Gaming & Gambling
Order of the Supreme Court of 16 January 2019 (Administrative Chamber, First Section)
·
The Order of the Supreme Court of 16 January 2019 (Administrative Chamber, First Section) grants leave for an appeal in cassation against a recent judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid examining the tax implications of the clandestine activity carried out by an entity supporting another entity engaged in illegal sports betting in Spain, before Law 13/2011.
Such are the consequences of the slowness of the Spanish judicial system. Ghosts from the past, which we thought forgotten, revive facts and cases on which we already had occasion to comment from the tax perspectives prevailing at the time: the case of companies illegally operating betting and gambling through “.com” websites which had “forgotten” to pay the Gambling Tax Levy, in the period preceding the Gambling Law of 2011.
This matter remains alive and is now awaiting the final judgment on the appeal in cassation, as the aforementioned Order reminds us.
- The litigation that has been revived
Long before 2011, one of the entities offering illegal sports betting in Spain needed an operational unit within the territory to centralise all promotion, advertising and marketing activities. If the media were hungry for advertising revenue, even from prohibited activities, dealings and contracts with them were necessary. It was a case of “hunger meeting the desire to eat”.
However, beyond assisting the activity it served (which at that time was unlawful under the laws then in force), it should at least have paid tax in accordance with the general tax rules.
The judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid of 17 July 2018 upheld the tax inspection assessment issued in 2012 in respect of VAT, the amount of which the company “forgot” to include in the invoices issued (and subsequently pay to the Treasury) for services provided to a Gibraltar company, under the same parent company, which operated illegal betting on the Internet during the financial years 2008 to 2011.
Back in 2012, this avoidance must have seemed a cruel joke to the Spanish tax authorities, which issued the assessment.
The amount of tax “forgotten” in this case in respect of VAT totalled €919,370.36, and they could count themselves “fortunate”, since the amount for the 2007 financial year, also included in the initial assessment, was annulled by the Regional Economic-Administrative Tribunal (TEAR) as it was time-barred.
The services provided are detailed in the judgment and consisted of all manner of marketing and intermediary activities on behalf of the Gibraltar betting company to advertise its brand and illegal website in Spain, all of which were transactions that, had the Law been strictly applied, would have resulted in the imposition of penalties, since at that time advertising these websites was unlawful, just as advertising unauthorised websites is today.
Nevertheless, the services were provided (or provided to themselves, since both companies were owned by the parent company); the provider (an apparently lawful entity) was in Barcelona, Spain, and the recipient (the clearly unlawful one) was in Gibraltar. And the services were subject to VAT, just like any other supply of services of this nature, for the conduct of a business with end recipients in Spain, namely Spanish bettors, even though doing so was illegal (Articles 69.One and 70.2 of the VAT Law (LIVA)).
Those subject to the inspection argued that, since the recipient was in Gibraltar, the transaction fell outside the scope of VAT, as though this were a licence to act with impunity, when ultimately the advertising services were provided in Spain, with a clear purpose: to promote betting by Spaniards. A monumental transfer of funds from Spanish bettors to Gibraltar companies.
Sponsorship agreements were entered into with Barcelona or Real Madrid, advertising contracts were negotiated with celebrities who would display the betting company's brand, advertising accounts were arranged with Spanish newspapers, Spanish players promoting its image were attended to, etc.
The issuing of invoices in these cases (between companies within the same group) usually serves one purpose: to balance the subsidiary's “internal” expenditure with sufficient income to bring the accounts to “0”, in other words, to cover expenses, so that the value of the consideration is usually artificial and is usually adjusted by the tax inspectors using the “related-party transaction” technique. In this case, this increased its nominal value by only 5% on that basis. Supplies that may or may not have been fictitious, relating to activities that may or may not have been lawful, but certainly subject to VAT. This is what follows from the judgment of the High Court of Justice of Madrid.
-The appeal
The matter still rumbles on. The Supreme Court has granted leave for the appeal in cassation, so that almost 6 years after the fraud was discovered, the litigation continues, with the appellants intending to take the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Curious, since Gibraltar companies will no longer enjoy the protection of the Court of Justice of the EU from 29 March.