Tax & Private Clients

Order of the Supreme Court (Administrative Chamber, First Section), of 21 December 2017

·


The Order of the Supreme Court (Administrative Chamber, First Section), of 21 December 2017. admits the appeal in cassation brought by the State Legal Service against the judgment of the High Court of Justice (TSJ) of the Valencian Community reiterating its tax case law concerning the VAT exemption for services relating to the operation of gaming machines in third-party hospitality establishments, which it considers in most cases to constitute partnership agreements that do not entail the provision of services between the parties.

This interpretation constitutes the settled case law of this Valencian territorial court, in contradiction with the majority of the Chambers of other High Courts of Justice, which consider, in accordance with an initial interpretation established by the Spanish Tax Agency (AEAT) following a consultation, that the third-party proprietors of the hospitality premises in which these machines are operated in fact provide services of various kinds and descriptions to the operating company that owns the machines, such that these activities are subject to the general VAT regime.

The judgment under appeal recognises the right to a refund of the input VAT borne by an operating company in respect of the VAT charged by the proprietor of the establishment on its invoice issued for the provision of these services, which the TSJ declares improper, in accordance with its historically maintained position.

The appellant is the State Counsel acting as representative of the A.E.A.T, relying on the other conflicting judicial decisions, meaning that this is an appeal equivalent to an appeal for the unification of case law. The Supreme Court considers that the matter is of objective interest for the purposes of cassation and that the judgment to be delivered must address the following questions:

1.) To determine whether, where an agreement classifiable as a partnership or joint operation agreement has been entered into between a business proprietor of a hospitality establishment and a business owner of type «B» gaming machines, there is a supply of services by the former to the latter which is subject to Value Added Tax and cannot be regarded as exempt under Article 20.One.19 of Law 37/1992, of 28 December, on Value Added Tax.

2º) To identify as legal provisions which will, in principle, be subject to interpretation Article 20.One.19 of Law 37/1992, of 28 December, on Value Added Tax, in conjunction with Article 3 of Royal Decree-Law 16/1977, of 25 February, regulating the criminal, administrative and tax aspects of games of luck, wagering or chance and betting, and Articles 14 and 17.4 (now Article 17.5) of Law 58/2003, of 17 December, the General Tax Law).

This Order has been reiterated in many other similar cases originating from the same TSJ of the Valencian Community (Orders of 15-1-2028 (4), 17-1-2018, 18-1-2018, 29-1-2018, 14-2-2018, and 26-2-2018)

More publications