Gaming & Gambling
The Supreme Court Changes Everything (Nelson Rose)
·
Article by Nelson Rose on the recent judgment of the United States Supreme Court of 14 May 2018 concerning the legality of sports betting in the United States.
(Authorised translation. Loyra Abogados)
\» Last year, I wrote a blog post about the then pending sports betting case, entitled “The Most Important Case of the Century. “The most important case of the century”
It has become even bigger than that.
In the coming days and weeks, I shall analyse in detail the major changes it entails. Here I provide a summary of what happened and why, and the questions that remain unanswered.
For most of my readers, the most significant finding is that States are now free to legalise sports betting, or any form of gambling they wish.
But my view goes much further. For the first time in American history, the United States Supreme Court expressly declares that the Federal Government cannot order States, or State officials, to do anything.
The Federal Government still has enormous power. But Congress, the Federal Courts, administrative agencies and even the President can only take legal action against individuals, not against local governments. – And the Federal Government has only those powers granted to it in the United States Constitution.
During the American Revolution, 13 colonies won their independence from the King of England. They were then independent “sovereign” nations, with unlimited powers within their borders. But they realised that they could not survive militarily against the great powers of the time, England, France and Spain, and therefore created a federation for common defence. When they created the Federal Government, the States surrendered some, but not all, of their powers.
The United States has a Government of “enumerated powers”, which means that, if any power is not provided for in the Constitution, it remains with the States. As Justice Alito says, “…the power to issue direct orders to State Governments is clearly absent from the list of powers granted to Congress ….”.
The problem arose because Congress passed a ridiculous Act (the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA), which prevented any State from legalising any form of sports betting if it had not already done so before 1991. Nevada and a dozen other States had some form of sports betting, including lottery outlets, betting at pelota courts and so-called “Calcutta auctions” (a kind of ascending-bid betting on particular sportspeople or teams), all of which could continue to be offered. But they remained frozen in the other States
Imagine an Act passed in 1928 declaring it an offence to offer talking films, but exempting those States where they were already showing still pictures with sound. Regardless of technological changes, only a few States could show talking films.
For its part, the State of New Jersey passed a ridiculous Act in an attempt to “circumvent” PASPA, the ridiculous federal statute. PASPA prohibited States from “authorising” sports betting, and the State Legislature passed a strange bill that repealed the criminal laws against such betting. There were some restrictions, such as requiring betting to take place at racecourses or casinos. But the State Legislature deliberately did not “authorise” sports betting, but merely “decriminalised” it. Thus, accepting bets on sporting events was now legal but unregulated, even if the betting premises were opened by the Mafia.
The clash between these two ridiculous laws produced one of the most ridiculous judicial decisions of all time. The Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit held that PASPA was not only constitutional, but also prevented the State of New Jersey from changing its criminal laws. In other words, the Federal Government could compel the State to retain a criminal offence, even when the voters and the State Legislature had decided otherwise, to permit the conduct.
As I have written many times, PASPA was the first Federal Act in history to interfere extensively with the right of States to establish their own gambling policies. I thought that the Supreme Court could limit the scope of the Federal Government’s activities, but only where matters of State police power were concerned. Police power is the almost unlimited right of States to protect the health, safety, welfare and morals of their residents. But police powers are normally confined to areas such as fires, diseases and gambling.
The Supreme Court interprets Congress’s order that New Jersey could not change its sports betting laws as acting as though there were a police officer in the State Legislature compelling the State to pass only those laws that the Federal Government wanted. And it does not confine its interpretation solely to matters of State police power.
In subsequent blog posts, I shall analyse what this means for other pressing issues of our time, including marijuana and immigration (a clarification: the State Attorney General cannot order State officials to do anything in relation to marijuana, and President Trump cannot order the enforcement of State laws to conduct raids on illegal aliens.
For now ….. what does this decision mean for the gambling industry?
Winners.
Obviously, New Jersey and other States that have casinos and racecourses and have not yet introduced sports betting will be able to attract more bettors and tourists. Delaware, for example, has betting premises with gambling machines, but lost a case under PASPA limiting betting in the State to betting premises.
Delaware is therefore in the best position to be the first State, apart from Nevada, to introduce sports betting
Some Indian tribes will be big winners. Some tribes have entered into State agreements to pay the State hundreds of millions of dollars, but only if they do not permit new Class III games. The Indian Gaming Regulatory Act classifies all games into three Classes. Class III comprises casinos, lotteries, pari-mutuel betting and sports betting. Consequently, some States will face the choice of granting them a monopoly over sports betting or facing the loss of a large amount of revenue. Even with a monopoly, tribes that are far from population centres will approach their States to approve the offering of betting by mobile phone or personal computer.
Although the professional and federated sports leagues fought this case all the way to the Supreme Court, they are, for the time being, big winners. Even if their proposal to receive 1% of betting turnover is not accepted (the so-called “integrity fee”, which I shall analyse in the future and have already discussed), the leagues and teams will benefit from a major boost in interest in any sport on which bets can be placed. This extends to the broadcast media, which will also be more inclined to increase advertising airtime.
Betting operators in other countries will benefit from the increased interest in sports betting. Canadians have been betting on the Kentucky Derby for decades, and one night, some time ago, I personally observed bets being taken at the Hollywood Park poker club on races taking place in Hong Kong. The “Federal Wire Act” (the Federal “Wire” Act) does not permit such cross-border betting on races or sporting events, but nobody cared. It is doubtful that Attorney General Sessions will be as lax in enforcing the “Wire” Act’s prohibitions against interstate or international betting on National Football League games.
Politicians and lobbyists will be big winners, especially at State level. The NFL is pushing for national regulation. But gambling has always been a matter for the States, because Nevada and Utah may share a border yet have completely divergent views. And this Congress will never pass substantive laws.
Internet poker will “boom”. The Department of Justice under Obama and the Federal Courts took the view that the Wire Act applied only to betting on sporting events and races. But all States, apart from Nevada, Delaware and N. Jersey, have been slow to recognise that all other forms of gambling, with minimal and creative legal development, can be made available to bettors in different States and nations. Once regulators realise that the “door is wide”, they will seek to have more online gambling authorised and taxed.
Losers
Nevada’s casinos, especially its largest betting operator, Caesars, will continue to do well for years. It will take months, and in some cases years, to pass new State laws and regulations. Meanwhile, more and more people will hear about the “new wave” of legalisation. It will be easy for Las Vegas to capitalise on this growing interest in betting on sporting events.
Eventually, Nevada will be harmed by competition across the nation. Why drive for 5 hours to place a bet if a local betting establishment is in the building downstairs, or available by telephone or PC.
Fantasy sports are taking a hard hit. They never took off in Europe, because they are actually sports betting.
Illegal betting premises may see their business increase in States that have not yet legalised the activity. Illegal operators do not have to pay State fees or taxes, although the cleverest are paying Federal Excise Taxes (excise duties). They can offer credit more easily. But I think legal premises will prevail, assuming they do not have to devote all their profits to an “integrity fee” for the leagues. Legal premises will be willing to cut their expenses when they have the right to take bets via PCs. They will also be able to advertise, including on television and online. Some big bettors may resist, maintaining their relationship with “offshore” operators that will not report their winnings to the IRS. But most bettors will prefer licensed operators, knowing that they will actually be paid.
Many questions remain
Which States will be first? My bet is Delaware, since sports betting had to be suspended only because the Federal Courts said that it was limited to betting premises under the now discredited PASPA. But other States, including New Jersey, Pennsylvania and West Virginia, have passed new laws making sports betting legal if the Supreme Court ruled as it has.
Who will obtain a licence? Some States are looking to their State lottery operators, which also operate games. But most will opt for a licensing system. The problem is political; there is so much legal gambling that one more form is not a major issue. But there is so much legal gambling that almost every State has powerful local operators. If these operators, for example horse racing and casino operators in New Jersey, now acquire the right to take sports bets, the legislation would support it. But in a State such as California, Indian tribes with gambling operations, card clubs and horse racing proprietors will have the political power to defeat a proposal they dislike; although they will not have sufficient influence to secure the passage of one that curtails their competitors.
Will Congress do anything? The NFL would love to see national regulations and a substantial share of betting go to the professional leagues. This is not going to happen, mainly because at least three States already have regulated legal gambling. But Congress could amend the Wire Act to permit interstate and international sports betting. Unfortunately, this will not happen either, because Congress has stopped passing substantive laws. This could change if the Democrats win both the House and the Senate in November 2018.
Can the other “Political Territories” have sports betting? The most important of these is Puerto Rico, with 3.4 million residents. But the US Virgin Islands and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands have casinos and might wish to take sports bets over the Internet from the rest of the world. The legal issues are thorny, because the Supreme Court focused its decision on “State sovereignty”. But there are precedents and good arguments for accepting that the Territories should be treated as States, especially where issues such as pre-emption and constitutional rights are involved.
Are there legal mechanisms that provide for the offering of sports betting? Beyond some State/Indian tribal agreements, which sometimes grant monopolies to tribes, some casinos have contracts with the NFL. Federal taxes were reduced years ago for sports betting premises, but there are also issues concerning the existence of State taxes and fees.
Most State Constitutions do not prohibit “gambling”, only “lotteries”. But some State courts and lawyers have declared that all forms of gambling fall within lotteries. The first question here is who decides what a “lottery” is, and whether the Supreme Court of each State will transfer to that State’s legislators the power to define whether betting in the State constitutes “lotteries”.
Will the sports leagues succeed in obtaining the so-called “integrity fee”? Teams have rights over their games, but do not have rights over the statistics generated by their games. Facts cannot be copyrighted. As matters stand, the leagues have no real bargaining power, because they have nothing to sell. Even so, it would be a good idea to have the teams as active partners on matters such as standardising the timing of the announcement of results and, yes, increasing integrity.
Is there any way around the Wire Act?. Even before the Supreme Court’s announcement, operators were devising schemes to allow sports betting across State borders. This includes the so-called “risk management” of bets. It could be regarded as a direct challenge to the Wire Act, because it was designed to help States enforce their public policies. It should not apply to State sports betting.
Unexpected consequences. Are eSports sports?. Until a few weeks ago, advocates of eSports were urging States to legalise them as a sport. Nevada did so, and limited betting to in-person pari-mutuel betting. But now advocates could argue that eSports are not sports, whereas the Wire Act provides for cross-border betting on sporting events.
Conclusion
By early 2020, we shall have more than a dozen States with legal sports betting. We may not see many bills to legalise sports betting become law before November 2018: it is late in the current legislative session and also an election year. But after the November elections, there will be an opening of legislative sessions of State regulators looking for ways to raise more revenue through less painful means.
One question that the Supreme Court will have to resolve is “can sports betting be offered by telephone or over the Internet?…\»
© Copyright 2018, I. Nelson Rose, Encino, California. All rights reserved worldwide. GAMBLING AND THE LAW® is a registered trademark of Professor I. Nelson Rose, www.GAMBLINGANDTHELAW.com.