Gaming & Gambling
State Lawyers up in arms
Carlos Lalanda ·
The detailed and transparent reporting by the gambling sector media is welcome, on matters that previously lay in the hidden drawers of offices as mysteries or secrets to be revealed only in very exceptional circumstances.
This time, we are shown successive reports exchanged on the recurring issue of “online gambling terminals: who has the power to authorise them: the State or the Autonomous Communities (CCAA)”, issued by the respective lawyers representing the interests involved. Several hundred pages of entertaining reading which some of us take the time to read in depth as a professional duty.
They originate in the countless requests and questions received on the subject, and the persistent uncertainty within the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling as to how to resolve them. In an attempt to obtain a definitive answer, an opinion was sought from the Ministry's State Legal Service, which is what is usually done to play for time …….. although another parallel opinion was received along the way.
And at the last meeting of the Gambling Policy Council held in March, it monopolised the agenda
State Lawyers everywhere
It is not that I now wish to detract from this prestigious legal corps. Merely to recount the succession of opinions as far as possible, and to summarise the relevant points.
In 2017, and in chronological order, the signatory of the first report is a State Lawyer (on leave of absence) who endorses the opinion in favour of his client, a reputable association of gambling sector businesses with an interest in the matter.
The signatory of the second report is the Chief State Lawyer at the Ministry of Finance, which is the Ministry vested with State competence in matters of lotteries, betting and games of chance.
It should be noted that the convoluted articles of Law 13/2011 which they seek to interpret were the work of another State Lawyer, in this case the person entrusted with steering the Gambling Law through the legislative process to a successful conclusion and under full sail.
But there are more State Lawyers in this account: the signatory of an initial report in 2011, in turn interpreting the then recently enacted Law. And still another unidentified one, namely the State Lawyer defending the Public Administration in the proceedings challenging certain Andalusian Regulations, which gave rise to the Supreme Court judgment repeatedly mentioned in those reports. And yet another issuing a report in 2013 as a consequence of the 2012 judgment of the Court of Justice of Andalusia on this matter.
A war of State Lawyers. Each defending their own position and interest, whether or not it coincides with that of the “State”.
What is discussed in those reports?
The analyses appear to be very similar and to revolve around the same provisions and concepts …. but reach different conclusions concerning the legal position of SELAE or ONCE lottery sales terminals, which seem to be the focus of all the interest in the matter this time. Terminals which, incidentally, are not described, as though there were a “consensus” on their inherent reality.
After pages and pages of citations and considerations of various kinds of law, as befits submissions of this nature, and subtle and sometimes striking conclusions, everything revolves around the same articles of the 2011 Gambling Law, several judgments repeated in both submissions, and the existence of various provisions in the respective Autonomous Community Gambling Laws which appear to support or refute the arguments advanced…. with different final interpretations in each report, depending on its author, the time at which the opinion was given, or the interests defended.
Interests involved and their defence
The actions of any lawyer are synonymous with defending a client in a legal matter, and the fact that all those mentioned hold the status of State Lawyers should not be taken literally, nor as meaning that they defend the State itself. The lawyer representing the business association is expressly released from doing so (“on leave of absence”, as he states in his report); the lawyer before the Andalusian Court and the Supreme Court in the proceedings referred to was in fact defending the interests of ONCE, whose hypothetical terminals had become subject to authorisation and gambling tax in all their forms; the person drafting the enigmatic articles of Law 13/2011 was, in a sense, also seeking to defend the interests of ONCE and LAE, an entity which at the time was still the “State”; the authors of the 2011 report, the 2013 report and the current 2017 report, although mutually contradictory, appear to be responding to the interests of the Central State, within whose sphere and on whose behalf they currently practise, but in different ways depending on when they were drafted.
Having unravelled this first issue, what underlies it is an eminently commercial interest, present or future, in the consequences of operating SELAE or ONCE lottery terminals in establishments open to the public, but only those which are new or different from their traditional “commercial sales network”; and, ultimately, whether their authorisation or control falls within the remit of the Central State or the Autonomous Communities.
And here the absence of other lawyers, those of the Autonomous Communities, is conspicuous. They would surely have something to say, although the fact is that they have already said it in the judicial proceedings to which the current reports refer, both in the Autonomous Community of Extremadura and in Andalusia. In both cases, defeated by a landslide.
What is missing from those reports?
Bewildered by the war of State Lawyers, and immersed in a sea of submissions and considerations, it seems risky and even arrogant to express an opinion on what the final solution to this interesting matter might be; and it is also bold to maintain that they are to some extent “incomplete”, from the perspective of some of the underlying facts. They lack, to a greater or lesser extent depending on the arguments defended, a description of the complete “reality”, or a necessary critique of certain “legislative excesses”.
- There is no description of the lottery terminals whose legal regime is being discussed (are they “Churra or Merino sheep”?). All the reports speak of them, but it is not clear which ones they concern: perhaps the “validation” machines operated by SELAE or ONCE sales agents, or operated by “third parties”? The automatic and “self-service” machines which interact directly with players? (See the image accompanying the article) Most probably the latter, but …… those which accept bets in cash, by card, through players' accounts? The imagination is free. It is hoped that someone will shed light on these products. All the debates focus on the supposed “SELAE and ONCE lottery sales terminals” but ….. do they really exist? In what shape or form will they exist?
2. There is no sound critique of certain legislative excesses. It is taken for granted that all the laws examined “comply” with the allocation of powers.
It could have been acknowledged that some of the rules examined are “bad or confusing”, or clearly contrary to the allocation of powers under the Constitution. Or that they would not withstand constitutional scrutiny, even though no one has yet challenged them. But we find only a little tentative criticism of the obscurity of some of them.
The framework of competence appears clear following the initial judgments of the Constitutional Court (TC), or the qualifications in the latest ones, but some recent provisions included in the Autonomous Community Gambling Laws tend to omit this fact, which cannot be disregarded as a starting point. Nor can the State Law disregard it or “cede anything” to Autonomous Community competence. In this context, State Gambling Law 13/2011, or the respective Autonomous Community Gambling Laws, may be more or less explicit, clear or confusing, but they cannot remove or confer any powers vested in the Autonomous Communities within that constitutional framework pursuant to their Statutes of Autonomy.
- The differing realities of the “management” of lotteries by SELAE and ONCE are omitted, In the case of ONCE, almost all “sales” are made through its own employees or associates, only occasionally through “third parties”. SELAE, for its part, sells only through the former “Lottery Agencies”, or “principal or supplementary external” network, currently and with some exceptions, individuals or entities linked to SELAE through commercial “Point of Sale Management” agreements (dedicated or mixed). They are genuine “third parties” in relation to SELAE, but genuine agents with their own establishments. In the reports mentioned, they appear to be left in a kind of limbo, hostage to a definitive interpretation of the Law.
- None of the reports refers to the “actual direct management” by SELAE and ONCE through their online points of sale such as the websites “loteríasyapuestas.es” and “www.once.es” , currently minor sales channels, separate from the traditional physical distribution networks. Do the reports refer to terminals which allow these websites to be used in establishments open to the public? This category would include, for example, self-service terminals for “online scratchcards”.
Too many questions and omissions of particular cases which entangle and mask the interests involved.
The scarcity and/or absence of judgments.
Finally, and as is usually the case, discussions concerning constitutional conflicts over competence are prolonged or become endless, and can never be declared closed, for lack of judicial rulings, which are what should resolve them.
This is a genuine shortcoming which has historically beset this and other sectors in Spain. As regards the problem of the allocation of powers between the State and the Autonomous Communities, the Constitution establishes an order, but this is only achieved after interminable delays and detours which lead to confusion.
It is true that we have some long-standing key judgments of the TC on the allocation of powers in relation to games of chance, but none could have taken account of “lottery terminals” in their possible present-day forms. On the other hand, the more recent judgments on the constitutional position of ONCE or SELAE games, although late, have always been emphatic in favour of State competence. Because they are games, lotteries, of State-wide scope; because their draws are conducted jointly and uniformly throughout the national territory, without exclusion. This is the case of the two judgments of the Supreme Court and the Court of Justice of Extremadura which were the immediate cause of the reports, and which once again maintain ONCE in an “impregnable” position vis-à-vis Autonomous Community law and competence.
From one perspective or another, only a ruling by the TC, through the conflict resolution procedure, would provide a definitive answer. And for that to happen, someone must initiate it once and for all.
We do not know whether the issuing of these reports will have dispelled the doubts raised with the Directorate-General for Gambling, which, like Hamlet and in the meantime, will probably continue to harbour its existential dilemma on this matter.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández
Madrid, 4 April 2017