Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the Supreme Court (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Section 3), of 12 June 2018
·
The Judgment of the Supreme Court (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Section 3), of 12 June 2018 dismisses the appeal on points of law against the judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid which upheld the validity of the amendment made to the Madrid Casino Regulations, introducing the regime for the so-called “Annex Rooms” of gambling casinos”, which may be opened on premises other than those of the casinos originally authorised through a competitive tender procedure and in distant locations, even in different towns. In turn, the appeal also challenged the authorisation granted on the basis of that regulatory amendment to one of the successful tenderers for the opening of one of these Rooms.
The judgment under appeal, of 1 March 2016, had already stated that the regulatory amendment and the resulting individual authorisation complied with the law, including the enabling Autonomous Community legislation, the Madrid Gambling Law; that being so, and since an infringement of Autonomous Community law could not be pleaded in these proceedings on appeal on points of law, the appellant could only raise issues of a constitutional nature and, in that event, the rules governing the referral of a question of constitutionality to the Constitutional Court (TC).
The Supreme Court reiterates that judicial bodies are not obliged to refer such a question and that the lower court duly justified its refusal to do so on the grounds that it considered there to be no prima facie indication of the alleged constitutional infringement.
There is another judgment to the same effect delivered by the Supreme Court on 20 June 2018.