Gaming & Gambling

Supreme Court Judgment (Third Chamber, Fifth Section) of 13 June 2017

·


The Supreme Court Judgment
(Third Chamber, Fifth Section) of 13 June 2017 examines various issues concerning the liability in damages of the Administration of the Valencian Community for having granted an authorisation to a bingo hall when, according to a subsequent judgment, it should not have done so under the statutory and regulatory criteria governing authorisations, thereby causing financial harm to a hall near the one improperly authorised. Both the judgment on appeal in cassation and the judgment of the lower court agree that the conditions for establishing liability in damages towards the proprietor of the affected establishment are met, since the declaration of nullity establishes the requisite elements of damage (loss of revenue at the hall over several financial years, according to the evidence submitted), a causal link between the proven damage and the improper authorisation and opening of the second hall, owing to their close proximity to one another; and unlawfulness, as the second authorisation was granted in breach of certain statutory and regulatory requirements, as determined in an initial court judgment.

However, the amount of compensation must be maintained in accordance with the approach taken by the lower court, which referred to the financial years in which revenue actually decreased, taking into account an adjustment factor consisting of the average decrease in revenue at bingo establishments in the province of Valencia during the financial years covered by the claim. Accordingly, compensation is payable only for certain financial years and subject to these adjustments.

More publications