Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the Supreme Court (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Third Section), of 12 June 2018
·
The Judgment of the Supreme Court (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Third Section), of 12 June 2018 reaffirms the refusal of authorisation for a bingo hall in the Canary Islands, applied for on 16 December 2005 and initially refused because the competent administration of the Autonomous Community of the Canary Islands considered that, given the large number of applications submitted at that time, a competitive tendering procedure had to be conducted for its award. The subsequent tendering procedure was declared unsuccessful because none of the bidders met the requirements for authorisation.
There were numerous procedural and factual vicissitudes prior to this judgment, as the High Court of Justice in Las Palmas initially delivered a judgment allowing the appeal; however, after that judgment had been set aside on procedural grounds, the case passed to the jurisdiction of the Court in Santa Cruz de Tenerife, which, by contrast, dismissed the appeal.
On this occasion, the Supreme Court concludes by definitively dismissing the appeal, since, in its view and ultimately, the appellant was excluded from the tendering procedure for failing to meet one of the requirements for holding the authorisation, nor can the authorisation be recognised under the doctrine of administrative silence.