Regulatory & Compliance

Judgment of the Supreme Court (Third Chamber; Third Section), of 23 May 2017

·


The Judgment of the Supreme Court
(Third Chamber, Third Section), of 23 May 2017 upholds the position of the National High Court on several matters concerning the legal regime governing Lottery Agencies which retain, on a transitional and exceptional basis, an administrative concession regime under SELAE as a consequence of the new regulation of this relationship under commercial law, established by Additional Provision 34 of Law 26/2009. The association APLA argued that the holders of those Agencies (which are now residual, the majority having opted for the commercial law regime) should retain the right to transfer ownership inter vivos and mortis causa pursuant to Articles 13 and 14 of Royal Decree 1082/1985; and the right to relocate the Agency within the same municipality or to another municipality, subject to prior authorisation from SELAE; and, furthermore, to obtain compensation for the removal of “exclusivity” in the sale of lottery tickets.

Both the National High Court and the Supreme Court maintain that there is no right to transfer the concession under administrative law, since the transitional retention of the administrative law regime is granted only to the current holder, until their death, retirement, relinquishment or cessation, and the current holder may only propose a new holder, who will, however, be governed by commercial law through the contract entered into with SELAE. This reiterates the judgments of the National High Court under appeal and other earlier judgments which so held. The same criterion must apply to transfers mortis causa, in which SELAE has the power to decide whether the successor under civil law meets the legal requirements for recognition of their appointment, under a contract and appointment.

The same applies to the right of relocation, which must be subject to the same criteria as those imposed on Points of Sale operating under commercial law, namely that the new location must represent a significant improvement in the commercial site, with other circumstances being assessed where there are competing applications.

As regards the right to compensation for the loss of exclusivity in the sale of lottery tickets previously enjoyed by the former Lottery Agencies, this loss is not compensable, since it is an abstract matter which cannot be upheld outside the procedural channels for the liability of Public Authorities.

More publications