion for problem gambling” (Reference to Becoña, 2004 and González-Roz and others, 2016).

I have italicised what the Plan says, not what I say.

Is all this true? Do we have anything to “challenge” in these statements, or do we accept them as valid?

Well then, let us focus on Spanish adolescents, continue following the thread, and see what the Estudes Survey is, and what, more precisely, it says about this.

The Estudes survey on our adolescents

 ESTUDES is a Survey on Drug Use among Secondary School Students conducted every 2 years, the latest being from 2016. It can be found on the <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Ministry of Health  website.. The sample comprises 35,369 young people aged between 14 and 18 studying at 863 educational establishments, which is, of course, a highly representative sample of the total (1,541,937), and is spread across all the Autonomous Communities. Some experts state that, as it is conducted in classrooms (1,726 in total), the answers are not entirely “private and sincere”.

Examining the 2016 survey not for scientific purposes, but for general knowledge, our young people are described at first sight (through the eyes of this writer, a citizen already “mature” in the statistical table, and therefore possibly biased) as a complete disaster.

These are the general Estudes figures on our adolescents, as percentages of the total. “Substance” addictions, according to its summary Power Point presentation:

Alcohol: 67%

Hashish: 18.3%

Daily tobacco use 8.8%

Drunkenness: 21.8%

Sedative-hypnotics: 11.6%

Other drugs and hallucinogens: from 1.4% to 2.3%.

If we make a quick extrapolation, as is usually done, we find that

1,033,097 drink alcohol;

336,142 get drunk;

282,174 smoke hashish;

135,690 smoke tobacco (every day);

178,864 take sedative-hypnotics; etc., etc.….

Since one does not see that many “zombies” in the streets, it is necessary to read more deeply between the lines to establish the actual frequency behind these percentages, rather than merely the Power Point headlines, in order to gain a more realistic picture of our young people. And, logically, to address the problem in its true dimensions. And to forget the headlines a little.

Survey on adolescent behaviour

Let us continue in greater detail, and go beyond the Power Point, to the

More publications