Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the Supreme Court, Administrative Division (Third Section), of 16 June 2017

·


The Judgment of the Supreme Court
(Third Division, Third Section) of 16 June 2017 dismisses the appeal in cassation brought by the Organización Impulsora de discapacitados (O.I.D.) against the judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid which upheld the refusal by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling of the Ministry of Finance to grant authorisation to hold various nationwide lottery draws. The applicability of Law 13/2011 on gambling, and in particular its provisions reserving the operation of lotteries of this scope to SELAE and ONCE, is beyond doubt, and its validity has been examined in several judgments refusing this authorisation, including from the perspective of EU rules and the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), such that “games of chance have not yet been harmonised and therefore Member States may not only set the objectives of their policy in this area, but may also establish the degree of protection they deem necessary, even restricting the freedom to provide services on grounds of protection of the general interest, subject only to the limitation that such restrictions must be proportionate and consistent with the purpose they seek to achieve”.

On this premise, and following an analysis of various CJEU judgments, such as that in the “Schindler” case and subsequent judgments, the Supreme Court once again declares the validity of the reservation in favour of SELAE and ONCE under the Gambling Law.

It also examines the possibility of unequal treatment of OID in comparison with ONCE, as alleged by the appellant, but clearly establishes the distinctions between the two, the latter being a public entity and the appellant a private entity; and because the economic or financial controls and the allocation of the funds obtained are very different in the two cases.

More publications