Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the Supreme Court (Third Chamber, Second Section), of 7 March 2017
·
The Judgment of the Supreme Court (Third Chamber, Second Section), of 7 March 2017 upholds the judgment of the National High Court declaring valid the Tax Inspection Report of Disagreement concerning Gambling Tax, in the raffles category, drawn up in relation to the activity conducted through the television channel “Cuatro”, consisting of draws or competitions involving premium-rate telephone calls, which in some cases had been the subject of attempted regularisation under the category of random prize draws. The Supreme Court reiterates the concept of a raffle and, in particular, the circumstances in which the taxable event occurs when these activities are conducted, and its distinction from a random prize draw, which is a draw that is free of charge for customers purchasing a product or service. The fact that the assessing body (Loterías y Apuestas del Estado) had initially classified it and assessed it as a random prize draw cannot be relied upon under the doctrine of consistency with prior conduct, since this was a provisional assessment which may be amended when new facts emerge that were not taken into account at the time. As in the judgment under appeal, the Supreme Court accepts that the status of taxable person for this Tax does not attach to the television channel, but to the entity organising the games, and that this liability may only be attributed to the channel where it jointly organises these competitions and raffles.