Gaming & Gambling
STATE-WIDE BINGO, absent from III Forobingo
Carlos Lalanda ·
“Comprehensive offering” “innovation”, “diversification”, “customer incentives”, “more games” ….
Key ideas and mantras repeated at the recent Conference on Bingo held in Logroño on 10 April (III National Bingo Forum)
This Congress addressed the main current issues concerning this important gambling subsector in Spain, with lively debate on the various matters on the table, for which the organisers deserve congratulations.
In my modest opinion, an opportunity was missed to address a matter perhaps forgotten because of the difficulties it entails, but which is surely now feasible and ripe from a business and regulatory perspective. I refer to the possible land-based offering of STATE-WIDE BINGO, consisting of one or more games offered simultaneously in halls in any territory and, naturally, with a prize far higher than that which can normally be offered in halls at present.
There are two possible ways of approaching this objective:
- As an offshoot of state-wide online bingo, with a state licence from the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) and through the authorisation of “terminals” by the Autonomous Communities (CCAA), an approach already being explored by some.
- As an evolution of the products and technologies adapted to physical halls, which have appeared under different names and in different forms: “simultaneous bingo”, “bingo interconnected between halls”, “interconnected electronic bingo, etc.” ….
Although the former were clearly championed and represented in the address by the Director-General for Gambling himself, nothing was said about the latter, and it is to these in particular that I shall refer.
SIMULTANEOUS BINGO, INTERCONNECTED BINGO, ELECTRONIC BINGO …. common to any Autonomous Community
The various formats in which attempts have been made, at different times, to interconnect bingo games across different premises have encountered obvious technological limitations but, above all, regulatory limitations and limitations arising from the allocation of powers, since any new variant or technological type has required the processing and approval of a specific and particular regulation; moreover, it has long been understood that any regulation of this game in its land-based offering falls within the powers of each Autonomous Community in which the premises where it is intended to be operated are physically situated. Thus, each case and new idea has required a great deal of bureaucracy and time. And all of this afresh in each territory………. for a simple game of bingo……….
Sharing a game of bingo across halls in several Autonomous Communities has proved an almost impossible undertaking…. with the sole exception of Electronic Bingo, since, in this variant, it is technologically sufficient for the interconnection system to extend to any hall in an Autonomous Community … or to any other Hall in another Community. In this case, the issue of the allocation of powers has been overcome through the so-called “Cooperation Protocols”, which have currently been signed, for this variant, between the Autonomous Communities of Castilla y León, Aragón, Madrid, Cataluña, La Rioja and Castilla La Mancha.
LAW 13/2011 on Gambling, and Law 20/2013 (LGUM), as applied to these bingo variants.
There is nothing, under the powers of the State, to prevent a bingo variant from being offered in any hall within the national territory. However, within the constraints of the final form of Law 13/2011, it has only been possible, in practice, to authorise its “online” variant (offered directly to users through their personal devices), so that its land-based forms require specific authorisation from the Autonomous Communities.
This online bingo offering is already operating, albeit without any land-based form as yet, and is governed by Order 3087/2011, which is much more flexible than any of the Autonomous Community Regulations. Since 2013, the type has been unrestricted, the minimum stake is 2 euros, and the maximum prize is 150,000 euros. Various operators holding state licences include it in their general gambling offering or their bingo-only offering. The special tax is 25% of winnings or Win, much lower than under most of the Autonomous Community Regulations and variants of this game.
This is what the Director-General for Gambling stated at Forobingo, indicating that the experience at this level is very positive, and may even serve as an example for land-based variants ………
However, he said nothing about a possible “standardisation” of rules on games that could be offered on a land-based basis…. throughout the national territory, or about the fact that these standards could be led by the central administrative body in the exercise of the coordinating powers specifically conferred upon it by the recent Law 20/2013 on the Guarantee of Market Unity (LGUM).
Nor did any of the other contributions raise this possibility.
What is needed is not a Protocol, BUT A COMMON STANDARD THAT ANY AUTONOMOUS COMMUNITY CAN ADOPT.
The Protocols signed by several Autonomous Communities concerning Electronic Bingo offered in halls in several Autonomous Communities are highly commendable and bold agreements, but they have no regulatory force. Even a brief examination reveals that they say nothing about the games, the prizes, or the distribution among the various Autonomous Communities of the tax revenue generated by this game. They even refer back to each signatory Community's own regulations on the presumption that the rules and techniques governing the games or the operation of such bingo variants are identical or, at least, mutually compatible. They thereby “authorise” the holding of “common” games or games with a “common pool”, which is ultimately the objective of these variants, without adding anything new to the respective regulations.
Under the scheme I propose, the powers of the Autonomous Communities are not encroached upon. The state body simply draws up and approves a “common standard” in the exercise of its coordinating powers, and each Autonomous Community then decides, in the exercise of its own powers, whether or not to “adhere” to it and, if it does, to incorporate it into its own list of possible offerings in the bingo halls of its own Autonomous Community.
This is now feasible as one of the approaches outlined by the judgments interpreting the LGUM, and can also be substantively included in the lines of work pursued by the cooperation bodies.
The recent amendment of the operating rules of the Gambling Policy Council, on the pretext of bringing them into line with the provisions of Law 40/2015 on the Legal Regime of the Public Sector, allows Agreements of this nature to be adopted (approval of common rules or standards on gambling), on the basis of content prepared by Working Groups in cooperation with, or at the proposal of, the various Autonomous Communities, with limited and voluntary effect for those Autonomous Communities that adhere to them.
POSSIBLE CONTENT of these “COMMON STANDARDS” concerning land-based bingo extending beyond a single Autonomous Community.
These “standards” or “common technical rules” may concern various aspects, without diminishing, but rather enhancing, the intervention of the respective Autonomous Communities in their respective territories:
- As regards the mechanics of the game of bingo, certain minimum conditions could be envisaged, in line with those currently applicable to “online bingo”: setting a minimum stake and a maximum prize.
- On strictly technical matters, the establishment of the technical specifications for the platforms, devices, software, etc. necessary to implement a form of bingo game distributed across any hall in the National territory. It cannot be ruled out that this standardisation might lead to a “single type approval” by the Directorate-General for Gambling of the Ministry of Finance.
- On authorisation matters. There can be no question of a “state administrative authorisation” (that is, for the entire national territory), since this bingo variant neither depends on “state Regulations” nor would it supersede the exclusive powers of the Autonomous Communities. Thus, depending on the variant, name and type of Bingo concerned (Interconnected, Electronic, etc.), the adoption by an Autonomous Community of a Common Technical Rule approved by the Gambling Policy Council…. would be sufficient to include this possible state-wide bingo game in its respective legal system ……
If it is true that bingo hall operators are convinced by the words heard in Logroño.
If it is true that technology has already reached a sufficient stage of development.
If it is true that the Autonomous Communities are determined to facilitate new offerings in the Halls within their territory,
The way is open ……
Madrid, 17 May 2018.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.