Gaming & Gambling

Someone Has a Report

Carlos Lalanda ·

Recently I had occasion to comment on the lack of rigour in certain news reports concerning the Ministry’s newly announced National Plan on Drugs, regarding the inclusion of the problem of drugs without substances, namely addictions, and in particular addictions to games of chance. This was because the underlying evidence and sources concerning the absolute and relative size of the population of minors with this addiction, or a tendency towards it, were questionable.

This time it is necessary to analyse a recent presentation of findings by the Regional Minister for Education of Castilla y León, from the 2018 School Coexistence Report on educational establishments in this Autonomous Community, with press articles bearing, among others, the following headlines: “online betting gains ground among schoolchildren in Castilla y León”; or “Castilla y León finds it “disturbing” that 8% of schoolchildren bet online”.

One moment ……. did the Regional Minister say this?: what is it based on? As in other cases, it is necessary to consult the “sources of the information” … to form a sound opinion.

Report A and Report B.

 The School Coexistence Report for the 2017–2018 academic year, presented on 16 November, says absolutely nothing about online betting by minors. It analyses the serious problem of bullying and even cyberbullying. So …. did the Regional Minister say anything? Is the news report incorrect? Let us investigate further ….

Indeed, it turns out that there is a Second Report (let us call it Report “B”), which accompanied the former at the same presentation, entitled:

“SAF_e Project”. Cybervictimisation and habits of ICT and Internet use among pupils in non-university education in Castilla y León (click  here to follow the link to the website of the School Coexistence Observatory of Castilla y León)

Saf_e is a project on cybervictimisation and ICT use among pupils in non-university education in the Autonomous Community of Castilla y León, whose aim is to understand the reality of this phenomenon and, on that basis, propose strategies and resources to enable it to be addressed appropriately.

The project was prepared by the Instituto Crímina of the Universidad Miguel Hernández de Elche, in collaboration with the Regional Ministry of Education of the Junta de Castilla y León.

This Saf_e Project focuses on various problems relating to Internet use, and above all on matters bordering on criminal conduct arising from schoolchildren’s use of this technology. This Report seeks to obtain statistical answers concerning the “cybervictimisation”, both social and economic, suffered by young people in Castilla y León, and even cases in which young people themselves have been perpetrators of cyberbullying, including sexual cyberbullying; serious problems which undoubtedly need to be addressed urgently from every perspective.

We again ask ourselves what this has to do with betting. To expand the objective data, the survey asks pupils about their Internet usage habits, including whether they bet a lot or a little online and how frequently.

Here, then, we have it, but let us continue to follow the thread.

The Saf_e Report:  the questions and answers on online betting by minors         

It is worth knowing that the survey sample comprises 7,282 pupils across 101 educational establishments in Castilla y León, from primary and compulsory secondary education (ESO) to upper secondary education and even intermediate vocational training, with pupils aged 9 to 20. The survey is not conducted in person, but online.

When they are asked about betting, those below the second year of ESO are excluded as being too young, but the older pupils are retained, meaning that there is likely to be a certain sample of those aged over 18 (an imprecise sample, but an important one, as we shall see).

Two questions are asked on this subject (p. 32):

Question  91: On the frequency with which the minor has gambled on an online betting platform (item 91): Ordinal-Lickert scale, from never to +10 times.

Question  92: Hours per week that the minor spends gambling on an online betting platform (Item 92). Categorical, with 6 options. We infer (from the chart on p. 163) that this scale runs from “0” to more than 15 hours per week:

I do not dispute, nor am I qualified to do so, whether the questions are well or poorly formulated, merely that the exact questions asked are not disclosed, nor does the Findings Report contain a tabulation of the answers, which makes it very difficult for genuine experts to verify and express an opinion, for or against, on the quality of the subsequent reasoning that we shall see.

But we should not be discouraged by this; let us turn to the content of the Findings Report on this issue, which appears to be the basis for the news reports and their headlines.

Findings: A brief section and an incorrect or confusing chart

 Pages 157 to 161 of the SAF_e Findings Report condense the survey results, referring to the section on “Deviant patterns of Internet and ICT use among young people in Castilla y León,”, as follows:

“some of the risks associated with the Internet that have not been mentioned thus far relate to its excessive use, online betting and sexting (sexual cyberbullying). It is precisely these risks that are discussed throughout this section, which details, on the one hand, the prevalence of surveyed pupils who use the Internet excessively and, on the other, the percentage of pupils who report engaging in online betting and sexting behaviour”

            For excessive Internet use, the term “prevalence” is used, that is, a term with clinical connotations; whereas for Internet betting the term “percentage” is used.

As regards “excessive Internet use in general, 1% of respondents appear to meet all the criteria for being considered addicted to the Internet, with the observation that “it must be borne in mind that this is often no more than the manifestation of other types of problems or that … it may conceal more powerful needs (p. 158) . This is clearly represented in chart 159: 99% do not use the Internet excessively whereas 1% (total number = 72) do.

However, when analysing those who bet, …. “online betting, conduct which has only been measured among pupils from the second year of ESO onwards, (that is, from the second year of ESO up to the age of 20), IS NOT VERY COMMON AMONG THE PUPILS SURVEYED.\» What does it mean to be common or otherwise? Let us turn to the specific findings, on the same page:

“1. Only 9% (n=398) state that they have bet online in the last year.

  1. Furthermore, a significant number of these pupils currently spend no hours per week on this activity (23%, and of those who do, 47% spend less than one hour per week on it”.

…… And there the analysis ends, with chart 163, which is, to say the least, perplexing (p. 161): does it refer to a percentage of the total number of pupils surveyed, or rather to the 9% who say they have gambled in the last year? In the absence of other tables, we lean more towards the latter interpretation, since it includes the 23% and 47% cited above. That chart (the only one referring to specific data) contains the following scale:

  • They no longer gamble, although they used to (approximately 23% of 9%= 2.07%)
  • They gamble for 1 hour or less per week (approximately 47% of 9%= 4.23%)
  • They gamble for 1 to 3 hours per week: (approximately 17% of 9%=1.53%)
  • They gamble for 4 to 7 hours per week (approximately 5% of 9%= 0.4%)
  • They gamble for 8 to 15 hours per week (approximately 2% of 9%= 0.2%)
  • They gamble for more than 15 hours per week (approximately 4% of 9%= 0.4%).

Indeed, if we add together all those who say they still gamble, they would amount to approximately 7%,  but most of them do so sporadically, and very few do so frequently or very frequently.

Of all these, we do not know how many are school pupils but of legal age, who are also included in the survey, or whether in such cases one could speak of a \»deviant pattern of Internet use\».  And if they are minors, how is it possible for them to hold gambling accounts, unless these are illegal or foreign websites, or they have improperly used adults’ cards or details? In short, very important unanswered questions, unresolved by the Report, which call for substantial qualifications to a straightforward reading of the media headlines.

 Conclusions

 The School Coexistence Report for the 2017/2018 academic year in Castilla y León does not refer to online betting, but to other very important problems (bullying, cyberbullying, etc.).

The Saf_e Report on usage habits and cybervictimisation includes, in passing and without this being its subject matter, a quantification of certain behaviours of young people in relation to the Internet.

The sample comprises pupils from educational establishments in Castilla y León up to the age of 20; and as the full statistics are not disclosed, it is not possible to know the age range or other parameters into which those who say they gamble online fall.

Among the “Highlights of the Saf_e Project” there are none referring to online betting. As the Report itself emphasises, online betting IS NOT VERY COMMON AMONG THE PUPILS SURVEYED.

The Report and the findings refer only to those who say they gamble online, and do not cover gambling in physical establishments.

The Report’s findings on online betting are very brief, and do not describe the statistics by age, or in relation to other parameters connected with the problems examined, such as cyberbullying.

The Chart on Page 163 (the only one on this issue) is incorrect, or may give rise to error as to the percentage to which it refers, which is not the total number of respondents, but 9% of them.

In short, the information appearing in the media seems to me to be confusing and incorrect.

Madrid, 19 November 2018.

Carlos Lalanda Fernandez

More publications