Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the Supreme Court (Third Chamber, Third Section), of 27 July 2017
·
The Judgment of the Supreme Court (Third Chamber, Third Section), of 27 July 2017, determines an appeal in cassation brought by the State Counsel against the judgment of the High Court of Justice (TSJ) of the Valencian Community which upheld the validity of Article 14 of Autonomous Community Decree 55/2011 approving the General Regulations on the Advertising of Games of Chance); consequently, the right of gambling companies authorised by the Valencian Community to advertise through Internet pages without prior authorisation, and also to insert banners and links to those pages subject to prior authorisation, would be valid and lawful.
The appellant State Counsel argued that this provision encroached upon State powers in the field of telecommunications and, by its very nature, all regulation of commercial promotion over the Internet.
The issue appears to have been partly misconceived from the outset, since, if the State considered that there had been an encroachment upon its powers, it is difficult to understand why the action brought was an application for judicial review before the ordinary courts rather than a dispute over powers before the Constitutional Court (TC), since both the TSJ of the Valencian Community and the Supreme Court (TS), while agreeing in rejecting the application for annulment, remain initial, but not final, instances in the interpretation of the Spanish Constitution (CE) and the distribution of powers.
This particular article of the Decree was subsequently substantially amended by Decree 26/2012 of the Valencian Community, narrowing the scope of the operator’s right to advertise on the Internet to its own website alone (and not on any other); moreover, Decree 55/2011 was repealed by a subsequent decree, Decree 190/2014, which reproduces the amended article in identical terms. Accordingly, from a procedural perspective, the challenge may be said to have become devoid of purpose.
Both at first instance and in cassation, the analysis of this issue, which is properly constitutional in nature, is not very thorough, but rather superficial, although at least the Supreme Court’s judgment examines various matters which had been described rather confusingly in the TSJ’s judgment and which are of considerable interest. For example, the Supreme Court examines several matters relating to the limits of the powers of the Autonomous Communities in relation to games of chance, and concludes that the exclusive power to grant authorisations of a territorial nature extends to their advertising regime, including through non-physical media such as the Internet, declaring that any company authorised in the Valencian Community may advertise on the Internet even though this medium is universal by nature, meaning that the message may be read and received by persons not located within its territory.
On this basic premise, this general authorisation does not affect State powers:
The power over telecommunications had been invoked only very briefly by the State Counsel in the appeal, because the contested Decree does not regulate the actual operation of gambling on the Internet, but rather the advertising of gambling authorised in the Valencian Community; consequently, these are the powers that should be examined in order to reach an interpretative decision:
– Powers over gambling belong exclusively to the Valencian Community, and it is implicitly assumed that the advertising regulated by the Decree does not exceed the territorial scope of those powers, even though the advertising may be viewed universally, that is, outside the Valencian Community.
– The power over advertising (of gambling) must follow the Autonomous Community’s regulatory power over gambling, since recourse cannot be had to the State power under the Gambling Law, Law 13/2011, Article 7.1, either. This article does not apply to gambling falling within the exclusive powers of the Autonomous Community, namely gambling conducted exclusively within the territory of the Autonomous Community …. \»as is the case\» (verbatim).
Finally, there is no infringement of the principle of market unity either, since the Valencian Community’s regulation of gambling has no effects beyond the territorial boundaries of the Valencian Community, which is its sole scope in accordance with its exclusive power.
As we have previously commented, this judgment has no substantive effect whatsoever, since the contested article had been substantially amended by a subsequent provision and ultimately definitively repealed by a new one.