Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the Supreme Court (Civil Chamber), of 17 May 2017

·


The Judgment of the Supreme Court
(First Civil Chamber) of 17 May 2017 determines the appeal in cassation in a case in which CODERE sought a declaration of unfair competition by Pokerstars through its offering of online gambling to the Spanish public before subsequently obtaining its licence under Gambling Law 13/2011; and consequently sought damages. The Supreme Court reverses the Provincial Court's decision and declares that there was unfair competition, but refuses to award damages.

To do so, the Court has required an extensive and partly contradictory interpretation of the grounds on which the Unfair Competition Law should apply to the case.

First, because Article 15.2 of that Law specifies that the mere infringement of legal rules intended to regulate competitive activity shall be regarded as unfair, whereas paragraph 1 of that article also requires a significant competitive advantage to be demonstrated. Turning specifically to online gambling activity, the Supreme Court corrects the Provincial Court, which invoked a “lack of enforceability” of the rules preceding Law 1372011, which made any form of gambling, including online gambling, subject to prior authorisation. These rules, namely Royal Decree-Law 16/1977, Royal Decree 444/1977 and, above all, Final Provision 14 of Law 42/2006, “meet the requirements of mandatory force, general applicability and enforceability necessary for their infringement to constitute the unfair conduct referred to in Article 15 of the Unfair Competition Law” (Legal Ground 11).

However, in a rhetorical pirouette, the Supreme Court determines on this first point that CODERE did not suffer any disadvantage, since, according to the Court, it could have circumvented strict compliance with that prohibition owing to the widespread tolerance of the Public Administrations. Rather, CODERE did not enter online operations because of its own choice of more traditional lines of business (Legal Ground 15).

Secondly, Articles 21.1.c and 23.1 of that Unfair Competition Law are examined, insofar as Pokerstars' practices could be considered misleading by suggesting that they were authorised in Spain. Not only were those activities unauthorised “only in Spain”, as the Provincial Court maintained; the Supreme Court goes further and considers that they were prohibited, and this is the crux of the matter, since in that case the conduct is misleading and no longer requires a competitive advantage as in the previous case; nor can the supposed “authorisation” be justified by that granted to Pokerstars in the Isle of Man, because that island did not fall within the scope of the EU Treaty for the purposes of the freedom to provide services.

Lastly, the damages sought are not awarded because, although in cases under Article 15 the direct purpose is to protect the maintenance of a market operating on the basis of competition through efficiency rather than illegality, in the case of Articles 21 and 23, which are those found to have been infringed, the interest protected is that of consumers, who must receive non-misleading information that complies with legal requirements.

More publications