Gaming & Gambling

Supreme Court (Third Chamber) Judgment of 20 April 2017

·


The Supreme Court Judgment
(Third Chamber, Third Section) of 20 April 2017 examines the extent of State competence to authorise a lottery activity such as that of the O.I.D., which extends throughout the national territory, and not merely to a single Autonomous Community. The case on appeal in cassation arises from the judgment delivered by the High Court of Justice of the Canary Islands, which held that the Autonomous Administration lacked competence to grant or refuse (as it had in practice done) the application submitted by that organisation, which covered marketing both through physical tickets and through the website. The regional court's judgment, upheld by the Supreme Court, recognised that the actual conduct of those draws through the online channel clearly falls within the nationwide sphere and that, therefore, rather than refusing the application, it should have ordered its referral to the appropriate State body.

The judgment reviews the state of the matter and the case law at various levels concerning the territorial scope of games of chance in relation to online operations. It thus recalls the broad terms of State competence established under Law 13/2011, curtailed in part by the successive Constitutional Court (TC) Judgments 35/2012 and 83/2012, which partially annulled the statutory provision establishing automatic State competence where a particular game extended beyond the territory of a single Autonomous Community; it must be determined in each case whether this supraterritorial scope reaches the “State” level (in which case the State is competent), or concerns only certain specific Autonomous Communities (in which case those Communities are competent through the constitutional mechanisms of “cooperation”).

As the case concerns an O.I.D. lottery draw, the Supreme Court reviews the regional case law from Cantabria and Castile and León, which served to establish the refusal of authorisation for this draw on the grounds of its “nationwide intent”, which is also the situation in the Canary Islands case.

It also, however, delves into the delineation of online games (for which the O.I.D. also sought authorisation). In this case, the approach taken by the Supreme Court is that, since these are games without a defined territorial scope, which even extends beyond national borders, “there is no doubt that authorisation for these games for entities wishing to operate from Spain must be granted by the State”. In another paragraph, it also considers that it might be possible to establish technical mechanisms allowing only those located in a particular Autonomous Community to access the game (which is not the case in the Canary Islands), hence the reference elsewhere in the judgment to Article 2(2)(b) of Law 13/2011, which sets out one of the matters excluded from the application of the Law: gambling activities conducted through telematic, electronic or interactive means whose scope is not nationwide.

More publications